Maker's Mark Old Fashioned Recipe, Smooth and Balanced

A Maker’s Mark Old Fashioned is an American bourbon cocktail made with whiskey, bitters, a little sugar, and citrus, served over ice. Stirring rather than shaking keeps it clear and lets you control its sweetness and dilution. This drink is for adults of legal drinking age; please drink responsibly.

Ingredients

2 oz (60 ml) Maker’s Mark bourbon
1 tsp (5 ml) 1:1 simple syrup
2 dashes (about 1 ml) Angostura aromatic bitters
1 strip orange peel, about 2 inches (5 cm) long, for garnish
1 cup (140 g) ice cubes, for stirring
1 large ice cube, about 2 inches (5 cm) wide, for serving
1 cocktail cherry (about 8 g), optional

Instructions

Chill a short rocks glass if you like, and prepare the garnish. Use a vegetable peeler or paring knife to cut a strip of orange peel, taking care to avoid a thick layer of bitter white pith. If using a cherry, set it aside for serving. Put a large ice cube in the rocks glass; if you do not have a large cube, use several fresh cubes instead.
Pour the Maker’s Mark, simple syrup, and Angostura bitters into a mixing glass or sturdy jar. A dedicated mixing glass is convenient, but any clean, heat-resistant glass vessel with room to stir will work. Measure the syrup rather than pouring freely: a small difference in sweetness is noticeable in a drink with only a few ingredients.
Add the cup of ice to the mixing glass. Stir smoothly with a bar spoon for about 20 to 30 seconds, keeping the spoon against the inside of the glass and moving the ice around rather than crushing it. The drink should become cold and slightly diluted. If you do not have a bar spoon, use a long-handled spoon and stir gently.
Strain the cocktail over the large cube in the rocks glass. If you used a jar without a built-in strainer, hold a small kitchen strainer over the serving glass as you pour. Do not pour the spent stirring ice into the drink; fresh serving ice melts more slowly and keeps the cocktail from becoming watery too quickly.
Hold the orange peel over the surface of the drink with its colored side facing down. Pinch it once to express its fragrant oils across the top, then run the peel around the rim and drop it into the glass or tuck it beside the cube. Add the optional cherry and serve right away.

Tips

Start with less syrup if you prefer a drier drink. One teaspoon gives a gently sweet balance, but bourbon, bitters, and personal taste vary. Try ¾ teaspoon (about 4 ml) the first time if you usually choose less-sweet cocktails; you can add a little more syrup before stirring if needed. It is harder to correct a drink that has already become too sweet.
Use fresh, solid ice. Ice that has been sitting out or is already wet melts faster and adds water before the drink is properly chilled. Large cubes are useful in the serving glass, but ordinary cubes are fine for stirring. If your freezer ice has picked up food odors, use fresh ice because those aromas can come through in a simple cocktail.
Adjust dilution by stirring, not by adding water at random. Stir for 20 seconds, taste, and continue briefly if the drink still tastes hot or overly concentrated. Ice size and temperature affect how quickly it melts, so the stated time is a useful starting point rather than an exact rule. Avoid shaking: it creates extra aeration and can make the drink cloudy.
Keep the garnish aromatic and simple. A thin peel with little pith gives a clean orange aroma. Expressing the oils over the drink adds fragrance without making it taste like orange juice. If you do not have an orange, a small lemon peel works, though it gives a sharper citrus note; leave out the peel rather than substituting bottled juice.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the Old Fashioned in a rocks glass, also called an old-fashioned glass, while it is cold and freshly stirred. A single large cube gives the drink a classic look and melts more slowly than a handful of small cubes, but a glass filled with regular ice is a perfectly practical choice. Set out a napkin and serve the cocktail on its own or alongside savory snacks such as salted nuts, olives, sharp cheese, or crisp crackers. These are accompaniments, not ingredients in the drink, and their salt and richness make a pleasant contrast to the bourbon’s sweetness and bitters’ spice.

The orange peel should be easy to smell when the glass is raised. If the drink is going to sit for a while before serving, add the garnish just before it reaches the table so its oils remain vivid. For a gathering, keep the glasses and garnish ready, but avoid adding ice to drinks too early. Ice continues to melt, so a cocktail poured well ahead of time will taste thinner than one stirred and served promptly.

Variations

Use a sugar cube. Replace the teaspoon of syrup with one small sugar cube and add 1 teaspoon (5 ml) water to the mixing glass with the bitters. Stir until the sugar is mostly dissolved before adding the bourbon and ice. This takes a little more stirring and can leave a subtle grainy texture if the sugar has not dissolved fully. Syrup is quicker and gives a more consistent result, while the cube is a familiar traditional-style option.

Try another aromatic bitters. Angostura is a dependable choice, but orange bitters can give the drink a brighter citrus edge. Replace one or both dashes with orange bitters, tasting as you go because brands and flavors differ. A dash of chocolate or aromatic-style bitters can make the profile warmer and more baking-spice-like, but use a restrained hand so the bourbon remains the focus.

Change the sweetener carefully. A teaspoon of maple syrup can replace the simple syrup for a rounder, woodsy sweetness; start with 1 teaspoon (5 ml), then adjust after tasting. Honey is also possible, though it is thicker and can be harder to mix into a cold drink. Loosen 1 teaspoon (5 ml) honey with 1 teaspoon (5 ml) warm water before measuring it into the cocktail. These swaps alter the flavor rather than acting as neutral sweeteners.

Make it a little lighter or stronger. For a gentler pour, use 1½ oz (45 ml) bourbon while keeping the bitters and syrup the same, then stir and taste. For a more spirit-forward version, use 2½ oz (75 ml) bourbon and increase the stirring slightly so it chills and dilutes properly. Do not simply add extra bitters to make a stronger drink; bitters add concentrated flavor, not the same balance as more whiskey.

Switch the citrus garnish. A lemon peel makes a sharper, less sweet-smelling finish, while a grapefruit peel adds a more bitter, fragrant note. Use only a small strip and express it over the glass as you would orange. Citrus juice is not a direct replacement: juice adds acidity and liquid, changing the drink’s balance and moving it away from the familiar stirred Old Fashioned style.

Storage and Reheating

An assembled Old Fashioned is best served immediately. Do not store it with ice in the glass: melting ice keeps diluting the drink, and the citrus aroma fades. There is no reheating step for this cocktail. If you need to prepare ahead, combine the bourbon, syrup, and bitters in a clean, sealed container, refrigerate it, and use it within 3 days for best flavor. Add ice and garnish only when serving. Measure the batch in servings so it is easy to pour the intended amount; for four drinks, for example, combine 8 oz (240 ml) bourbon, 4 tsp (20 ml) syrup, and 8 dashes bitters.

Keep any pre-mixed base refrigerated rather than leaving it out for an extended period, and do not add orange peel or ice to the stored container. Citrus peel can contribute a stronger, sometimes bitter flavor if left to steep, while ice will dilute the whole batch. If you have poured a drink over ice, do not return it to the storage container. Discard any leftover serving rather than trying to restore its original balance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make a Maker’s Mark Old Fashioned without simple syrup?

Yes. Use one sugar cube with 1 teaspoon (5 ml) water and the bitters, stirring until the sugar is mostly dissolved before adding the bourbon and ice. You can also use a small measured amount of maple syrup or thinned honey, though each gives a distinct flavor. Avoid adding dry sugar directly to a finished, cold drink because it may not dissolve evenly.

Should I muddle the orange peel or cherry?

No muddling is needed for this version. Express the oils from the orange peel over the cocktail and use it as a garnish. Muddling fruit can release extra juice and, in the case of citrus pith, unwanted bitterness. If you enjoy a muddled-fruit style, treat it as a separate variation and use a light touch rather than crushing the peel aggressively.

What if I do not have a mixing glass or bar spoon?

A sturdy jar or other clean, roomy glass vessel works for mixing, and a long-handled spoon can stir the drink. Pour through a small kitchen strainer if the vessel has no strainer built in. The essential points are to stir the bourbon, syrup, bitters, and ice until cold, then strain onto fresh ice; specialized bar tools are convenient but not required.

Can I use a different bourbon?

Yes. Another bourbon can be used in the same 2 oz (60 ml) measure, though its sweetness, spice, and oak flavors may differ from Maker’s Mark. Keep the syrup and bitters amounts the same for the first try, then adjust the sweetener by a small amount if the finished drink tastes too sweet or too sharp. Rye whiskey also works, but usually gives a drier, spicier character.

Can I make several drinks at once?

Yes. Multiply the bourbon, syrup, and bitters by the number of servings and refrigerate the measured mixture in a sealed container for up to 3 days. For the best texture, stir each serving with ice and strain it over fresh ice rather than pouring the batch over ice and leaving it to sit. Add a fresh orange peel to each glass just before serving.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).

Maker’s Mark Old Fashioned Recipe, Smooth and Balanced