Low-Calorie Substitute for Butter: Easy Yogurt Spread

This yogurt-based butter substitute combines plain Greek yogurt, a little olive oil, lemon, and seasonings into a tangy spread for toast, vegetables, and cooked dishes. It is quick to make and uses yogurt for most of its volume, but it behaves differently from butter in baking and high-heat cooking.

Ingredients

3/4 cup (180 g) plain, unsweetened nonfat Greek yogurt, cold
1 tablespoon (15 ml) extra-virgin olive oil, or a mild neutral oil
1 teaspoon (5 ml) fresh lemon juice
1/8 teaspoon (0.7 g) fine salt, or to taste
1/8 teaspoon (0.4 g) garlic powder, optional
1 tablespoon (3 g) finely snipped fresh chives, optional

Instructions

Prepare the ingredients. Measure the yogurt and oil, squeeze the lemon, and snip the chives if using. Keep the yogurt cold while you work; cold yogurt makes a thicker spread and is easier to portion neatly.
Stir the base. Put the Greek yogurt in a small bowl. Add the lemon juice, salt, and garlic powder, if using. Stir until smooth, scraping the sides and bottom so there are no concentrated pockets of seasoning.
Incorporate the oil. Drizzle in the olive oil a little at a time while whisking. Continue until the mixture looks uniform and lightly glossy. It will not become exactly like butter: the yogurt gives it a cool, creamy texture, while the oil adds a soft richness.
Add the herbs. Fold in the chives with a spoon. Taste a small amount and adjust the salt or lemon if needed. Keep the seasoning restrained at first; the flavor will seem more blended after chilling.
Chill before serving. Cover the bowl and refrigerate for 20 minutes so the spread firms slightly and the flavors settle. Spoon it into a clean serving dish, or transfer it to a covered container. Serve cold or let it stand at room temperature for about 5 minutes if you prefer it softer.

Tips

Choose thick yogurt. Plain nonfat Greek yogurt gives the mixture body without adding much liquid. Regular plain yogurt is thinner and can make a loose, runny spread; if that is what you have, strain it through a fine-mesh sieve lined with cheesecloth in the refrigerator until thick, then measure it. Do not use sweetened or flavored yogurt, which will make the result taste unlike a savory butter substitute.
Add oil gradually. Whisking the oil in slowly helps it disperse through the yogurt. Adding it all at once can leave a slick on the surface. If the mixture separates after chilling, stir it gently; do not keep beating it in the hope that it will turn into a firm butter-like block.
Season for the food you are serving. The base recipe is mildly savory. For plain toast, a pinch more salt may be welcome, while a version for vegetables or potatoes can take extra herbs, pepper, or garlic. If you plan to use it in a recipe, keep the seasoning neutral and account for the salt already called for there.
Do not use it as a one-for-one baking fat. Butter contributes fat, water, and structure, and this spread contains a great deal of yogurt. It can make cookies cakey or cause a cake to bake up damp if substituted in equal volume. Use a baking-specific swap, such as replacing only part of the butter with unsweetened applesauce in a moist quick bread, rather than assuming this spread will perform like butter.

Serving Suggestions

Use the spread wherever a cool, tangy topping makes sense. Spoon a little onto a baked potato, steamed green beans, corn, or warm roasted vegetables just before serving. It also works on toast, English muffins, and savory crackers. For a sandwich, spread a thin layer on the bread in place of butter, then add the usual fillings; its yogurt tang is especially compatible with cucumber, tomato, roasted vegetables, and fresh herbs.

For a warm dish, add it after cooking rather than using it to fry ingredients. A spoonful stirred into hot mashed potatoes or a bowl of rice will soften and coat the food, but it will taste brighter and less buttery than a pat of butter. Start with a small amount, taste, and add more if the texture and flavor suit the dish. The spread is best served cold or gently warmed by the food; it is not designed to be heated in a pan.

Variations

Herb and lemon: Add 1 teaspoon (2 g) finely grated lemon zest and 1 tablespoon (3 g) chopped parsley or dill. This is a good choice for vegetables, fish, or toast. Smoky paprika: Stir in 1/4 teaspoon (0.6 g) smoked paprika and a pinch of black pepper for potatoes or corn. Sweet breakfast version: Leave out the salt, garlic, and chives, and stir in 1 teaspoon (5 ml) maple syrup with a pinch of cinnamon. Use this on toast or pancakes, but keep the sweet batch separate from savory leftovers.

If you need a substitute specifically for baking, choose one based on the recipe rather than trying to adapt this spread. In muffins, quick breads, and some snack cakes, unsweetened applesauce can replace part of the butter; replacing about half is a cautious starting point, and the result will usually be moister and less rich. For sautéing, a splash of water or broth can help soften onions or vegetables without butter, but it will not brown them in the same way. For pastry, crisp cookies, or recipes that depend on creaming butter with sugar, use a tested recipe formulated for a different fat instead.

Storage and Reheating

Transfer the spread to a clean, airtight container and refrigerate it promptly, within 2 hours of preparation. It is best used within 3 days for the freshest flavor and texture. Because the base is yogurt, keep it refrigerated between servings and use a clean spoon each time; do not leave it on a buffet or countertop for extended periods. If it develops an unusual smell, visible mold, or an unexpectedly watery or discolored surface, discard it rather than tasting it.

This recipe is intended to be served cold, so reheating is not recommended. Warm it only indirectly by adding a small spoonful to food that has just finished cooking. Freezing is also not ideal: yogurt can separate and turn grainy after thawing, so make a smaller batch instead of freezing leftovers. If a little liquid separates during storage, stir the spread gently and use it soon.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this a lower-calorie substitute for butter?

It is designed to be a lighter spread by using Greek yogurt for most of the volume and limiting the added oil. The exact calorie difference depends on the yogurt and oil you choose, so compare the package labels if you need a precise figure. It will not have butter’s flavor or richness, and a thin layer is often more satisfying than using it as a thick pat.

Can I use this mixture in place of butter in cookies or cakes?

Not as a direct, equal-volume replacement. Yogurt contains considerably more water and less fat than butter, so cookies may spread or set differently, and cakes can turn dense or overly moist. Use a recipe designed for yogurt or another butter alternative, or replace only part of the butter in a moist quick bread and expect a noticeable change in texture.

Can I cook or fry with this butter substitute?

No. Greek yogurt can split, release water, or stick when exposed to the direct heat of a skillet, and this mixture is not a frying fat. Cook with a suitable small amount of oil, or soften vegetables with water or broth, then add the yogurt spread after cooking if you want its tangy flavor.

Can I make the recipe with regular yogurt?

Yes, but regular plain yogurt is generally thinner than Greek yogurt, so the spread may be runnier. Strain it in the refrigerator through cheesecloth or a clean fine-mesh filter until it reaches a thick, spoonable consistency, then measure the amount needed. Avoid straining it at room temperature for an extended period.

How can I make the spread dairy-free?

Use a thick, plain, unsweetened plant-based yogurt, preferably one labeled Greek-style. Plant-based yogurts vary widely in thickness and flavor, so stir in the oil gradually and add the lemon and salt to taste. A thin product may need straining, and the finished spread may taste less tangy or creamy than the dairy version.

Can I prepare it ahead of time?

Yes. You can make it up to 3 days ahead and keep it covered in the refrigerator. Chilling for at least 20 minutes is already part of the recipe, and making it earlier gives the garlic and herbs more time to flavor the yogurt. Stir gently before serving if any oil or liquid has separated.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).