No, the blackening of cheese does not necessarily mean it is aged. While some aged cheeses develop dark or black rinds, blackening can also result from mold growth, oxidation, or even a harmless wax or ash coating, and it is not a reliable indicator of age or quality.
Why Cheese Rinds Turn Black
Cheese rinds form naturally as the exterior of the wheel dries and interacts with the environment during aging. The color of a rind depends on the specific microbes, treatments, and conditions used. Blackening can come from several distinct sources:
- Ash coating: Some cheeses, like Morbier or certain goat cheeses, are intentionally rolled in vegetable ash (usually activated charcoal) to create a black layer that helps regulate moisture and encourage specific mold growth.
- Mold growth: Certain molds, such as Mucor or Rhizopus, produce dark gray or black patches on the rind. These are often part of the aging process and are safe, though they may look alarming.
- Oxidation: Exposure to oxygen can cause the surface of some cheeses to darken, especially if the cheese is cut or the rind is damaged.
- Wax or paint: Some cheeses are coated with black wax or a dark food-grade paint to protect them during aging, as seen with certain aged Gouda wheels.
None of these factors directly correlate with the length of aging. A young cheese can have a black rind (like ash-coated fresh goat cheese), and an aged cheese can have a pale or orange rind (like aged Cheddar).
How Aging Actually Works
Aging, also called affinage, is the controlled process of storing cheese under specific temperature, humidity, and airflow conditions to develop flavor, texture, and aroma. During aging, enzymes and microbes break down fats and proteins, creating new compounds. The rind is a byproduct of this process—it forms as the surface dries and becomes colonized by beneficial molds and bacteria.
The color of the rind is determined by the specific microflora that the affineur encourages. For example:
- Brie and Camembert develop a white bloomy rind from Penicillium camemberti.
- Washed-rind cheeses like Époisses are brushed with brine or alcohol, promoting orange Brevibacterium linens bacteria.
- Natural-rind cheeses like aged Gouda or Parmigiano-Reggiano develop a hard, often brown or gray-brown rind without added coatings.
Black rinds are less common but appear in cheeses like Sottocenere (which has a black ash rind) or certain alpine styles where the rind is treated with ash or dark molds. The aging duration can range from a few weeks to several years, but the rind color alone doesn’t tell you how long the cheese has been aged.
How to Tell If a Black Rind Is Safe to Eat
Not all blackening is safe. Here’s how to distinguish between safe rind and spoilage:
- Check for fuzziness: Dry, hard, or slightly wrinkled black rinds are usually fine. Fuzzy, slimy, or wet black patches may indicate unwanted mold or bacterial growth.
- Smell: A strong ammonia or putrid odor suggests spoilage, while a earthy, mushroomy, or nutty smell is typical for aged cheese.
- Look for cracks: Deep cracks in the rind can harbor harmful bacteria, especially if the cheese has been stored improperly.
- When in doubt, cut it off: For hard cheeses, you can safely trim off the rind and the cheese underneath is usually fine. For soft cheeses, discard the entire cheese if the rind shows signs of spoilage.
If you bought a cheese with an intentionally black rind (like ash-coated), the rind is edible but may be bitter or chalky. Many people prefer to remove it.
Common Misconceptions About Black Cheese
One widespread myth is that black rinds indicate a highly aged, premium cheese. In reality, some of the most expensive aged cheeses have pale or orange rinds. Another misconception is that black mold on cheese is always dangerous. While some molds produce mycotoxins, the molds used in cheese production are safe for human consumption. However, if you see black mold on a cheese that wasn’t intended to have it, especially on a soft cheese, it’s best to discard it.
Another related question is whether the blackening of the cut surface (the paste) means aging. The interior of aged cheese often develops small white crystals (tyrosine or calcium lactate) and a darker yellow or amber color, but it should never turn black. A black interior indicates severe spoilage or contamination, not aging.
How to Choose Cheese by Rind Color
When selecting cheese, don’t rely on rind color to judge age. Instead, look at the label or ask the cheesemonger. Terms like “aged 12 months” or “young” are more reliable. If you’re exploring black-rind cheeses, try these:
- Morbier: A French cow’s milk cheese with a distinctive black ash line in the middle (not the rind) and a gray-brown rind.
- Sottocenere: An Italian cheese with a black ash rind, often flavored with truffles.
- Ash-coated goat cheese: Fresh or semi-aged logs with a black coating that contrasts with the white interior.
These cheeses vary in age from a few weeks to several months, proving that black rinds aren’t tied to extended aging.
Cost and Availability
Black-rind cheeses are not inherently more expensive than other cheeses. The cost depends on the milk type, production method, and aging time, not the rind color. For example, a small ash-coated goat cheese log might cost $5–8, while a wedge of aged Sottocenere might cost $15–20 per pound. Specialty cheese shops and online retailers often stock these varieties, but they may be harder to find in regular grocery stores.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is black mold on cheese dangerous?
Not always. The black molds used in cheese production (like Mucor) are safe. However, if black mold appears on a cheese that wasn’t intentionally inoculated, it could be a spoilage mold. For hard cheeses, you can cut off at least 1 inch (2.5 cm) around the moldy spot. For soft cheeses, discard the entire cheese.
Can you eat the black rind?
Yes, most black rinds are edible, but they may be bitter, chalky, or earthy. If you don’t like the texture or taste, simply cut it off. For ash-coated cheeses, the ash is flavorless and safe to eat.
Does a black rind mean the cheese is old?
No. Some fresh cheeses have black rinds (ash-coated), and some aged cheeses have no black at all. Aging is determined by time and conditions, not rind color.
How should I store cheese with a black rind?
Wrap it in wax paper or cheese paper, then loosely in plastic or a container. This allows the rind to breathe while preventing it from drying out. Store in the refrigerator’s vegetable drawer, and use within 2–3 weeks for best quality.
Why does my cheese turn black in the fridge?
This is usually due to oxidation or moisture loss, not aging. If the cheese was cut, the exposed surface can darken. It’s safe to eat if the flavor and smell are normal—just trim off the darkened part.
Final Thoughts
Blackening on cheese is a visual cue that can come from intentional treatments, natural rind development, or spoilage. It is not a reliable sign of aging. To know how long a cheese has been aged, check the label or ask the seller. When in doubt about safety, trust your senses and err on the side of caution.
Related
- Baked Eggs in a Baking Dish: Easy Sheet-Pan Recipe
- Baked Eggplant Slices: Easy Crispy Oven Recipe
- Baked Egg Yolk: Rich, Creamy & Easy Recipe
More recipes to cook
Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).