Substitute for Butter Flavor Crisco: Easy 1-Cup Swap

A handy substitute for butter-flavor Crisco is plain vegetable shortening mixed with a little butter-flavor extract; use it cup for cup in most recipes. This quick blend keeps the firm, high-fat texture of shortening while adding buttery flavor, so it works especially well in cookies, pie crusts, frosting, and other baking.

Ingredients

1 cup (about 205 g) plain vegetable shortening
1/4 teaspoon (1.25 ml) butter-flavor extract, plus up to 1/4 teaspoon (1.25 ml) more to taste

Choose a neutral-tasting, solid vegetable shortening rather than liquid oil. Butter-flavor extract is sold in the baking aisle; its strength varies by brand, so begin with the smaller amount and check the bottle directions. This makes about 1 cup of substitute. It is an approximation, not an exact copy of a particular commercial shortening, and the flavor may be a little less pronounced.

Instructions

Measure the shortening. Spoon 1 cup (about 205 g) plain vegetable shortening into a small mixing bowl. If it is very firm, let it stand at room temperature for 5 to 10 minutes so it is easier to stir; it should remain solid, not melted.
Add the flavoring gradually. Drizzle in 1/4 teaspoon (1.25 ml) butter-flavor extract. Stir and press the shortening against the sides of the bowl with a flexible spatula until the extract is evenly distributed. Scrape the bowl so there are no concentrated streaks.
Adjust only if needed. Smell the mixture and, if you want a more noticeable butter note, stir in the remaining 1/4 teaspoon (1.25 ml). Extracts differ in intensity, so adding the full amount automatically can make some blends taste artificial.
Use or store. Measure the blend by volume as you would butter-flavor shortening. If a recipe calls for 1/2 cup, use 1/2 cup of this mixture; return any extra to a clean, airtight container.

Tips

Keep it solid for the closest texture. Shortening is solid at room temperature, while oil is liquid. Substituting oil changes how dough creams, holds air, and spreads, so it is not the best direct replacement when a recipe specifically calls for shortening. Do not melt this blend unless the recipe explicitly asks for melted fat.
Check the recipe’s salt before changing anything. This blend contains only the shortening and extract, so it does not add the salt that some butter-flavored products may contain. Follow the recipe’s salt quantity as written for the first batch. If you know your original product was salted and the result tastes flat, add a small pinch of salt to the blend next time, accounting for any salt already in the recipe.
Measure shortening without air pockets. Press it firmly into a dry measuring cup and level the top. For a recipe written by weight, use the weight requested for shortening rather than assuming that a cup of butter has the same weight. A scale makes partial amounts easier to measure consistently.
Do not over-flavor the batch. Butter-flavor extracts can have a strong, sometimes candy-like aroma when used generously. Start with 1/4 teaspoon per cup, especially for delicate pie dough or frosting, and increase in small increments. If the extract label gives a specific usage rate, use that as your guide.

Serving Suggestions

Use this replacement in the same kinds of recipes that call for butter-flavor Crisco. In drop cookies, it provides a shortening-style bite and helps the dough hold its shape; actual spread still depends on the recipe’s sugar, flour, and baking temperature. In pie pastry, cut the cold blend into the flour as directed, keeping the pieces small and distinct so the crust stays workable. For frosting, let the blend soften just enough to beat smoothly, then add the other ingredients in the order the recipe specifies.

It can also be used for savory baking when the recipe calls for shortening, such as biscuits or some dumpling doughs, but the butter aroma may be noticeable. For a savory dish where a buttery flavor is not wanted, plain shortening is a better choice. If using it to grease a baking pan, spread only a thin film; the added extract is intended for flavor and does not improve the pan’s nonstick properties.

Variations

Plain shortening, no extract: Use plain vegetable shortening one for one when you do not have butter flavoring. The texture will be close to a shortening-based original, but the finished food will taste more neutral. This is often perfectly suitable when the recipe has strong flavors such as chocolate, spices, or nuts.

Butter instead: In many cookies, cakes, and quick breads, use 1 cup (227 g) softened unsalted butter for each 1 cup of shortening. Butter contributes water and milk solids and melts differently, so the result can spread more, brown faster, and taste richer. Chill cookie dough if the recipe allows and watch the first baking batch closely. This is a flavor-forward alternative, not a texture-identical one.

Half shortening, half butter: For a middle ground, use 1/2 cup (about 103 g) shortening and 1/2 cup (113 g) butter in place of 1 cup of shortening. This gives more buttery flavor while retaining some of shortening’s structure. Expect more browning and possibly more spread than with the all-shortening blend.

Use butter extract sparingly: If you have only a concentrated butter-flavoring product rather than an extract, follow its label dose instead of assuming the amounts are interchangeable. Some flavorings are designed to be used in tiny drops. Too much can leave a sharp aftertaste, and adding extra liquid can affect a very precise dough or candy recipe.

Storage and Reheating

Transfer the mixture to a clean, dry, airtight container and keep it in a cool, dark cupboard, following the storage directions and date on the shortening and extract packages. For best flavor, use the blend within about 1 month; discard it sooner if it develops an off smell, unusual color, or any other sign of spoilage. Do not store it beside a warm oven or in direct sunlight, where it can soften and take on other odors.

You can refrigerate the blend in a sealed container for up to 3 months for quality, though it will become firmer. Let the amount you need stand briefly at room temperature before measuring or mixing; do not microwave it until melted if the recipe calls for solid shortening. Freezing is possible in a well-wrapped container for up to 3 months, but it may be less convenient to portion while frozen. Thaw it in the refrigerator, then let it soften slightly before use. This is a fat blend, not a cooked dish, so reheating is unnecessary.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I substitute this for butter-flavor Crisco one for one?
Yes. Replace the called-for amount by volume: use 1/2 cup of the blend for 1/2 cup of butter-flavor Crisco, for example. It is intended to match the solid shortening format and add a butter-like aroma. Differences in product salt and extract strength mean the flavor will not be perfectly identical.

Can I use regular butter instead?
Usually, but expect a different result. Butter contains water and milk solids, and it melts and browns differently from shortening. Cookies may spread more, crust may be less tender or flaky, and baked goods can have a richer flavor. If the recipe depends on a particular shape, try the shortening-and-extract blend first.

What if I cannot find butter-flavor extract?
Use plain shortening in the same amount and leave out the flavoring. The recipe should still get the structural effect of shortening, but it will not have the same buttery aroma. Butter can provide that flavor in many recipes, though it changes texture as described above.

Can I use this blend for frying?
It is better suited to baking and frosting recipes that specify butter-flavor shortening. Extracts are made for particular uses, and adding them to fat for frying can produce an unwanted flavor or aroma as the fat heats. Use an appropriate cooking oil or the recipe’s recommended frying fat instead.

Does this substitute contain dairy?
Plain vegetable shortening is generally made from vegetable fats, but ingredients and manufacturing practices vary, and butter-flavor extracts may have different formulations. Check both product labels for milk ingredients and allergen statements. If you are cooking for someone with a food allergy, do not rely on the words “butter flavor” alone to determine whether a product is suitable.

Should I add salt to the substitute?
Not automatically. Start with the salt specified in the recipe because the blend above is unsalted. If you are matching a product you know contained salt, a small pinch can help, but account for the recipe’s existing salt and taste the finished result before changing the amount for future batches.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).