Substitute for Butter Flavored Shortening: Best Swap

The most reliable substitute for butter flavored shortening is butter: use 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons (255 g) butter for every 1 cup (205 g) shortening called for. Butter adds a familiar buttery flavor, but its water content can make baked goods spread more and turn out less tender than they would with shortening.

This simple conversion works in many cookies, cakes, quick breads, and frostings, though the finished texture will not be identical. Use unsalted butter when possible so you can control the recipe’s salt, and follow the recipe’s directions for whether the fat should be softened, melted, or cold.

Ingredients

1 cup plus 2 tablespoons (255 g) unsalted butter, for each 1 cup (205 g) butter flavored shortening in the recipe

Instructions

Check the amount of shortening. Read the ingredient list and note how many cups of butter flavored shortening the recipe needs. This conversion is for each cup, so multiply the butter amount accordingly. For example, 1/2 cup shortening takes 1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoon butter (128 g); 2 cups shortening take 2 cups plus 1/4 cup butter (510 g).
Measure the butter by weight or volume. Weigh 255 g for each cup of shortening, or measure 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons using standard US measuring cups and spoons. If using stick butter, check the wrapper markings, which commonly show tablespoon measurements. Do not measure melted butter in a dry measuring cup unless the recipe specifically calls for melted fat.
Match the state of the fat to the recipe. If the recipe says softened shortening, use softened butter that yields to a light press but is not shiny or melting. For a recipe calling for melted shortening, melt the butter gently and let it cool until warm rather than hot before adding it. If the recipe calls for cold shortening, chill the measured butter and cut it into pieces as directed.
Adjust the salt only if needed. Unsalted butter keeps the recipe’s salt level predictable. If salted butter is all you have, use it and reduce the added salt by about 1/4 teaspoon for each 1/2 cup of butter, then consider the recipe’s other salty ingredients. The exact salt content varies among butter brands, so this is a practical estimate rather than a precise correction.
Use the butter in the recipe’s normal order. Cream softened butter with sugar when the recipe instructs you to cream the fat, or combine melted butter with the wet ingredients when that is the stated method. Do not add extra flour automatically; first follow the recipe as written, because changing flour can make the result dry or dense.
Watch the bake rather than relying only on the original time. Butter can cause dough to spread sooner and can brown more quickly than shortening. Begin checking a few minutes before the recipe’s stated finish time, and use the recipe’s visual cues—such as set centers or lightly browned edges—to decide when the food is done.

Tips

Expect a different texture. Shortening is nearly all fat and stays solid over a wider temperature range, while butter contains water and milk solids. That difference can produce more spread, crisper edges, and a less lofty or tender crumb. The swap gives a buttery flavor, not a perfect copy of shortening’s structure.
Start with cool, properly softened butter. Butter that is too warm can make cookie dough greasy and encourage excessive spreading. If the butter has become shiny or very soft, chill it briefly until it is pliable again rather than trying to compensate with extra flour.
For cookies that spread too much, chill the dough. If the recipe allows, refrigerate the mixed dough for 20 to 30 minutes before baking. This is a useful adjustment, not a guarantee that every cookie will keep the same shape; pan type, dough temperature, and the recipe’s sugar and flour ratios also affect spread.
Do not use oil as a direct equal-volume replacement. Oil lacks butter’s water and milk solids and is liquid at room temperature, so it can change both the dough’s structure and its handling. If you need a dairy-free option, use a solid plant-based baking stick formulated for baking, following its package directions, rather than assuming liquid oil will behave the same way.

Serving Suggestions

This is a baking substitution rather than a finished dish, so serve the result according to the recipe you are adapting. Butter works especially naturally in sugar cookies, drop cookies, brownies, muffins, quick breads, and simple cakes, where its flavor is welcome. For biscuits, pie crust, or other recipes that depend on a flaky or especially tender texture, the result may be less dependable because shortening behaves differently during mixing and baking.

If you are making cookies, let them cool on the baking sheet for the time specified by the original recipe before moving them; butter-rich cookies can be delicate while hot. Cakes and quick breads should cool in the pan only as long as the recipe recommends, then finish cooling on a rack if instructed. For frosting, taste before adding more sugar: butter contributes its own flavor and can make the frosting softer, so a brief chill may help it hold its shape.

Variations

For recipes that already use butter: If the ingredient list includes both butter and butter flavored shortening, replace only the shortening portion with the measured butter. The recipe will have a stronger overall butter character and may spread more, so avoid changing its existing butter amount at the same time.

For salted butter: Use the same total quantity, 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons (255 g) per cup of shortening, then reduce added salt modestly. If the recipe contains very little salt, or if the butter label gives a sodium amount, use that information to make a more considered adjustment. A small difference in salt is usually easier to manage than changing the fat-to-flour balance.

For a dairy-free bake: Replace the shortening with the same amount of a firm, unsalted plant-based baking stick if its package indicates it can be used for baking. Some spreads in tubs have more water and are softer, which may cause extra spread or a softer set. Check the ingredient label and keep the product cold or softened as the recipe requires.

For a closer shortening-style texture: The butter conversion is the simplest one-ingredient approach, but it cannot fully reproduce shortening’s high fat content and stable structure. In a recipe where shape is critical, such as decorated cookies, a better option may be to use plain vegetable shortening and add a small amount of butter extract only if desired and available. That preserves more of the shortening’s baking behavior, although the flavor will depend on the extract and will not be exactly the same as butter.

Storage and Reheating

Keep unused butter wrapped and refrigerated according to the package date and storage directions. For best quality, protect it from odors by keeping it in its wrapper or a covered container; freeze extra butter in a tightly wrapped package for up to about 6 months for best quality. Thaw frozen butter in the refrigerator, not on a warm counter. If you have measured more butter than the recipe needs, refrigerate it promptly and use it as you would ordinary butter.

Butter does not need reheating for this substitution. If the recipe requires melted butter, melt only what you need and let it cool to the temperature the recipe calls for before mixing. Do not leave butter or butter-based dough at room temperature for more than 2 hours; return it to the refrigerator sooner in a warm room. Storage times for the finished cookies, cake, or other bake depend on that specific recipe, so follow its guidance rather than applying butter storage times to the baked product.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace butter flavored shortening with butter one to one?

A one-to-one volume swap is often used in casual baking, but butter contains water and less fat by volume than shortening. For a closer fat-equivalent conversion, use 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons (255 g) butter for 1 cup (205 g) shortening. Even with that amount, the result may spread or brown differently, so check the bake a little early.

Will my cookies taste different?

Yes. Butter gives cookies a more recognizable buttery flavor, while butter flavored shortening generally contributes flavor without behaving exactly like butter. Expect possible changes in spread, edge crispness, and thickness. The size of the difference depends on the cookie recipe, how warm the dough is, and whether it is baked on a cool or warm tray.

Should the butter be melted or softened?

Use the form specified in the original recipe. Softened butter is generally used for creaming with sugar, while melted butter is used when the recipe asks for melted shortening. Substituting one form for another changes how the fat combines with the other ingredients, so do not melt butter simply to make measuring easier.

Can I use margarine or a tub spread instead?

A firm baking stick may work, but margarine and plant-based products differ in fat and water content. A soft tub spread is especially likely to make dough looser and baked goods spread more. Check whether the product is labeled for baking and use its package guidance; avoid assuming that every spread can be exchanged cup for cup.

What is the best substitute for butter flavored shortening in frosting?

Butter is a straightforward substitute when a buttery flavor suits the frosting. Use 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons butter for each cup of shortening, but expect a softer frosting with a more noticeable butter taste. Chill it briefly if it is too loose to spread or pipe, and add any extra powdered sugar gradually so the frosting does not become overly sweet or stiff.

Can I use this swap in pie crust or biscuits?

You can, but the texture may be less flaky or tender than the recipe intends. Shortening stays solid during mixing and can help create a particular crumb or layered structure. Keep the butter cold, handle the dough as little as possible, and follow the recipe’s chilling instructions. For the closest result in a recipe that depends strongly on shortening, use a solid shortening rather than butter.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).