Amish Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies with Fluffy Filling

Amish-style peanut butter whoopie pies are soft, cake-like peanut butter rounds sandwiched around a fluffy butter-and-peanut-butter filling. Popular in Pennsylvania Dutch baking, they make a generous, portable treat, and family versions vary in both the cake and filling.

Ingredients

½ cup (113 g) unsalted butter, softened
¾ cup (150 g) packed light brown sugar
¼ cup (50 g) granulated sugar
½ cup (128 g) creamy peanut butter, preferably no-stir
1 large egg, at room temperature
⅓ cup (80 ml) milk
1 teaspoon (5 ml) vanilla extract
2 cups (250 g) all-purpose flour, spooned into the measuring cup and leveled
1 teaspoon (5 g) baking soda
½ teaspoon (2 g) baking powder
½ teaspoon (3 g) fine salt
½ cup (113 g) unsalted butter, softened, for the filling
¾ cup (192 g) creamy peanut butter, for the filling
2½ cups (300 g) powdered sugar, sifted if lumpy
1 teaspoon (5 ml) vanilla extract, for the filling
1–2 tablespoons (15–30 ml) milk, as needed for the filling
⅛ teaspoon (about 0.5 g) fine salt, for the filling, optional

Instructions

Prepare the oven and pans. Set a rack in the middle of the oven and heat it to 350°F (175°C). Line two baking sheets with parchment paper. If you have only one sheet, bake the rounds in two batches and let the pan cool before adding the next batch; dough placed on a hot pan can spread too quickly.
Mix the dry ingredients. In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt until the leaveners are evenly distributed. Breaking up any small baking soda lumps now helps prevent bitter spots in the finished cakes.
Cream the butter, sugars, and peanut butter. In a large bowl, beat the ½ cup butter, brown sugar, granulated sugar, and ½ cup peanut butter with a hand mixer or stand mixer on medium speed for about 2 minutes. Stop when the mixture looks creamy and slightly lighter; it does not need to become very fluffy. Scrape the bowl so the mixture at the bottom is incorporated.
Add the egg and liquids. Beat in the egg until blended, then mix in ⅓ cup milk and 1 teaspoon vanilla. The mixture may look a little curdled at this point, especially if the ingredients were cool. That is fine; the flour mixture will bring it together.
Finish the batter. Add the dry ingredients in two additions, mixing on low speed just until no dry flour remains. Scrape the bowl once. The batter should be soft and scoopable, not pourable. Avoid beating it for a long time after adding flour, which can make the rounds tougher rather than tender.
Portion the rounds. Scoop 24 portions, about 1½ tablespoons (roughly 25 g) each, onto the prepared sheets. Leave about 2 inches (5 cm) between portions. If you want especially even sandwiches, weigh a couple of scoops to check their size, then use that as a visual guide. Leave the dough mounded; do not flatten it, since it spreads as it bakes.
Bake in two batches. Bake one sheet at a time for 10–12 minutes, then bake the second sheet for another 10–12 minutes. The rounds are ready when their tops look set, their edges are lightly colored, and they spring back gently when touched. For egg safety, check a thicker round by inserting an instant-read thermometer sideways into its center; it should reach at least 160°F (71°C), the USDA FSIS safe minimum for egg dishes. Do not wait for the cakes to turn dark brown, or they may dry out.
Cool completely. Let each sheet stand for 5 minutes, then move the rounds carefully to a wire rack. Cool them for about 45 minutes from the time the last batch comes out. The cakes must be fully cool before filling; even a little warmth can soften the butter filling and make it slide.
Make the filling. Beat the remaining ½ cup butter and ¾ cup peanut butter together until smooth, about 1 minute. Add the powdered sugar in two or three additions, mixing on low so it does not puff out of the bowl, then beat in 1 teaspoon vanilla and the optional pinch of salt. Add milk 1 teaspoon at a time until the filling is thick, smooth, and easy to spread. You may not need all of it.
Assemble the pies. Turn half the cooled rounds flat-side up. Divide the filling among them, using about 2 tablespoons per round, and gently top with the remaining cakes, flat-side down. Press just enough for the filling to reach near the edges without squeezing out. Let the pies sit for 10 minutes before serving so the filling settles, or chill them if you prefer a firmer center.

Tips

Measure flour lightly. Flour packed into a cup can make the batter dry and the cakes dense. Spoon it into the measuring cup and level it, or use the 250 g weight. If the batter seems unusually stiff after mixing, check your measurement before adding extra milk; a small amount of variation is normal.
Use similar-sized portions. Consistent scoops bake evenly and make pairs that fit together neatly. A 1½-tablespoon cookie scoop is convenient, but two spoons work too. If one sheet has larger portions than the other, those cakes may need a minute or two longer, so judge each batch by its appearance rather than relying only on the timer.
Choose the right peanut butter. Regular creamy, no-stir peanut butter gives the most predictable batter and filling. Natural peanut butter can separate and vary in thickness; if using it, stir it thoroughly first and expect the filling to need a little more powdered sugar or less milk. That can make the flavor more pronounced and the texture slightly less smooth.
Keep the cakes tender. Do not overmix once the flour goes in, and do not leave the rounds in the oven until they look deeply browned. They continue to firm as they cool. If a round breaks when you move it, leave it on the sheet for another minute before transferring it.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the pies at cool room temperature, when the cakes are soft and the filling is creamy but holds its shape. They are substantial, so one pie per person is a satisfying dessert or snack. For a dessert plate, cut a pie in half and serve it with sliced apples, pears, or a small bowl of berries; the fresh fruit gives a bright contrast to the sweet filling without making the cakes seem heavier.

These are also easy to pack for a picnic, bake sale, or lunchbox. Put each pie in a small paper liner or wrap it individually so the filling does not smear against other food. If the pies have been refrigerated, set them out for about 15–20 minutes before serving for a softer bite. Keep them out only as long as needed for serving and return extras to the refrigerator.

Variations

Chocolate-dipped edges: Let the assembled pies chill until firm, then dip one edge of each in melted semisweet chocolate. Set them on parchment until the coating firms. This adds a chocolate note and a little crunch; chill the pies again if the room is warm. Do not dip them while the filling is soft, or the cakes may shift.

Use crunchy peanut butter: Replace the creamy peanut butter in the cakes or filling with the same quantity of crunchy peanut butter. The cakes will have small nut pieces throughout, while crunchy filling will be less silky and may be harder to spread. For an even filling texture, keep the filling creamy and use crunchy peanut butter only in the cakes.

Make them peanut-free: For someone avoiding peanuts, use a smooth sunflower seed butter in both the cakes and filling, in equal amounts. Its flavor is different, and the batter or filling may be a little looser, so add milk cautiously and adjust the filling with powdered sugar if needed. Check every ingredient label and prevent cross-contact with peanut-contaminated utensils, pans, and surfaces. This substitution is not suitable for someone with a sunflower seed allergy.

Add a little cinnamon: Whisk ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon into the dry cake ingredients for a warm, gently spiced version. The cinnamon complements the peanut butter without changing the method. Avoid adding much more unless you want it to become the dominant flavor.

Storage and Reheating

Because the filling contains butter and milk, refrigerate the pies within 2 hours of assembling them. Store them in a covered airtight container, placing parchment between layers if needed to protect the tops. They keep well for 3–4 days in the refrigerator. For the softest texture, let a pie stand at room temperature for 15–20 minutes before eating, but do not leave the full container out for an extended period.

To freeze, arrange assembled pies in a single layer until firm, then wrap them individually and place them in a freezer-safe container for up to 2 months. Thaw them overnight in the refrigerator or for a few hours in the fridge, then let them soften briefly at room temperature before serving. There is no need to reheat whoopie pies. Microwaving an assembled pie can melt the filling and make the cakes gummy; if you want a warmer cake, warm an unfilled round very briefly, cool it until just warm, and add filling afterward.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did my whoopie pies spread flat? Common causes are butter that was very soft or partly melted, a hot baking sheet, too little flour, or batter that was beaten for a long time after the flour was added. Use softened butter that still holds its shape, measure the flour carefully, and cool the pan between batches. The rounds should spread, but they should remain thick enough to split into soft, cake-like halves.

Can I make the batter ahead? These rounds are most predictable when baked soon after mixing, since the baking soda begins reacting once it meets the wet ingredients. If you need to plan ahead, bake the cakes first, cool them completely, and store them covered for a day before filling. You can also make the filling a day ahead and refrigerate it; let it soften until spreadable, then beat it briefly before assembling.

Can I use natural peanut butter? Yes, provided it is thoroughly stirred so the oil is evenly mixed in. Natural peanut butters differ from jar to jar, so the batter may spread more and the filling may be less stable. If the filling feels loose, beat in powdered sugar a tablespoon at a time. If the batter is notably thin, chill it for 15 minutes before scooping rather than adding a large amount of flour.

How can I tell whether the filling is the right consistency? It should hold a soft peak on a spoon and stay on a cake round when spread, while still being easy to smooth. If it is stiff or crumbly, add milk a teaspoon at a time. If it runs toward the edges, add powdered sugar a tablespoon at a time. Temperature matters, too: very warm butter makes filling soft, while cold butter can leave it lumpy.

Can I make smaller pies? Yes. Scoop about 1 tablespoon (15–18 g) per round, leave space between portions, and begin checking them around 8 minutes. Smaller cakes bake faster and make more, but the exact yield depends on scoop size. Pair the cooled rounds by matching their diameters, then use less filling per sandwich so it does not overwhelm the smaller cakes.

Can I assemble them the day before serving? Yes. Assemble the pies, cover them, and refrigerate overnight. The cakes may soften slightly as they sit against the filling, which many people enjoy, but they will be more delicate to handle. Keep them chilled until shortly before serving and transport them in a firm container so the sandwiches do not slide or get crushed.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).