Oatmeal Cookie Shot: A Creamy Cinnamon Cocktail

An oatmeal cookie shot is a sweet, creamy cocktail that combines Irish cream, coffee liqueur, butterscotch schnapps, and a touch of cinnamon for the flavor of an oatmeal cookie in a small glass. Shake it with ice and serve it cold; the liqueurs bring plenty of sweetness, while cinnamon adds a warm finish.

Ingredients

2 oz (60 ml) Irish cream liqueur
2 oz (60 ml) coffee liqueur
2 oz (60 ml) butterscotch schnapps
¼ tsp ground cinnamon (about 0.7 g), plus a pinch for garnish
1 cup (150 g) ice cubes
Optional: 1 tbsp (15 ml) simple syrup, only if you prefer a sweeter shot

Instructions

Chill four small shot glasses in the freezer for about 5 minutes while you gather the ingredients. This is optional, but cold glasses help keep the drink cool as you serve it.
Pour the Irish cream, coffee liqueur, and butterscotch schnapps into a cocktail shaker. Add the ground cinnamon and ice. If you know you prefer a sweeter drink, add the optional simple syrup; taste the liqueurs first, since they are already sweet.
Secure the shaker and shake firmly for 10–15 seconds, until the outside feels cold. Shaking disperses the cinnamon and chills the liqueurs without needing to dilute them with extra liquid.
Strain evenly into the chilled shot glasses. If you like, finish each with a very small pinch of cinnamon. Serve straight away, before the ice melt thins the drink.

Tips

Measure before adding extra sweetness. The three liqueurs contain sugar, and brands differ in sweetness. Skip the syrup unless you have tasted the mixture and want it sweeter.
Keep cinnamon from clumping. Add it directly to the liquid before the ice, then shake well. For an especially smooth drink, stir the cinnamon into the coffee liqueur first.
Use a substitute thoughtfully. If butterscotch schnapps is unavailable, use caramel schnapps in the same quantity; the result will taste more like caramel and less like butterscotch. A small splash of vanilla vodka can add aroma, but it is less sweet and will make the shot stronger.
Make a small batch at a time. Shaking with ice gives the best cold, freshly mixed texture. Avoid leaving the drink in a shaker with ice, where it will continue to dilute.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the shots immediately after shaking, as an after-dinner drink or alongside coffee and a small dessert. They pair naturally with oatmeal cookies, shortbread, ginger cookies, or a simple piece of dark chocolate. Because the drink is rich and sweet, a small portion is usually enough; offer water alongside it and let guests choose whether they want a second.

For a simple garnish, dust the surface with cinnamon through a fine sieve. You can also place a small cookie on the side of each glass, but keep it separate rather than crumbling it into the drink, where it can make the texture gritty. If serving several guests, shake two portions at a time when your shaker is small, and strain each round as soon as it is ready.

Variations

Less sweet: Reduce the butterscotch schnapps to 1½ oz (45 ml) and increase the coffee liqueur by ½ oz (15 ml). This makes the coffee flavor more noticeable and tones down the candy-like sweetness.
More spice: Add a tiny pinch of ground nutmeg along with the cinnamon. Use a light hand so the spice does not overpower the creamy liqueurs.
Without coffee liqueur: Replace it with 2 oz (60 ml) of another dark, sweet liqueur, such as a caramel liqueur. The finished shot will lose the roasted coffee note, so add only a small pinch of instant espresso powder if you want to bring some of that flavor back.
Cookie-inspired rim: Moisten the outside rim of each glass with a little Irish cream and dip it in finely crushed oatmeal cookie. Keep the crumbs on the rim rather than mixing them into the drink, and serve promptly so the coating stays crisp.

Storage and Reheating

This drink is best served freshly shaken. If necessary, combine the measured liqueurs and cinnamon in a covered container and refrigerate for up to 24 hours; do not add ice until just before serving. Shake the chilled mixture with fresh ice, then strain into glasses. Once a portion has been poured over ice, drink it promptly rather than storing it. Do not leave the cream liqueur mixture at room temperature for more than 2 hours, and do not freeze it: freezing can affect the creamy texture. There is no reheating step.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does an oatmeal cookie shot contain oats?
No. The name describes the flavor, which comes from the creamy, coffee, butterscotch, and cinnamon combination. A cookie garnish can add actual oats, but it is optional.

Can I make oatmeal cookie shots without a shaker?
Yes. Stir the ingredients and cinnamon with ice in a mixing glass or sturdy cup for about 20 seconds, then strain into shot glasses. The drink may be slightly less frothy, but it will still be chilled and mixed.

Can I make these shots ahead for a party?
You can measure the liqueurs and cinnamon together and refrigerate them, covered, for up to 24 hours. Shake each batch with ice just before serving so it stays cold without becoming watery.

What if I do not have butterscotch schnapps?
Caramel schnapps is the closest straightforward substitute, though it gives a more caramel-forward flavor. Vanilla vodka is another option, but because it is less sweet, the drink will taste less like a cookie and may be stronger.

Can I serve this as a larger drink?
Yes. Double or triple the ingredients and pour the mixture over fresh ice in a small rocks glass. Keep the same proportions, taste before adding syrup, and remember that the larger serving contains more alcohol than a single shot.

Is this drink suitable for children or anyone avoiding alcohol?
No. It contains alcoholic liqueurs. This drink is for adults of legal drinking age only; drink responsibly. For a nonalcoholic alternative, combine chilled coffee, cream, a little caramel syrup, and cinnamon, adjusting the sweetness to taste.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).