Pimm’s and Lemonade Recipe: A Classic British Summer Cup

Pimm’s and lemonade is a British summer pitcher drink made with Pimm’s No. 1, fizzy lemonade, ice, and fresh fruit and herbs. Its bittersweet, citrusy flavor and crisp garnishes make it refreshing to serve at a garden gathering or picnic, and the simple one-to-three ratio is easy to scale. This recipe is for adults of legal drinking age; drink responsibly.

Ingredients

1 cup (240 ml) Pimm’s No. 1
3 cups (720 ml) chilled sparkling lemonade, preferably the clear, lightly sweetened British-style lemon soda rather than still American lemonade
4 cups (about 560 g) ice cubes
½ medium cucumber (about 150 g), washed and cut into thin half-moons
1 cup (150 g) strawberries, hulled and halved or quartered if large
1 small orange (about 130 g), washed and cut into thin rounds or half-moons
1 small lemon (about 100 g), washed and cut into thin rounds
8–10 fresh mint sprigs (about 10 g), rinsed and gently patted dry

Instructions

Prepare the fruit and mint. Wash the cucumber, strawberries, orange, lemon, and mint. Slice the cucumber and citrus thinly so they release some aroma into the drink while still being easy to lift out with a spoon. Hull and halve the strawberries. Keep the mint sprigs whole; bruising or tearing them can make the drink taste grassy, and small torn pieces are harder to avoid while drinking.
Fill the pitcher with ice. Choose a pitcher that holds at least 2 quarts (1.9 liters), leaving a little room at the top for stirring. Add the ice first, then tuck in most of the cucumber, strawberries, citrus, and mint. Reserve a few attractive pieces of each garnish for the glasses. Starting with cold ingredients and plenty of ice helps keep the drink crisp without needing a long chilling step.
Add the Pimm’s. Pour 1 cup (240 ml) of Pimm’s No. 1 over the ice and fruit. Stir gently once or twice to distribute it. There is no need to muddle the fruit: the goal is a lightly infused, clear drink, not crushed fruit or a pulpy texture.
Top with lemonade and stir gently. Pour in 3 cups (720 ml) of chilled sparkling lemonade. Use a long spoon to lift the ingredients from the bottom and turn them through the liquid once or twice. Avoid vigorous stirring, which knocks out carbonation. Taste a small sip before serving; the standard one-part Pimm’s to three-parts lemonade balance is fruity and gently sweet, but you can adjust it in the glass.
Serve straight away. Add a few reserved fruit slices and a mint sprig to each glass, then ladle in the drink with ice. If the pitcher has been standing for a few minutes, give it one gentle stir before pouring. Offer a long spoon or cocktail pick so guests can reach the fruit, and keep extra chilled lemonade nearby for anyone who prefers a lighter drink.

Tips

Check the lemonade label. “Lemonade” means different things in different places. For the familiar British Pimm’s Cup style, use a carbonated lemon soda. In the United States, bottled lemonade is often still and more tart; if that is what you have, mix it with plain sparkling water to add fizz and soften the intensity. A lemon-lime soda can work too, though it makes the finished drink sweeter and less distinctly lemony.
Keep every liquid cold. Chill the Pimm’s and lemonade before mixing, and use solid ice rather than small crushed ice. Cold ingredients preserve the bubbles and slow dilution. If you want to prepare in advance, wash and slice the fruit earlier, but wait to add the ice and lemonade until guests are ready to drink.
Use fresh, firm garnishes. Choose strawberries that are ripe but not soft, and a cucumber that feels firm. Overripe berries can break apart and cloud the pitcher. If mint is especially strong, use fewer sprigs; it should add a fresh aroma rather than cover the citrus and Pimm’s.
Adjust by the glass rather than over-sweetening the pitcher. Fruit sweetness and lemonade brands vary. If a serving tastes too sweet, add a splash of sparkling water or a squeeze of lemon to that glass. If it tastes too strong, top it with more lemonade. This keeps the main pitcher balanced for different preferences.

Serving Suggestions

Serve Pimm’s and lemonade in tall, ice-filled glasses so there is room for both the drink and a little garnish. A highball or large wine glass works well; the glass shape is less important than having enough space for the fruit. Put a cucumber slice, a strawberry half, and a citrus slice in each glass, then finish with mint. A reusable straw is optional, but a spoon or pick makes the fruit easier to enjoy.

This pitcher is well suited to warm-weather meals and relaxed gatherings. Pair it with savory picnic food such as sandwiches, quiche, crisp salads, or grilled vegetables, or set out salty snacks alongside it. Because the drink is lightly sweet and aromatic, it works best with food that is not heavily sweetened. For a larger party, make more than one pitcher rather than packing a single pitcher so tightly with fruit and ice that it becomes difficult to pour.

For a slower gathering, serve the pitcher on a tray with a bowl of extra ice and a jug of chilled lemonade. Guests can top up their own glasses without repeatedly adding warm ingredients to the main pitcher. Keep the drink out of direct sun and return it to the refrigerator if it will not be served promptly.

Variations

Less sweet: Replace 1 cup (240 ml) of the lemonade with 1 cup (240 ml) of chilled sparkling water. The drink will be lighter and less sugary, with the Pimm’s and fruit flavors more prominent. If it seems too tart, add lemonade back a splash at a time rather than sweetening the whole batch.
More citrus-forward: Add a few extra lemon slices or a small squeeze of lemon juice to the pitcher. This brings sharper acidity, particularly useful if your sparkling lemonade is quite sweet. Add the juice gradually so it does not overwhelm the cucumber and mint.
Different seasonal fruit: Try thin slices of apple, a few raspberries, or pieces of ripe pear in place of some strawberries. They change the aroma and sweetness, so use them as a garnish rather than assuming they will taste identical to the classic combination. Keep cucumber and mint if you want the drink to retain its familiar fresh character.
Single serving: Pour 2 tablespoons (30 ml) Pimm’s No. 1 over a glass filled with ice, top with 6 tablespoons (90 ml) sparkling lemonade, and add a little cucumber, strawberry, citrus, and mint. This keeps the same one-to-three ratio without leaving a pitcher to go flat. Multiply the quantities for additional glasses.
No sparkling lemonade available: Combine 2 cups (480 ml) chilled still lemonade with 1 cup (240 ml) sparkling water for the mixer quantity in this recipe. It will have a fresher, less soda-like lemon flavor, and its sweetness depends on the lemonade you use. Taste before adding it to the pitcher.

Storage and Reheating

This drink is best immediately after mixing, while the lemonade is bubbly and the ice has not had time to melt. For food-safety purposes, refrigerate the pitcher within 2 hours; do not leave it standing at room temperature through a long party. If the weather is hot, keep it chilled and return it to the refrigerator between servings rather than relying on a pitcher of melting ice.

If you have leftovers, remove the ice and fruit, cover the remaining drink, and refrigerate it promptly. It is best within about 24 hours, although it will lose much of its carbonation and the fruit flavor may become more pronounced. Do not store it with the ice, which will dilute it, or leave sliced fruit soaking in the drink overnight if you want a clean, fresh flavor. Add fresh ice and garnish when serving the chilled leftover drink.

There is no reheating step for Pimm’s and lemonade. Heat would drive off the bubbles and change the character of the drink, so serve it cold. If you are preparing ahead, keep the sliced fruit in a covered container in the refrigerator and store the Pimm’s and lemonade separately; combine them with fresh ice shortly before serving. Follow the storage directions on the bottles for any leftover Pimm’s or lemonade.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the usual ratio of Pimm’s to lemonade?
The familiar starting ratio is one part Pimm’s No. 1 to three parts sparkling lemonade. This recipe uses 1 cup Pimm’s and 3 cups lemonade. It is a useful balance rather than a rule: add more lemonade for a lighter glass, or measure a little more Pimm’s into an individual serving if you prefer a stronger flavor.

Is Pimm’s and lemonade the same as a Pimm’s Cup?
Pimm’s and lemonade is often served as a Pimm’s Cup, particularly in British summer settings. The name can refer to slightly different recipes, and fruit, herbs, and mixer choices vary from household to household. This version uses Pimm’s No. 1, fizzy lemonade, cucumber, strawberries, citrus, mint, and ice for a straightforward pitcher.

Can I use regular still lemonade?
Yes. Still lemonade works, but the drink will not have the classic sparkle and can taste more sharply lemony. Combine it with sparkling water to restore the fizz, or top each glass with sparkling water just before serving. Start with the same amount of mixer and taste before making any further adjustment.

Can I make the pitcher ahead?
You can wash and cut the fruit and chill the bottles several hours ahead, storing the prepared fruit covered in the refrigerator. For the best bubbles, do not add the lemonade until serving time. Add the ice and mix the Pimm’s with the lemonade just before pouring; a fully mixed pitcher can be refrigerated briefly, but it will gradually go flat.

Can I make Pimm’s and lemonade without alcohol?
For a nonalcoholic pitcher, omit the Pimm’s and use a nonalcoholic botanical or fruit-cup-style drink if available, then add sparkling lemonade to taste. The result will not taste exactly like Pimm’s, so adjust with citrus, cucumber, and mint rather than trying to match the original drink’s strength. Keep separate pitchers clearly identified if serving both versions.

Should the fruit be eaten or removed?
Either is fine. The fruit is there to flavor and decorate the pitcher, and many people enjoy the strawberries and citrus after they have soaked briefly. Cucumber and citrus can become less pleasant as they sit, so remove the garnishes if the pitcher will be stored. Add fresh fruit to glasses for a neater presentation.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).