Powdered Sugar Substitute for Baking: Easy Blender Recipe

This powdered sugar substitute is granulated sugar blended with a little cornstarch until fine and fluffy. It is a handy pantry fix for icing, glaze, and dusting, though its texture may be less silky than commercial powdered sugar in delicate baking.

Ingredients

This batch makes about 1¾ cups (roughly 210 g) of homemade powdered sugar substitute, or fourteen 2-tablespoon portions. The final volume varies a little with the blender and how finely the sugar is ground.

1 cup (200 g) granulated white sugar
1 tablespoon (8 g) cornstarch

Instructions

Measure the ingredients. Add the granulated sugar and cornstarch to a completely dry, high-speed blender or spice grinder. A full-size blender works best for this amount; a small grinder may need the ingredients divided into batches. Measuring takes about 1 minute.
Grind until very fine. Secure the lid and blend for 30 to 60 seconds, stopping once or twice to shake the container if needed. The mixture should look like soft, even powder, with no obvious sparkling crystals. Avoid running the blender continuously for several minutes, which can warm the sugar and encourage clumping. Allow about 1 minute of blending time.
Let the sugar dust settle. Turn off the blender and leave the lid in place for 1 minute. This pause keeps a cloud of fine sugar from escaping when you open the container.
Check and sift. Open the blender away from your face. Rub a small pinch between your fingertips; if it still feels distinctly gritty, blend for another 15 to 30 seconds and let the dust settle again. For a smoother result, sift the powder into a bowl and return any coarse crystals to the blender. Allow about 2 minutes for checking and sifting.
Use or pack away. Measure the finished substitute by volume for recipes that call for powdered sugar. Transfer any extra to a clean, dry, airtight container. The finished powder is ready to use; there is no cooking or cooling stage.

Tips

Keep every tool dry. A damp blender jar or spoon can make the powder clump. If the equipment was washed recently, dry it thoroughly and check the bottom and lid for moisture before adding the sugar.
Blend in short bursts if your machine runs hot. A powerful blender can make a fine powder quickly, while a basic blender may leave a few crystals. Use short pulses, pause between them, and scrape or shake only after the blades have stopped.
Use the right comparison. The homemade mixture is not a sugar-free replacement. It is made from ordinary granulated sugar and is intended to stand in for powdered sugar; it does not replace brown sugar, liquid sweeteners, or granulated sugar in every recipe.
Do not skip sifting for a smooth finish. Sifting catches larger crystals and small clumps before they go into a glaze or frosting. For a rustic dusting over a cake, you can often use the powder without sifting.

Serving Suggestions

Use the substitute where powdered sugar is mainly there to sweeten or finish a dish. For a quick glaze, whisk 1 cup (about 120 g) of the substitute with 1½ to 2 tablespoons (22 to 30 ml) of milk, lemon juice, or water, adding the liquid gradually until it is thick but pourable. A few drops of vanilla or citrus juice can add flavor. If the glaze looks grainy, let it stand briefly, whisk again, or sift it before spreading.

It is also useful for a simple buttercream, a thin icing for cinnamon rolls, or a light dusting over brownies, waffles, fruit tarts, and cookies. For dusting, put the powder in a fine-mesh sieve and tap it gently over the cooled dessert. Powder melts quickly on a warm, moist surface, so wait until baked goods have cooled and dust shortly before serving if you want the white finish to remain visible.

For buttercream, beat softened butter until smooth before adding the substitute in several additions. Taste and check the texture before using it to pipe detailed decorations. Homemade powder can feel slightly less fine on the tongue than commercial confectioners’ sugar, so it is better suited to casual frosting than to a very smooth, showcase finish.

Variations

Make it without starch for immediate use. Blend 1 cup (200 g) granulated sugar by itself and use it right away in a recipe where a little extra starch is not wanted. Without the cornstarch, the powder is more likely to cake during storage, so make only what you need. It can still be somewhat less fine than packaged powdered sugar.

Try another neutral starch. If cornstarch is unsuitable for your recipe, use 1 tablespoon (about 8 g) arrowroot starch or tapioca starch in its place. Either can help limit clumping, but the texture and thickening behavior may differ slightly, especially in a cooked filling or icing. Choose a starch that fits the recipe and any dietary requirements.

Make a small batch. For a smaller amount, blend ½ cup (100 g) granulated sugar with 1½ teaspoons (about 4 g) cornstarch. A small quantity may not reach the blades in a large blender, so use a spice grinder or another appropriately sized machine. Work in short bursts and check the texture before stopping.

Flavor the finished powder carefully. For a subtle vanilla note, blend in a small pinch of vanilla powder if available. Do not add liquid vanilla extract to the blender: added moisture can make the sugar clump. For citrus flavor, use finely grated dry zest or add fresh zest directly to the frosting or glaze rather than storing it in the powder.

Storage and Reheating

Store the finished substitute in a clean, airtight container in a cool, dry cupboard for up to 1 to 2 months for best texture. Label it so it is not mistaken for plain granulated sugar. Keep it away from steam, wet measuring spoons, and humid spots near a kettle or dishwasher. Refrigeration is not necessary and can introduce moisture when a cold container is opened in a warm room.

If the powder develops small lumps, break them up with a dry spoon or sift the amount you need. If moisture has made it damp, sticky, or hard in a way that will not sift out, discard it rather than trying to dry it. This is a dry baking ingredient, so there is no reheating step. Once mixed into a glaze or frosting, follow the storage directions for that particular recipe; this substitute does not make a finished dessert shelf-stable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use this in any recipe that calls for powdered sugar?
Not always. It works best when powdered sugar is used for a quick glaze, a basic frosting, or a finishing dust. Recipes that depend on the exact fine texture, starch level, or behavior of commercial confectioners’ sugar may turn out differently. For delicate meringues, finely textured cookies, candy, or a recipe where powdered sugar is a structural ingredient, use the type specified if possible.

How much homemade substitute replaces 1 cup of store-bought powdered sugar?
Start with 1 cup by volume for 1 cup by volume, then adjust to the recipe’s texture and taste. The batch in this recipe yields about 1¾ cups, but the precise volume depends on how finely the sugar is ground and how it settles. Avoid packing it into the measuring cup; spoon it in lightly and level the top.

Will blending make the sugar as fine as commercial powdered sugar?
It can become quite fine in a powerful blender or grinder, but home equipment varies. Commercial products are usually milled very finely and may include a small amount of starch to prevent caking. If you can still feel crystals after blending and sifting, use the mixture in a less texture-sensitive application rather than expecting it to disappear perfectly into a delicate icing.

Can I use a food processor instead of a blender?
A food processor can work, but its bowl and blade may not grind a small quantity as evenly as a blender or spice grinder. Process in brief pulses, pause to let the dust settle before opening, and check for coarse grains. If the sugar keeps moving away from the blade or remains gritty, transfer it to a smaller grinding appliance or make a larger batch.

Can I use a sugar substitute such as erythritol instead of granulated sugar?
This recipe is designed for granulated cane or beet sugar, not a non-sugar sweetener. Some granulated sugar alternatives can be ground into powder, but they may cool or taste different, dissolve differently, and behave differently in baking. Follow a recipe specifically developed for that sweetener rather than assuming the substitution is one-to-one.

Why is my homemade powdered sugar clumpy?
Clumping usually comes from moisture, warm equipment, or powder left exposed to humid air. Make sure the blender and storage container are completely dry, let the blender cool between batches, and close the container promptly. A small dry lump can be sifted out; damp or sticky sugar is better discarded.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).