Paleo Substitute for Cornstarch: How to Use Arrowroot

Arrowroot powder is a practical paleo substitute for cornstarch when you need to thicken a sauce, soup, or fruit filling. Stir it with cool water to make a smooth slurry, then add it near the end of cooking; it thickens quickly and gives many liquids a glossy finish.

This small-batch recipe makes enough slurry to thicken about 1 cup (240 ml) of liquid. Cornstarch is made from corn, which strict paleo approaches generally exclude, while arrowroot comes from a tropical root; individual paleo guidelines can vary.

Ingredients

1 tablespoon (8 g) arrowroot powder, also sold as arrowroot starch
2 tablespoons (30 ml) cool water

Instructions

Measure the thickener. Put the arrowroot powder in a small bowl. Break up any compacted lumps with the back of a spoon so they will mix evenly.
Make a slurry. Add the cool water gradually while whisking or stirring. Continue until the mixture looks smooth and milky, with no dry pockets or visible clumps. This is the full slurry recipe; add it to the hot liquid in the dish you are thickening rather than trying to cook the slurry by itself.
Warm the liquid you want to thicken. Bring your soup, gravy, sauce, or fruit juices to a gentle simmer using the cooking directions for that dish. Stir the slurry once more immediately before adding it, since starch settles quickly.
Add gradually and stir. Pour the slurry into the simmering liquid in a thin stream while whisking or stirring continuously. For a small pan, start with about half the slurry, give it 20 to 30 seconds to thicken, and add more only if needed.
Heat just until thickened. Keep the liquid at a gentle simmer for about 30 to 60 seconds, stirring, until it looks glossy and coats a spoon. Take it off the heat once it reaches the texture you want. Avoid a long, vigorous boil, which can weaken arrowroot’s thickening power.

The recipe’s two minutes are for measuring and mixing the slurry. The time needed to heat a separate sauce or soup depends on that dish and is not included in the slurry’s prep time. If you are adapting a recipe that calls for cornstarch, add the arrowroot at the end rather than following instructions that simmer cornstarch for a long time.

Tips

Use a cool liquid to start. Arrowroot dropped directly into hot liquid can seize into lumps before it disperses. Water is an easy neutral choice; a little cool broth or juice from the recipe also works.
Stir immediately before pouring. The powder settles to the bottom of the bowl within a short time. If the slurry has been waiting, whisk it again so the measured starch actually reaches the pan.
Thicken in small additions. One tablespoon of arrowroot is a reasonable starting point for about 1 cup (240 ml) of liquid, but the result depends on how much water is in the dish and how thick you want it. Add the remaining slurry in stages rather than committing all of it at once.
Keep the heat gentle once it thickens. Extended boiling can make an arrowroot-thickened sauce thin again or turn its texture unpleasantly slippery. Stop cooking as soon as the sauce is glossy and thick enough.

Serving Suggestions

Use the slurry in a pan sauce, gravy, or broth-based soup when you want body without a floury taste. It is especially handy for finishing a sauce after meat or vegetables have been removed from the pan: loosen the browned bits with broth, bring the liquid to a simmer, then stir in the slurry gradually. If the sauce is already salty or reduced, add only as much thickener as you need so it does not become overly dense.

Arrowroot also works well for fruit fillings and clear sauces. Mix it with a little of the recipe’s cold fruit juice before adding it to warm berries or sliced fruit. It can create a bright, translucent finish that lets the fruit show through. For a stir-fry sauce, whisk the slurry into the other sauce ingredients and add it near the end, stirring until the coating clings to the vegetables or protein.

For a baked pie or tart, follow a filling recipe designed for arrowroot if possible. Starch behavior changes with the quantity of fruit, its juiciness, and the time spent baking, so a sauce ratio does not automatically translate to a reliable pie filling. A filling that looks slightly loose while hot may also set more as it cools.

Variations

Tapioca starch: Tapioca starch, sometimes labeled tapioca flour, is another common paleo-friendly option made from cassava. Use it in a slurry in the same general way, beginning with a modest amount and adjusting to the recipe. It tends to give a more elastic or slightly chewy texture than arrowroot, so it can suit fruit fillings and coatings but may not be the best match for every delicate sauce.

Arrowroot with a little tapioca: For an all-purpose pantry blend, combine equal parts arrowroot powder and tapioca starch in a clean, dry jar. Measure the blend as you would a single starch, then make a cool-water slurry before adding it to hot liquid. This is a useful option when you want to experiment with texture, but it is not a guaranteed one-for-one replacement in every baked recipe; keep notes and adjust the next batch based on the result.

For a crisp coating: Dust small pieces of meat, fish, or vegetables lightly with arrowroot before pan-frying, or use tapioca starch if you prefer a chewier crust. This is a dry-coating use, so do not mix the powder with water first. Use a thin coating and shake off excess; a heavy layer can become gummy. Cook the food according to its recipe and safe-temperature guidance.

For a dairy-based sauce: Arrowroot can turn slick or stringy in some milk- or cream-heavy sauces, especially when boiled. If you want to use it, whisk it into a small amount of cool liquid from the recipe and add it at the very end over low heat. Stop as soon as the sauce thickens; for a recipe that depends on a long simmer, choose a thickener specified for that method instead.

For baking: There is no universal paleo starch that replaces cornstarch identically in every cake, cookie, or pastry. Cornstarch may tenderize a flour mixture or change its structure rather than simply thicken liquid. Arrowroot or tapioca can sometimes work, but use a tested recipe with that starch when the baked texture matters.

Storage and Reheating

For the most reliable result, mix the slurry just before you need it. If you must prepare it ahead, cover the bowl and refrigerate it for up to 24 hours; the powder will settle, so stir it thoroughly before use. Refrigerate it within 2 hours of mixing, and discard it if it has been left at room temperature longer than that. Do not store unused wet slurry at room temperature.

Keep unopened or dry arrowroot powder in an airtight container in a cool, dry pantry, following the package’s best-quality guidance. Keep moisture out of the container and use a clean, dry spoon. If you have thickened a sauce or soup, refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours and use them within 3 to 4 days. Arrowroot sauces may loosen or separate after chilling, and freezing can make the texture less smooth. Reheat leftovers to 165°F (74°C), stirring as they warm; add a small splash of water or broth if the sauce has become too thick.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace cornstarch with arrowroot in equal amounts?

It is a useful starting point in many sauces, but not a promise of identical results. Begin with about 1 tablespoon (8 g) of arrowroot for 1 tablespoon of cornstarch in roughly 1 cup (240 ml) of liquid, then add it gradually and stop when the texture is right. The best amount depends on the recipe and how thick you want the finished dish.

Is arrowroot powder the same as arrowroot flour?

In most grocery stores, arrowroot powder, arrowroot starch, and arrowroot flour refer to the same fine starch used for thickening. Check the ingredient label to make sure it is pure arrowroot rather than a blend with another starch or added ingredients.

Can I add arrowroot powder straight to a hot sauce?

It is better to make a slurry first. Dry powder can form lumps as its outside thickens on contact with heat, leaving dry starch trapped inside. Mixing it with cool water before it goes into the pan helps it disperse smoothly.

Why did my arrowroot sauce turn thin after it thickened?

The sauce may have boiled vigorously or simmered for too long after the starch thickened. Arrowroot usually performs best when added near the end of cooking and heated only until the liquid becomes glossy. For a dish that must simmer for a long time, add the arrowroot shortly before serving.

Does arrowroot work in acidic sauces?

It is often a suitable choice for fruit sauces and other acidic mixtures, where it can give a clear finish. Still, add it near the end and avoid prolonged boiling. If the sauce contains a lot of fruit juice or vinegar, use the recipe’s texture as your guide and add the slurry in stages.

What is the best paleo substitute for cornstarch in baking?

There is no single best substitute for all baking. Arrowroot and tapioca starch can work in particular recipes, but they do not behave exactly like cornstarch in every batter or dough. For predictable results, choose a recipe written for the starch you plan to use rather than swapping it blindly into a recipe that relies on cornstarch for structure.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).