The best frozen french toast sticks are Eggo Thick & Fluffy French Toast Sticks—they crisp up well in the toaster, have a sturdy yet tender crumb, and hold their maple flavor without tasting artificial. They edge out the competition because they deliver the closest texture to homemade French toast, with a satisfying cinnamon-sugar coating that stays put.
What to Look For
Not all frozen french toast sticks are equal. The criteria that actually matter when choosing a box:
- Texture after cooking: The best sticks are crisp on the outside and soft, not doughy, inside. Check reviews for how they fare in a toaster vs. oven—some turn rock-hard or soggy.
- Batter flavor: Real egg-and-cinnamon flavor beats plain bread with sugar. Look for ingredients like cinnamon, vanilla, and egg, not just high-fructose corn syrup.
- Coating stability: The cinnamon-sugar or batter coating should stay on the stick, not flake off into your toaster or plate.
- Size and count: Sticks vary from thin, snack-sized pieces to thick, hearty ones. Check the net weight—some boxes have fewer, smaller sticks than others.
- Cooking method versatility: If you only have a toaster, choose sticks designed for toaster use. Some are better in the oven or air fryer.
- Ingredients and allergens: Many contain wheat, egg, and soy. If you need gluten-free or vegan, check for dedicated lines.
Top Picks
1. Eggo Thick & Fluffy French Toast Sticks
Strengths: These are the gold standard. They toast up golden and crisp in a standard toaster (2 cycles) or air fryer (5 minutes at 375°F/190°C). The interior is soft and airy, not dense. The cinnamon-sugar coating is generous and stays on. They have a balanced sweetness—you can eat them plain or with syrup.
Trade-offs: They contain wheat, egg, and soy. The “thick� version is slightly denser than the original, but still good. They’re not the cheapest per ounce.
Who it suits: Anyone who wants a reliable, kid-friendly breakfast that tastes like real French toast. Best for toaster users.
2. Kellogg’s Eggo Original French Toast Sticks (Cinnamon)
Strengths: The classic version. They’re thinner than the Thick & Fluffy, so they cook faster (1-2 toaster cycles). They have a lighter, crispier texture and a more pronounced cinnamon flavor. Great for dipping in syrup.
Trade-offs: The thinner profile means they can dry out if overcooked. They’re also smaller, so you may need more per serving.
Who it suits: Those who prefer a crunchier, less bready stick and want quick cooking.
3. Trader Joe’s French Toast Sticks
Strengths: These are a fan favorite for their thick, brioche-like bread and real maple syrup flavor. They have a more premium taste and texture—the bread is soft and eggy, and the coating is more like a batter than a sugar dusting. They bake well in the oven (10 minutes at 400°F/200°C).
Trade-offs: Only available at Trader Joe’s. They’re not in a toaster-friendly shape—they’re more like small toast slices, so they don’t fit standard toaster slots. They also have a higher calorie count.
Who it suits: Those who want a more indulgent, bakery-style French toast and don’t mind oven cooking.
4. Whole Foods 365 Organic French Toast Sticks
Strengths: Made with organic wheat and no artificial flavors or high-fructose corn syrup. They have a clean, simple ingredient list. They toast up nicely in the oven or toaster oven, with a decent crisp and soft center. The cinnamon flavor is mild but natural.
Trade-offs: The coating is lighter, so they’re less sweet. They can be a bit dry if you skip syrup. They’re also pricier than mainstream brands.
Who it suits: Shoppers who prioritize organic ingredients and a less sugary breakfast.
5. Nature’s Path Organic French Toast Waffles (not sticks, but close)
Strengths: If you’re open to a waffle-shaped alternative, these are organic, vegan, and have a great cinnamon flavor. They toast up crisp and hold syrup well. They’re a good compromise for those who want a healthier option.
Trade-offs: They are waffles, not sticks, so the shape is different. They’re also thinner and less filling.
Who it suits: Vegans or those looking for a plant-based breakfast that still feels like French toast.
6. Store Brands (Great Value, Kroger, etc.)
Strengths: Budget-friendly and often taste similar to Eggo. They come in large boxes and are fine for a quick breakfast. Some store brands have improved their recipes to be crispier.
Trade-offs: Quality varies widely. Some are doughy, some are too sweet, and the coating can fall off. Check reviews for your specific store.
Who it suits: Those on a tight budget who don’t mind inconsistency.
How to Choose
Budget: Store brands are cheapest (often under $2 per box), while organic or specialty brands can cost $4-5. Eggo sits in the middle. If you eat them often, buying in bulk or store brand can save money.
Use case: For busy mornings, toaster-friendly sticks (Eggo) are fastest. For a weekend treat, oven-baked Trader Joe’s are worth the extra time. If you have an air fryer, most sticks work well, but thicker ones need longer.
Dietary needs: For gluten-free, look for specific gluten-free brands (like Katz or Glutino) that make French toast sticks. For vegan, Nature’s Path waffles are a good option, but most sticks contain egg.
Common trade-offs: Healthier options are often less sweet and less crispy. Thicker sticks are more filling but take longer to cook. Organic doesn’t always mean better taste—it’s about ingredient quality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I cook frozen French toast sticks in the microwave?
Yes, but they will be soft, not crispy. Microwave for 30-60 seconds on high. For best results, use a toaster, oven, or air fryer.
How do I get them crispy in the toaster?
Use the “frozen� setting if available, and toast twice on a medium setting. Let them cool for 30 seconds—they crisp up as they cool.
Are frozen French toast sticks healthy?
They’re a processed breakfast food, often high in sugar and refined carbs. Some are organic or have fewer additives. Pair with fruit or protein for a balanced meal.
What’s the best way to reheat leftover cooked sticks?
Reheat in a toaster oven or air fryer at 350°F (175°C) for 3-5 minutes. Avoid the microwave, which makes them soggy.
Can I make my own frozen French toast sticks?
Yes. Make French toast, cut into sticks, freeze on a baking sheet, then store in a bag. Reheat in a toaster or oven. This gives you control over ingredients.
Are there gluten-free frozen French toast sticks?
Yes, brands like Katz and Glutino make gluten-free versions, but they may be harder to find. Check the freezer section or online.
Bottom Line
For most people, Eggo Thick & Fluffy French Toast Sticks are the best all-around choice—they taste great, cook perfectly in a toaster, and have a texture that satisfies. If you want a more premium, bakery-style treat, go with Trader Joe’s (if you have one nearby). For a healthier, organic option, Whole Foods 365 is solid. Budget shoppers can try store brands, but be prepared for some inconsistency. Ultimately, the best pick depends on your priority: convenience, taste, or ingredients.
Related
- Garlic Knots with Rhodes Rolls: Easy Recipe
- Greek Fried Calamari Recipe (Crispy & Tender)
- Garlic Knots Store: How to Keep Them Fresh
More recipes to cook
Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).