Substitute for Butter or Crisco: Ratios That Work in Baking

If you need a substitute for butter or Crisco, the simplest swaps are usually one cup for one cup, but the results will not be identical. Butter adds water and dairy flavor, while vegetable shortening is nearly all fat and tends to make baked goods softer and more tender, so a small liquid adjustment can help your recipe behave as expected.

Ingredients

To replace 1 cup (about 205 g) Crisco with butter: 1 cup (227 g) unsalted butter, softened if the recipe calls for creaming. If the recipe contains another liquid, hold back 1 tablespoon (15 ml) at first.
To replace 1 cup (227 g) butter with shortening: 1 cup (about 205 g) vegetable shortening, plus 2 tablespoons (30 ml) water or milk. Use the added liquid when the original recipe includes liquid; see the instructions if it does not.
Optional for the shortening-for-butter swap: ¼ teaspoon (1 ml) fine salt if using unsalted shortening in a recipe that depends on salted butter for seasoning. Add less if the recipe already contains plenty of salt.

Choose one substitution based on what your recipe calls for; these are separate options, not ingredients to combine. Weighing is useful, but the volume ratios are practical for everyday baking.

Instructions

Check which direction you are swapping. If the recipe calls for Crisco and you have butter, use the first ingredient option. If it calls for butter and you have shortening, use the second. Do not assume that a result made with one swap can be reversed with precisely the same adjustments: butter contains water and milk solids, while shortening does not.
Measure the replacement accurately. Use a level cup, not a loosely filled or heaped measure. For butter, pack it into a dry measuring cup or use the markings on the wrapper, then soften it only as much as the original method requires. For shortening, press it into the cup so there are no large air pockets, then level the top. If the recipe gives a weight, use that weight when possible and remember that a cup of butter weighs more than a cup of shortening.
When using butter instead of Crisco, start with less recipe liquid. Butter is roughly 15–18 percent water, whereas vegetable shortening is essentially fat. Keep the butter volume equal to the shortening volume, but reserve 1 tablespoon (15 ml) of the recipe’s milk or water for each cup of Crisco being replaced. Mix the dough or batter before deciding whether to add it back. If the recipe contains no other liquid, there is nothing to hold back; simply use the butter and expect a somewhat different texture.
When using shortening instead of butter, account for the missing water. Use the same volume of shortening as the butter amount, then add 2 tablespoons (30 ml) water or milk per cup of butter replaced. If the original recipe has enough liquid, add the measured amount gradually and stop when the dough reaches the consistency described. If it has no liquid at all, do not pour water into a creamed mixture automatically: the added water can make it separate or turn a cookie dough sticky. In that case, use shortening alone, accept a drier or more tender result, or choose another recipe-tested fat such as butter-flavored shortening.
Follow the original mixing method, then watch the dough. If the recipe says to cream butter and sugar, beat softened butter and sugar until light, but do not expect shortening and butter to aerate in exactly the same way. If it calls for cutting cold fat into flour, keep the replacement cold and work quickly. Stop mixing once the flour is incorporated, and use the recipe’s stated chilling and baking times as a starting point.
Check the first batch for doneness and spread. Butter can make cookies spread more and brown sooner; shortening can help them hold their shape and stay pale. Begin checking a few minutes before the recipe’s stated finish time, especially for cookies, and look for the recipe’s visual cues rather than relying only on the clock. For pastry, judge the crust by its color and structure; for cakes and quick breads, use the recipe’s usual doneness test.

Tips

Expect a flavor change. Butter contributes a familiar dairy aroma and browning from its milk solids. Plain shortening has a more neutral taste, so swapping it for butter can make cookies or pastry less rich-tasting. A pinch of salt or a little vanilla may round out a sweet recipe, but neither fully duplicates butter.
Do not melt butter unless the recipe asks for melted fat. A creaming recipe relies on softened, not liquid, butter to trap air with sugar. Melted butter can make cookies spread and can change cake texture. Shortening should also be used at the temperature and consistency specified by the method.
Keep pastry ingredients cold. In pie dough, biscuits, and scones, warm fat can blend too thoroughly into the flour. Chilled butter or shortening leaves small pieces that help create a flaky texture. If the dough becomes soft while shaping, cover and refrigerate it for 20–30 minutes before baking.
Make a small test batch for important recipes. A cup-for-cup swap is a useful starting point, not a promise of an identical result. If appearance matters, bake two or three cookies first and adjust chilling or liquid before baking the full tray. Avoid changing several ingredients at once, since it becomes harder to tell what affected the result.

Serving Suggestions

Use the butter-for-Crisco swap in familiar baked goods where a buttery taste is welcome: drop cookies, brownies, muffins, quick breads, and some cake batters. It is particularly convenient when the recipe uses creamed fat and sugar, though cookies may spread more and brown more deeply than they would with shortening. Let baked goods cool according to the recipe before moving them; tender cookies and pastry can break while hot.

For pie crust, biscuits, and other pastries, either fat can work, but the finished texture differs. Butter gives a rich flavor and a crisp, browned crust; shortening is easy to handle and can produce a tender, less buttery crust. If a recipe uses a blend of butter and shortening, replacing only the missing portion rather than changing the entire amount often preserves more of its intended balance. Serve pies and pastries as directed by their recipes, since fillings may need separate cooling time.

Variations

Use a half-and-half blend. If a recipe calls for 1 cup (227 g) butter and you have some butter plus shortening, use ½ cup (113 g) butter and ½ cup (about 103 g) shortening. This keeps some butter flavor while allowing the shortening to contribute a tender texture. Because the blend has less water than all butter, add liquid only if the dough seems dry and the recipe can accommodate it.

Try a neutral liquid oil for some cakes. In a moist cake or quick bread that calls for melted butter, a neutral oil such as canola or sunflower oil can sometimes replace it. Use about ¾ cup (180 ml) oil for each cup (227 g) butter as a starting point, since oil is pure fat and butter includes water. This is not a good general choice for creaming recipes, flaky pastry, or cookies that need solid fat to hold their shape. The crumb will usually be softer and the flavor less buttery.

Choose coconut oil selectively. Refined coconut oil has a mild flavor; unrefined oil tastes more distinctly of coconut. It is solid when cool and liquid when warm, so its behavior depends on room temperature. It can work in some cookies and pastry at a one-to-one volume starting point, but it may make baked goods firm or brittle when chilled. It is not an exact replacement for butter in recipes where butter’s water and milk solids are important.

For a dairy-free option, read the label. Vegan baking sticks are formulated to resemble butter more closely than many soft tub spreads. A firm baking stick can often be used in equal volume for butter, but water content and salt vary by product. Soft spreads may contain more water and can make dough greasy or cause excess spreading. Follow the package’s baking guidance when available, and adjust salt if the product is salted.

Storage and Reheating

Store butter in the refrigerator and follow its package guidance; keep shortening tightly covered in a cool, dry pantry according to its label. Do not leave either ingredient exposed to heat, moisture, or strong odors. If you have measured a replacement but have not mixed it into a recipe, return it to the correct storage promptly. Butter left at room temperature should not sit out for more than 2 hours.

For baked goods made with either swap, storage depends on the specific food. Keep plain cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for about 3–5 days if the recipe has no perishable filling. Refrigerate cakes or pastries with cream, custard, or another perishable topping within 2 hours and use them within 3–4 days. Freeze suitable baked goods for about 2–3 months for best quality, wrapped tightly and labeled; thaw in the refrigerator or at room temperature as appropriate. Reheat only when the recipe benefits from it, using a low oven briefly to refresh pastry. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours, and reheat leftovers to 165°F (74°C).

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use butter instead of Crisco in the same amount?
Usually, yes: start with 1 cup butter for 1 cup Crisco by volume. Butter has more water and milk solids, so baked goods may spread more, brown more, and taste richer. If the recipe contains milk or water, hold back 1 tablespoon per cup of Crisco and add it only if the mixture needs it.

How much Crisco replaces 1 cup of butter?
Start with 1 cup of shortening for 1 cup of butter. Butter contains water, so adding 2 tablespoons (30 ml) water or milk per cup can help replace that moisture when the recipe has room for extra liquid. The amount is a guide rather than a guaranteed fix; avoid adding it automatically to a dough with no other liquid, because the texture may become sticky or uneven.

Will cookies taste different if I swap butter and shortening?
Yes. Butter gives cookies a richer flavor and generally encourages more browning and spread. Shortening is milder and can make cookies thicker or more tender. Chilling the dough can reduce spreading in a butter-based swap, but it cannot make the flavor or texture exactly match the original.

Can I use margarine or tub spread instead?
Firm baking margarine or vegan baking sticks may work in many recipes, but check the label for fat content and salt. Soft tub spreads often contain more water, so they can make cookies spread excessively or pastry turn soft. Do not assume that all products sold as margarine are interchangeable with butter or shortening.

What is the best substitute for Crisco in pie crust?
Cold butter is the easiest widely available option and gives a flavorful, browned crust, though it may be less forgiving to handle as it warms. Use the same volume as the shortening, keep it cold, and avoid overworking the dough. A blend of butter and shortening can give you some butter flavor while retaining shortening’s easy handling.

Can I replace Crisco with oil?
Not as a universal one-to-one swap. Liquid oil cannot trap air in a creaming method and does not form the solid pieces needed for flaky pastry. It can work in certain cakes or quick breads designed for liquid fat, but use a recipe-specific conversion rather than substituting it blindly in cookies, biscuits, or pie dough.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).