Substitute for Butter When Baking: Ratios That Work

A reliable substitute for butter when baking is neutral oil: use ¾ cup (180 ml) oil for every 1 cup (227 g) butter in cakes, muffins, and many quick breads. The swap is simple, but oil cannot be creamed like solid butter, so cookies and pastries may turn out flatter, denser, or less flaky; choosing the right substitute depends on what you are making.

Ingredients

¾ cup (180 ml; about 165 g) neutral-flavored oil, such as canola, vegetable, or grapeseed oil, to replace 1 cup (227 g) butter

Instructions

Check how much butter the original recipe calls for and how it is used. This formula makes enough oil to replace 1 cup of butter. For a smaller amount, use 6 tablespoons (90 ml) oil in place of ½ cup (113 g) butter, or 3 tablespoons (45 ml) oil in place of ¼ cup (57 g) butter. These are practical starting ratios, not a claim that oil and butter behave identically.
Measure the oil into a small cup or bowl. Choose a neutral oil when you do not want an extra flavor in the finished bake. Canola, ordinary vegetable oil, and grapeseed oil are generally mild. Light olive oil can work in savory breads or strongly flavored cakes, while extra-virgin olive oil has a more noticeable taste.
Add the measured oil at the point when the recipe adds its fat, then follow the recipe’s mixing order as closely as possible. If the instructions call for melting butter, add the oil directly. If they call for creaming softened butter with sugar, mix the oil and sugar until evenly combined, but do not expect the mixture to become pale and fluffy: liquid oil does not trap air in the same way solid butter does.
Bake at the original recipe’s stated temperature and begin checking for doneness at its usual time. The substitute does not require cooking on its own. Look for the recipe’s normal visual or texture cues, such as a set center or a tester coming out with a few moist crumbs for a cake. The exact result depends on the batter and the other ingredients, so avoid adding extra flour or liquid unless the recipe itself calls for it.

Tips

Use oil mainly in moist batters. Cakes, muffins, pancakes, and quick breads are usually the most forgiving places to make this swap. Their batters can incorporate liquid fat without relying on distinct pieces of cold butter for their structure. The crumb may feel more tender or moist, and the flavor will be less buttery.
Do not use the same assumption for every cookie. Butter creamed with sugar helps create air and affects how cookies spread. Oil can make many cookie doughs softer and the baked cookies thinner or denser. If you want to try it, start with a small batch and chill the dough only if the original recipe’s texture allows it; chilling will not make oil behave exactly like solid butter.
Keep the oil flavor in mind. A strong-tasting oil can take over a delicate vanilla cake or shortbread-style bake. For chocolate, spice, citrus, or savory recipes, a more distinctive oil may suit the other flavors. If in doubt, use a neutral oil and save flavorful oils for recipes that specifically benefit from them.
Match the substitute to the recipe’s job for butter. Butter contributes fat, some water, milk solids, flavor, and structure. A straight oil swap supplies fat but does not reproduce all of those qualities. For flaky pastry, laminated dough, or a recipe that depends on solid butter pieces, use a solid baking fat rather than trying to correct the dough by adding extra water.

Serving Suggestions

Use the oil ratio in recipes where a soft, moist crumb is welcome. It is a practical option for a simple loaf cake, banana bread, muffins, snack cake, or many boxed cake mixes. In a chocolate cake or spiced muffin, the other strong flavors can make the difference in buttery flavor less noticeable. For a plain vanilla cake, expect a cleaner, less rich taste and consider adding flavor already suited to the recipe, such as vanilla, citrus zest, or warm spices, rather than increasing the oil.

Oil-based bakes can be pleasant at room temperature because the fat stays fluid instead of firming as butter does. Serve cakes and muffins according to their recipe, once they have cooled enough to slice without crumbling. For savory quick breads, this substitute can work with herbs, cheese, or vegetables, but keep any added ingredients within the original recipe’s proportions so the batter does not become too wet. If serving a bake with a spread, choose one that complements the recipe; the substitute itself does not need to be served separately.

Variations

Use a dairy-free baking stick for a closer texture. If avoiding dairy is the goal and a solid fat is important, choose a plant-based baking stick labeled for baking and use the package or recipe’s one-for-one guidance. Baking sticks are formulated to be firmer than many tub spreads. The finished flavor and spread can still differ from dairy butter, so check whether the product is salted and adjust added salt in the recipe only when appropriate.

Try coconut oil where its texture and flavor suit. Refined coconut oil has a mild flavor; unrefined coconut oil tastes more distinctly of coconut. It is solid when cool and liquid when warm, so its state matters if a recipe asks for softened or melted butter. It may help in some cookies or quick breads, but it is not a guaranteed one-for-one match for a carefully developed pastry recipe.

Use shortening for some cookies and pastry. Vegetable shortening is solid and can be substituted for butter by volume in some recipes, but it has little of butter’s flavor and a different water content. Cookies may spread less, and the texture can be more tender or crumbly. Follow a recipe designed for shortening when possible, especially for delicate pastry.

Choose applesauce only when a lower-fat texture change is acceptable. Unsweetened applesauce is sometimes used to replace part of the fat in moist cakes or muffins, but it is not a direct fat-for-fat substitute. It adds water and fruit flavor, and a bake can become heavier or more cake-like. If experimenting, replace only part of the butter at first rather than swapping all of it, and do not use applesauce for flaky pastry or crisp cookies.

Storage and Reheating

This formula is measured oil, so it does not need to be cooked, chilled, or assembled in advance. Store the oil in its original closed container according to its label, in a cool, dark place, and use it by the date and quality guidance on the package. Keep measuring spoons and cups dry; water or food crumbs in the container can affect the oil. If you have measured a portion into a clean, covered container, use it promptly in the recipe rather than treating it as a prepared, long-term butter substitute.

There is nothing to reheat before using the oil. Add it at the stage specified in the original baking recipe. If a baked item made with the substitute remains, let it cool and store it according to that item’s recipe; many cakes and muffins keep covered at room temperature for about 2 to 3 days, while items with perishable fillings or toppings should be refrigerated. Refrigerate perishable foods within 2 hours. Reheat an individual slice only if you prefer it warm, using a brief low-power microwave interval so it does not dry out; reheating is optional, not part of making the substitute.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace butter with oil in any baking recipe?

No. Oil is most useful in moist batters and less dependable in recipes that rely on butter’s solid state, such as laminated pastry, pie crust, or cookies that need creaming for lift. It also changes flavor and spread. When a recipe’s texture depends on chilled, softened, or whipped butter, choose a solid baking substitute or a recipe developed for oil instead.

How much oil replaces one stick of butter?

One US stick is ½ cup (113 g) butter. Use 6 tablespoons (90 ml) oil as a starting conversion. Measuring by volume is convenient, but the finished result will not exactly match butter because butter contains water and milk solids as well as fat. If the recipe is especially sensitive to texture, a solid butter alternative is a safer choice.

Should I add water to make up for the water in butter?

Not automatically. The ¾-cup oil ratio is intended as a practical baking substitution, and adding water without accounting for the whole recipe can make the batter too loose or change its structure. Some recipes may need adjustments, but those should come from a tested version of that specific recipe rather than a universal extra-liquid rule.

Can I use olive oil instead of butter in a cake?

Yes, if the flavor works with the cake. A mild or light olive oil will be less noticeable than extra-virgin olive oil. Use ¾ cup (180 ml) oil for each 1 cup (227 g) butter, and expect a softer, less buttery result. Olive oil is often a natural match for citrus, chocolate, or spice flavors, while a delicate vanilla cake may show its taste more clearly.

Is margarine a one-for-one substitute for butter?

A solid margarine or plant-based baking stick can often replace butter in equal amounts, but check its label and texture. Tub spreads tend to contain more water and can make baked goods spread or soften differently. For cookies, pastry, or a recipe that calls for creaming, use a firm product intended for baking rather than assuming every spread will behave alike.

Why did my cookies spread or turn dense after using oil?

Butter is solid at room temperature and can hold air when creamed with sugar; oil is liquid and cannot create that same structure. As a result, an oil-based cookie may spread more, feel denser, or have a different chew. Use a recipe written for oil, try a solid baking stick, or test the substitution on a small portion before committing the whole batch.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).