Old Granny Punch Recipe: A Bright, Bubbly Party Drink

Old granny punch is a family-style party drink made with fruit juices, lemonade, and fizzy ginger ale, served cold over ice with fruit for garnish. Recipes vary from one household to another; this version balances sweet pineapple and orange with tart cranberry and lemon, then adds the ginger ale just before serving so the punch stays lively.

Ingredients

4 cups (950 ml) pineapple juice, preferably unsweetened
3 cups (710 ml) orange juice
3 cups (710 ml) lemonade
2 cups (475 ml) cranberry juice cocktail
2 tablespoons (30 ml) fresh lemon juice
¼ cup (60 ml) simple syrup, optional, for a sweeter punch
2 liters (about 8½ cups) chilled ginger ale
6 cups (about 900 g) ice, plus extra for serving
1 medium orange (about 180 g), thinly sliced
½ cup (85 g) maraschino cherries, drained, optional
8 fresh mint sprigs (about 5 g), optional

Instructions

Combine the juices. In a large pitcher or food-safe container, stir together the pineapple juice, orange juice, lemonade, cranberry juice cocktail, and fresh lemon juice. If you know you like a sweeter punch, add the simple syrup now; otherwise, wait until you taste the finished drink. Stir well so the sharper lemon and cranberry are evenly distributed.
Chill the juice base. Cover the container and refrigerate the mixture for 2 hours. Chilling the base before serving helps keep the ice from melting too quickly and means you will not need to dilute the punch to get it cold. If you are preparing it for later, keep the base covered and leave the ginger ale unopened in the refrigerator.
Prepare the fruit. Just before serving, wash and thinly slice the orange. Drain the cherries if using them, and rinse the mint sprigs. Set aside a few orange slices and mint leaves for garnishing individual glasses. Thin slices are easier to scoop from the bowl and add a fresh citrus aroma without making the punch difficult to serve.
Taste and adjust. Pour the chilled juice base into a punch bowl or a large drink dispenser. Taste a small spoonful before adding the soda. If it is too tart for your guests, stir in the optional simple syrup a little at a time; if it tastes too sweet, add a splash of lemon juice. Keep in mind that ginger ale will add sweetness as well as bubbles.
Add the fruit and ginger ale. Stir in the orange slices and cherries. Pour in the cold ginger ale slowly, then give the punch one gentle stir. Avoid vigorous mixing, which knocks the carbonation out. Add the mint sprigs if desired, or place them in glasses so their flavor does not become too strong in the bowl.
Serve promptly. Add some of the ice to the bowl or dispenser, and put extra ice in a separate bucket or directly in guests’ glasses. Ladle the punch into glasses, making sure each serving gets a little fruit. If the gathering will last a while, keep the remaining juice base and ginger ale chilled and replenish the bowl in smaller batches.

Tips

Start with cold ingredients. Refrigerate the juices and ginger ale in advance. Cold ingredients preserve more fizz and reduce the need for lots of ice, which can water down the flavor. If you have forgotten to chill the base, set the covered container in an ice bath and stir it occasionally rather than adding a large amount of ice to the juice.
Choose juice to suit the balance. Cranberry juice cocktail is sweetened and gives this recipe a rounder, milder flavor. Unsweetened cranberry juice is much sharper; if you use it, begin with a smaller amount and adjust with lemonade or syrup after tasting. Pineapple juice labeled unsweetened lets you control the sweetness more easily.
Do not add the soda early. Ginger ale loses its sparkle if it sits mixed with the juices for hours. Keep it cold and sealed until just before serving, and stir only once or twice. For a smaller group, mix half the juice base with half the soda and save the rest for a fresh second batch.
Keep the ice from diluting the bowl. Use a large block of ice or a few frozen juice cubes in the punch bowl, or serve the punch over ice in individual glasses. Regular small cubes chill quickly but melt faster, especially outdoors. Avoid freezing the whole finished punch because carbonation and texture will not hold up well.

Serving Suggestions

Serve old granny punch in a chilled punch bowl with a ladle, or use a beverage dispenser with a spigot wide enough for the fruit slices. A bowl makes the citrus and cherries visible, while a dispenser is convenient for a buffet; in either case, keep extra ice beside the serving area rather than packing the container with it. That way, guests can choose how much ice they want and the main batch stays flavorful.

This drink fits a family reunion, birthday table, picnic, or holiday meal, and its bright color works well with a simple garnish. Add an orange slice and a cherry to each glass, or tuck in a small mint sprig for a fresher aroma. For children or anyone who prefers a less fizzy drink, pour a serving over ice and let it stand briefly, or top it with a little chilled water. Use sturdy cups for outdoor gatherings, and set out a small sign noting that the punch contains fruit juices and ginger ale.

If serving over an extended event, put out a modest amount at a time and refill the bowl from the refrigerated base. This keeps the drink colder and fizzier than leaving a full batch on the table. Keep the serving bowl away from direct sun and heat, and replace the ice as it melts rather than pouring meltwater into the punch.

Variations

Make it less sweet: Replace some or all of the ginger ale with chilled club soda, adding it gradually so you can check the balance. You can also use unsweetened cranberry juice in place of the cranberry juice cocktail, but that change makes the punch noticeably tarter. Taste before adding syrup; the lemonade and orange juice may provide enough sweetness on their own.

Use lemon-lime soda: Swap the ginger ale for an equal amount of lemon-lime soda for a sweeter, more citrus-forward bowl with less ginger flavor. Since lemon-lime soda can be quite sweet, leave out the simple syrup at first. A half-and-half blend of ginger ale and club soda is another useful middle ground when you want both ginger flavor and a lighter sweetness.

Add a sherbet float: For a creamy party-bowl variation, place small scoops of orange or raspberry sherbet on top just before serving. The sherbet softens into a frothy layer, making the drink sweeter and less clear, so it is best added to a small batch that will be served right away. Do not stir the sherbet into the full make-ahead juice base.

Make a frozen fruit garnish: Freeze orange slices or a few cherries in a shallow layer of water in a clean, freezer-safe ring mold, then float the finished ice ring in the bowl. This takes extra freezing time and is optional, but it chills the punch more slowly than loose cubes. Use a ring that fits your bowl and leave room for the drink to rise as the ice melts.

Adjust the citrus: For a more lemony punch, increase fresh lemon juice by 1 tablespoon (15 ml) at a time. For a softer citrus edge, use orange juice in place of part of the lemonade. Make changes to the juice base before adding ginger ale, since tasting and correcting the balance is easier before the drink is fizzy.

Storage and Reheating

This punch is served cold, so reheating is not appropriate. If you are making it ahead, refrigerate the juice base in a covered container and keep the ginger ale separate. For food safety, refrigerate the ingredients and any leftover punch within 2 hours of serving; if it has been sitting out longer than that, discard it rather than saving it. On a hot day above 90°F (32°C), limit that time out of refrigeration to 1 hour.

The uncarbonated juice base is best used within 3 to 4 days when kept continuously refrigerated at 40°F (4°C) or colder. Once the ginger ale and ice have been added, the punch is best served the same day because it loses fizz and becomes diluted. Leftovers that have been handled cleanly can be covered and refrigerated promptly, but expect them to be flatter the next day; discard them within 3 to 4 days total. Do not freeze the finished carbonated punch for storage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make old granny punch the day before?
Yes. Mix the pineapple, orange, lemonade, cranberry, and lemon juices up to a day ahead, cover, and refrigerate. Keep the ginger ale sealed and chilled separately, and add it only when you are ready to serve. You can slice the orange a few hours ahead, but keep it covered in the refrigerator so it stays fresh.

Can I make this punch without ginger ale?
Yes. Use chilled club soda for a less sweet, lighter drink, or use lemon-lime soda for a sweeter citrus version. You can also use sparkling water, although it contributes less flavor than ginger ale. Add the carbonated substitute just before serving, and taste the juice base first because different sodas change the sweetness.

What can I use instead of cranberry juice cocktail?
Use an equal amount of another cranberry blend, or try pomegranate juice for a similarly tart, deep-colored punch. Pure cranberry juice is more acidic and less sweet than cranberry juice cocktail, so start with less and adjust the overall balance with lemonade or a small amount of syrup. The finished color and flavor will vary with the substitute.

How do I make a smaller batch?
Halve each ingredient, including the ginger ale, and serve the punch in a pitcher. The juice base still benefits from chilling, though a smaller container may cool more quickly if the ingredients begin cold. Add the soda just before pouring, and keep any extra base refrigerated for a later batch rather than mixing all the carbonation in at once.

Can I make this punch with alcohol?
This recipe is written as a nonalcoholic party punch. If you choose to offer an alcoholic version, keep it separate from the main bowl, label it clearly, and serve it only to adults of legal drinking age. A measured splash of a spirit in an individual glass is easier to control than adding alcohol to the whole batch; drink responsibly.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).