St Elizabeth allspice dram is a Jamaican allspice liqueur with warm, peppery spice and rum behind its sweetness; this homemade substitute infuses rum with whole allspice, then blends it with simple syrup. It is useful in tiki cocktails and baking, though the homemade version may taste fresher and more spice-forward than the bottled liqueur.
Ingredients
- 1 cup (240 ml) dark or aged rum, preferably Jamaican rum for a closer flavor
- 2 tablespoons (12 g) whole allspice berries
- 1/2 cup (120 ml) water
- 1/2 cup (100 g) granulated sugar
- 1 thin strip orange peel, about 1 by 2 inches (2.5 by 5 cm), optional
Instructions
- Crack the allspice. Put the whole berries in a sturdy zip-top bag and gently crush them with the bottom of a small pan, or pulse them once or twice in a spice grinder. Aim to split most berries, not turn them into powder. This takes about 3 minutes and helps the rum draw out their aroma without making straining difficult.
- Start the infusion. Transfer the cracked berries to a clean, dry, sealable glass jar and pour in the rum. Close the jar and refrigerate it for 7 days, shaking gently once a day. If using orange peel, add it for only the final 24 hours so it contributes a light citrus note without taking over or turning bitter. Keep the jar closed between shakes.
- Make the syrup. After the infusion is ready, combine the water and sugar in a small saucepan. Warm over medium heat, stirring, until the sugar dissolves and the liquid just begins to simmer; this should take about 5 minutes. Do not boil it down to a thick syrup. Remove the pan from the heat and let the syrup cool for 30 minutes, until it is no longer warm.
- Strain and blend. Set a fine-mesh strainer over a clean bowl and pour the infused rum through it. For a clearer result, line the strainer with a coffee filter and allow extra time for the liquid to pass through. Discard the berries and peel. Stir the cooled syrup into the strained rum, then taste a small amount. The full batch takes about 10 minutes to strain, mix, and transfer.
- Rest before using. Pour the mixture into a clean bottle or jar, seal it, and refrigerate for 12 hours so the spice and sweetness settle together. The result should be aromatic, sweet, and distinctly allspice-led. This batch yields roughly 1 1/2 cups (about 360 ml), or 24 portions of 1 tablespoon (15 ml); actual yield varies slightly with straining.
Tips
- Use whole berries, not a spoonful of ground spice. Whole allspice releases flavor gradually and is much easier to strain. Ground allspice can make the drink gritty and intensely woody, and it may continue to grow stronger while stored. If ground spice is your only option, use just 1/2 teaspoon (about 1 g), steep for 12 hours, and filter through a coffee filter; expect a less clean flavor.
- Choose a rum with some character. Dark or aged rum gives the substitute the round, molasses-like base that suits many allspice-dram cocktails. White rum works in a pinch, but the result tastes lighter and less rich. Avoid heavily spiced rum unless you want its extra vanilla or cinnamon flavors to compete with the allspice.
- Adjust sweetness at the glass, not by guessing at the bottle. The syrup amount is a balanced starting point, but different rums and cocktail recipes vary. If a drink tastes too sweet, reduce the dram slightly or balance the cocktail with its listed citrus; do not add extra water to the whole batch, which can flatten its flavor.
- Strain patiently. Pressing the berries through the strainer can push fine particles into the liqueur and make it cloudy or gritty. Let gravity do the work, especially if using a coffee filter. A little natural haze is not necessarily a problem, but the texture should not feel sandy.
Serving Suggestions
Use the substitute in drinks that call for allspice dram, including tiki-style rum cocktails, punches, and some winter sours. It pairs especially well with aged rum, lime, orange, pineapple, and aromatic bitters. Because the strength and sweetness of homemade infusions differ from bottle to bottle, begin with about three-quarters of the dram quantity in the recipe, taste, and add more in small increments. For a drink that calls for 1/2 ounce (15 ml), start with 1 teaspoon (5 ml) to 1 tablespoon (15 ml), depending on how prominent you want the spice.
It also works in small amounts in baking: add a teaspoon to cake batter, fruit compote, or a glaze where rum and warm spice make sense. Stir it into a sauce only after removing the pan from the heat if you want its aroma to remain noticeable. This alcoholic substitute is for adults of legal drinking age; drink responsibly.
Variations
Make a quick cocktail-only stand-in: If there is no time to infuse a full batch, mix 1 ounce (30 ml) dark rum with 1/8 teaspoon (about 0.3 g) freshly ground allspice and 1 teaspoon (5 ml) simple syrup. Let it stand for 10 minutes, then strain through a coffee filter. This is a small, immediate workaround rather than a bottle-ready liqueur; the spice may be sharper and less integrated, so use it sparingly and taste before adding it to a drink.
Make a nonalcoholic allspice syrup: Simmer 1/2 cup (120 ml) water with 1/2 cup (100 g) sugar and 1 tablespoon (6 g) lightly cracked allspice berries for 5 minutes. Cool for 30 minutes, strain, and refrigerate. Use 1/2 to 1 ounce (15 to 30 ml) in a mocktail, adjusting the other sweet ingredients. It brings sweetness and allspice aroma but does not reproduce rum’s flavor or the alcoholic liqueur’s body.
Use another allspice dram: A different allspice liqueur is the closest direct replacement, but brands vary in sweetness, proof, and intensity. Start with a little less than the recipe asks for, then taste. If the available bottle is much sweeter, reduce another syrup in the drink; if it is less aromatic, a dash of aromatic bitters can add complexity, though it will not reproduce the same allspice character.
Shift the citrus note: Leave out the orange peel for a more direct allspice-and-rum profile, or use a strip of lemon peel for a brighter, sharper accent. Citrus peel is optional rather than essential to the substitute. Avoid including much white pith, which can add bitterness, and remove the peel after its final day in the infusion.
Storage and Reheating
Keep the infusion refrigerated in a sealed jar throughout its 7-day steep, and refrigerate the finished substitute promptly after mixing. Use a clean spoon or pour directly from the bottle rather than dipping into it. For best flavor, use the finished batch within 3 weeks. The aroma may gradually fade, and separation or a little spice sediment can occur; shake gently before measuring. Discard it if you see mold or notice unexpected fizzing or an off smell.
This is a drink ingredient, so reheating is not needed. If adding it to a warm sauce or dessert, measure out only what you need and stir it in near the end of cooking; prolonged heating can dull the allspice and rum aromas. Do not leave the bottle on the counter between uses. The nonalcoholic syrup variation should also be refrigerated and is best used within 1 week.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the closest substitute for St Elizabeth Allspice Dram?
Another allspice dram is the closest one-for-one option, although its sweetness and spice strength may differ. This homemade rum infusion is a practical alternative when you cannot find the bottle, but it is not an exact copy. Start with less than the recipe’s stated amount, then adjust after tasting.
Can I use ground allspice instead of whole berries?
Whole berries are strongly preferred because they infuse cleanly and are easy to remove. Ground allspice can turn the mixture cloudy, gritty, and more intense than intended. If necessary, use 1/2 teaspoon (about 1 g), steep for only 12 hours, and filter it carefully through a coffee filter before mixing with syrup.
Can I use this substitute right away?
The main recipe needs 7 days for the refrigerated rum infusion, plus 12 hours after blending for the flavors to settle. For a same-day drink, use the quick cocktail-only mixture in the Variations section. It is less rounded, so add it gradually rather than swapping it in at the full volume automatically.
How much homemade dram should I put in a cocktail?
Begin with about three-quarters of the amount of commercial dram listed, especially if your substitute has steeped for the full week or tastes very spicy. In a drink calling for 1/2 ounce (15 ml), try 1 teaspoon to 1 tablespoon first, then adjust. Cocktail balance depends on the other sweeteners, citrus, and rum in the recipe.
Can I make this without alcohol?
Yes. Make the allspice syrup variation and use it in mocktails or desserts. It provides sweetness and warm spice, but it will not have the rum notes or the same body as an alcoholic dram. Reduce other sweeteners in the drink if the syrup makes it too sweet.
Does homemade allspice dram substitute need to be refrigerated?
Yes. Refrigerate it while it infuses and after the syrup is added, keeping the container sealed between uses. The recipe recommends using the finished batch within 3 weeks for its best aroma. Refrigeration does not make the flavor identical to commercial dram, but it helps keep the homemade mixture in good condition.
Related
- Salmon Recipes on the Grill: Lemon-Dill Salmon
- Salmon Recipes in the Skillet: Crisp, Tender Fillets
- Salmon for People Who Hate Salmon: Crispy Bites
More recipes to cook
Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).