Old Fashioned Recipe with Chocolate Bitters

An Old Fashioned with chocolate bitters is a spirit-forward cocktail made with bourbon or rye, a little sugar, aromatic bitters, and a twist of orange. The chocolate notes deepen the whiskey’s flavor without making the drink taste like a dessert; this recipe is for adults of legal drinking age, so please drink responsibly.

Ingredients

2 oz (60 ml) bourbon or rye whiskey: Bourbon gives the drink a rounder, sweeter base, while rye is usually spicier and drier. Choose a whiskey you enjoy sipping; a middle-proof bottle makes it easier to keep the flavors balanced.
1 sugar cube (about 4 g): A standard white sugar cube dissolves gradually and is easy to measure. If you do not have cubes, use 1 teaspoon (4 g) granulated sugar; the fine crystals dissolve a little faster.
1 teaspoon (5 ml) water: This helps dissolve the sugar before the whiskey and ice go in. Use cool, plain drinking water.
2 dashes (about 1 ml) chocolate bitters: These add a restrained cocoa-like aroma and spice. Dash strength varies by bottle, so begin with two rather than pouring freely.
1 dash (about 0.5 ml) aromatic bitters: This supports the whiskey and rounds out the flavor. If you only have chocolate bitters, use 3 dashes total, though the drink will have a more direct chocolate-spice character.
1 large ice cube, about 2 inches (5 cm) wide: A large cube chills the drink while melting more slowly than a handful of small cubes. If you have no large cube, use several solid, cold cubes and serve promptly.
1 strip orange peel, about 2 inches (5 cm) long by 1 inch (2.5 cm) wide: Cut a strip with a vegetable peeler, avoiding as much of the bitter white pith as possible. It is a garnish, but expressing its oils over the glass makes a noticeable difference.

Instructions

Prepare the orange peel. Wash and dry the orange, then cut a strip of peel about 2 inches (5 cm) long. Trim away any thick pith from the back if needed. Set it aside while you mix the drink; cutting the peel first keeps the finished cocktail from sitting while you search for a garnish.
Start the sweetener. Put the sugar cube in a sturdy rocks glass. Add the water and both kinds of bitters directly over the cube. Let it soften for about 20 seconds, then press and stir it with a bar spoon until the cube has mostly dissolved. A few tiny grains are fine, but an intact hard cube can leave the first sips overly sweet and the last sips gritty.
Add the whiskey and ice. Pour in the bourbon or rye and add the large ice cube. Stir steadily for about 20 to 30 seconds, keeping the spoon against the inside of the glass. This chills and slightly dilutes the spirit, softening its sharpest edges. If using small cubes instead, stir for about 15 to 20 seconds because they melt more quickly.
Taste and make a small adjustment. Take a sip before adding anything else. If it tastes hot or overly strong, stir for another 5 to 10 seconds to add a little more dilution. If it seems too sweet, add a few drops of whiskey; if you want more aromatic bitterness, add one additional dash of bitters and stir briefly. Adjust in small increments, since a dash can change the balance in a single-serving drink.
Finish with orange. Hold the orange peel skin-side down over the glass and gently pinch it once to release its fragrant oils over the surface. Rub the peel around the rim, then drop it into the drink or rest it on the edge. Serve right away while the ice is cold and the orange aroma is fresh.

Tips

Keep the chocolate in the background. Chocolate bitters are an accent, not a chocolate syrup. Two dashes give a subtle cocoa aroma; add a third only after tasting. Too much can make the cocktail taste strongly of spice or bitters and hide the whiskey.
Choose the whiskey for the profile you want. Bourbon tends to make a softer, rounder drink, particularly with a sweeter whiskey. Rye contributes peppery, herbal notes and can make the finish feel drier. Either works, so there is no need to buy a special bottle just for this recipe.
Do not shake this cocktail. Shaking adds air and can break the ice into small pieces that melt quickly. Stirring chills the drink more gently and keeps it clear. If you do not own a bar spoon, a long-handled teaspoon works well.
Use fresh ice and a fresh peel. Ice that has absorbed freezer odors can affect a drink with so few ingredients. A recently cut orange peel also smells brighter than one that has dried out. If you have only small ice, use cold cubes and avoid letting the drink stand before serving.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the Old Fashioned in a short rocks glass with the large cube still in the glass. The broad opening leaves room for the orange aroma, while the heavy base is comfortable to hold. This is a strong, slow-sipping cocktail rather than a tall, fizzy drink, so a small glass of still water alongside it is a useful non-alcoholic option for the table.

Its whiskey, bitters, and orange flavors pair well with salty or savory snacks such as toasted nuts, sharp aged cheese, olives, or crisp crackers. For a dessert pairing, try a small piece of dark chocolate or a simple nut-based cookie; keep the portion modest so it does not overwhelm the drink’s bitters. Serve the cocktail after a meal or alongside snacks, and make sure guests have appealing alcohol-free choices as well.

Variations

Rye and chocolate: Use rye whiskey for a drier, spicier version. Keep the sugar and bitters measurements unchanged for the first pour, then taste before making adjustments. If the rye is especially bold, another dash of water or a slightly longer stir can soften its intensity without adding more sweetness.

Maple Old Fashioned: Replace the sugar cube and water with 1 teaspoon (5 ml) pure maple syrup. Stir it with the whiskey and bitters until combined, then add the ice. Maple syrup dissolves more readily than a sugar cube and lends a mild woodsy sweetness, so start with the measured teaspoon rather than pouring in extra. Its flavor can be more noticeable than plain sugar.

Orange-forward version: Add a second dash of aromatic bitters or use a slightly wider strip of orange peel, but avoid muddling the peel into the drink. Muddling can release bitter pith and make the citrus taste harsh. For a less sweet cocktail, reduce the sugar to half a cube (about 2 g), while keeping the bitters and whiskey the same.

Chocolate bitters only: If aromatic bitters are unavailable, use 3 dashes of chocolate bitters in total. The result will still be an Old Fashioned in style, but the chocolate-spice note will be more pronounced and the drink may seem less complex. Avoid replacing bitters with chocolate syrup, which adds substantial sweetness and changes the texture.

Storage and Reheating

This cocktail is best mixed and served immediately. Ice keeps melting after the drink is made, so storing the finished cocktail in its glass will gradually water it down and flatten the orange aroma. If you need to make it ahead, mix the whiskey, sugar, water, and bitters without ice, cover it, and refrigerate within 2 hours. Use the chilled mixture within 24 hours for the best flavor, then pour it over fresh ice and add the orange peel just before serving.

There is no reheating for a cocktail. If a drink has been sitting with ice, it cannot be restored to its original balance; make a fresh one rather than trying to remove the dilution with extra whiskey. For a small gathering, you can multiply the whiskey, sugar, water, and bitters in a covered container and chill the mixture, but leave ice and orange peel out until each drink is poured. Keep any prepared mixture refrigerated and discard it after 24 hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do chocolate bitters taste like?
Chocolate bitters are concentrated aromatic bitters with cocoa-like notes, usually accompanied by spices or other botanical flavors. They do not taste like sweet chocolate syrup, and the small quantity in this recipe should add depth rather than turn the drink into a chocolate cocktail. Different bottles vary, so follow the measured amount and taste before adding more.

Can I make an Old Fashioned without a sugar cube?
Yes. Use 1 teaspoon (4 g) granulated sugar with the measured water and bitters, then stir until the crystals are mostly dissolved before adding whiskey and ice. You can also use 1 teaspoon (5 ml) maple syrup, which mixes easily and gives the drink a distinct maple note. Avoid adding a larger pour without tasting, because extra sweetener can hide the whiskey and bitters.

Should I use bourbon or rye whiskey?
Both are suitable. Bourbon generally creates a rounder, sweeter-tasting drink, while rye often brings more peppery spice and a drier finish. Pick according to your preference and the whiskey you have available. If you are unsure, make the first drink with the stated sugar amount, then adjust the next one rather than changing several ingredients at once.

Can I make this recipe without a large ice cube?
Yes. Use several fresh, solid cubes and stir for a shorter time, around 15 to 20 seconds, because smaller pieces chill quickly but also melt faster. Avoid crushed ice, which can dilute the cocktail before you finish it. If the drink becomes too warm or watery, start again with fresh ice instead of adding more bitters to compensate.

Can I batch Old Fashioneds for a party?
Yes. Multiply the whiskey, sugar, water, and bitters by the number of servings, then stir the mixture in a covered container until the sugar dissolves. Refrigerate it within 2 hours and use it within 24 hours. Pour individual servings over fresh ice and express a new orange peel for each glass; do not add ice to the batch, since it will melt and dilute every serving.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).