Substitute for Sour Cream in Casserole: What Works Best

Plain Greek yogurt is the easiest substitute for sour cream in a casserole: use it in the same amount, and choose full-fat yogurt for the creamiest result. This American-style chicken, broccoli, and rice casserole uses yogurt in a savory sauce that bakes up creamy without needing sour cream.

Ingredients

2 cups (320 g) cooked long-grain rice, cooled or warm
3 cups (420 g) cooked chicken, cut into bite-size pieces
2 cups (180 g) small broccoli florets, steamed until just tender and drained well
1 cup (245 g) plain full-fat Greek yogurt
⅓ cup (80 ml) milk
¼ cup (55 g) mayonnaise
1½ cups (170 g) shredded sharp cheddar cheese, divided
1 tablespoon (15 g) Dijon mustard
2 teaspoons (10 ml) lemon juice
1 teaspoon (3 g) garlic powder
¾ teaspoon (4.5 g) fine salt
¼ teaspoon (0.5 g) black pepper
½ cup (30 g) panko breadcrumbs
1 teaspoon (5 ml) olive oil

Instructions

Heat the oven to 375°F (190°C). Lightly grease a 2-quart (about 1.9-liter) casserole dish. Have the rice and chicken cooked before you begin; this recipe is designed to use prepared ingredients rather than cook raw rice or chicken in the casserole.
In a large bowl, whisk together the Greek yogurt, milk, mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, lemon juice, garlic powder, salt, and pepper until smooth. The sauce will be thicker than a sauce made with sour cream alone, but the milk loosens it so it can coat the rice and chicken. Whisk gently rather than beating vigorously; a smooth mixture is easier to distribute evenly.
Add the rice, chicken, broccoli, and 1 cup (115 g) of the cheddar to the bowl. Fold until the rice and vegetables are coated and the chicken is spread throughout. Break up any compacted clumps of rice with a fork. If the mixture seems unusually stiff, stir in another tablespoon or two of milk, just enough to make it easy to spread without turning it soupy.
Spoon the mixture into the prepared dish and level it gently. In a small bowl, combine the panko with the olive oil and the remaining ½ cup (55 g) cheddar. Scatter this topping evenly over the casserole. Keep the topping loose rather than pressing it down, so it browns instead of forming a dense layer.
Bake uncovered for 25 to 30 minutes, until the edges are bubbling and the topping is golden. Check the temperature in the center with a food thermometer; because the cooked chicken is being reheated, USDA FSIS guidance is to heat leftovers and casseroles containing cooked poultry to 165°F (74°C). If the top browns before the center reaches that temperature, loosely cover the dish with foil and continue baking, checking again after a few minutes.
Take the casserole out when it is hot throughout and the center has reached 165°F (74°C). Serve while warm. The sauce will look soft and creamy rather than sharply separated; a little bubbling around the edge is normal.

Tips

Use plain yogurt, not flavored. Unsweetened Greek yogurt is the closest easy swap because it is thick and tangy. Regular plain yogurt can work, but it is thinner; strain it through a fine sieve or clean cloth for 20 to 30 minutes, or reduce the milk slightly so the casserole does not become watery.
Choose full-fat for a forgiving sauce. Lower-fat yogurt is more prone to looking grainy when heated, especially in an acidic sauce. Full-fat yogurt and the mayonnaise in this recipe help give the filling a rounded, creamy texture. Do not boil the sauce on the stovetop before baking.
Drain vegetables carefully. Broccoli that carries water into the dish can thin the sauce. If using frozen broccoli, thaw it completely, drain it, and pat it dry. Cut large florets into smaller pieces so each serving gets an even mix of rice, chicken, and vegetables.
Season the components, not just the topping. Cooked chicken and rice can vary in saltiness. Taste the yogurt sauce before mixing, then adjust the salt and pepper to suit the ingredients you have. If the chicken is already strongly seasoned, start with less salt.

Serving Suggestions

Serve this casserole as a complete weeknight meal, or pair it with a crisp green salad dressed with vinaigrette to balance the rich, cheesy topping. Steamed green beans, roasted carrots, or a bowl of sliced tomatoes also make easy sides. If you want a little freshness at the table, offer chopped parsley or sliced scallions for sprinkling over individual portions; these add color and a mild herbal or onion note without changing the creamy base.

The casserole is filling, so modest portions alongside a vegetable side are usually enough. For a larger meal, add warm rolls or crusty bread to catch any sauce left on the plate. If serving a group, place the hot baking dish on a heat-safe surface and spoon portions directly from it. Let guests add extra black pepper or a squeeze of lemon at the table rather than adding more acid to the whole dish, which can make the yogurt sauce taste sharper.

Variations

Swap the protein. Use an equal amount of cooked turkey instead of chicken. For a meatless version, replace the chicken with 2 cups (300 g) of drained, rinsed white beans or chickpeas. Beans make the casserole heartier and have a softer texture; fold them in gently so they stay mostly whole. Confirm that any cooked poultry used has been stored safely and reheat the finished dish to 165°F (74°C).

Try another sour-cream substitute. An equal amount of full-fat plain regular yogurt can replace Greek yogurt, though it may make the filling looser. For a richer, less tangy result, use 1 cup (225 g) of blended cottage cheese; blend it until smooth before mixing, and add milk gradually because cottage cheese moisture varies. A dairy-free plain yogurt can also work if it is unsweetened and thick, but flavor and baking texture depend on the product, so check the casserole’s center temperature and expect a slightly different finish.

Change the vegetables or cheese. Replace the broccoli with 2 cups (150 g) of thawed, well-drained peas, chopped cooked cauliflower, or a mixture of finely chopped vegetables. Monterey Jack gives a milder, stretchier topping, while a small amount of Parmesan adds a saltier, more savory flavor. Keep the total amount of vegetables similar; adding a lot more can release extra moisture and soften the topping.

Make it gluten-free. Use certified gluten-free panko or replace the breadcrumbs with ⅓ cup (35 g) of crushed gluten-free crackers. The crumb texture may be finer and a little less crisp, but the topping still adds a pleasant contrast. Check packaged ingredients such as mustard and breadcrumbs if you need to avoid a particular ingredient.

Storage and Reheating

Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours of baking. Transfer them to a covered, shallow container, or cover the casserole dish once it has stopped steaming heavily, and keep it refrigerated for 3 to 4 days. The topping softens as it sits, but the filling should remain creamy. For easier reheating, divide the casserole into individual portions before storing.

Reheat a portion in the microwave, covered loosely, stirring or turning it partway through if practical; heat until the center reaches 165°F (74°C). To reheat a larger amount in the oven, cover the dish with foil and warm it at 350°F (175°C) until the center reaches 165°F (74°C), removing the foil near the end if you want to restore some crispness. Reheating time varies with portion size and whether the casserole is cold from the refrigerator, so use a thermometer rather than relying only on the surface looking hot.

You can freeze cooled portions in airtight, freezer-safe containers for about 2 to 3 months for best quality. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before reheating, and heat to 165°F (74°C). The broccoli and yogurt sauce may be a little softer after freezing and thawing, and the breadcrumb topping will lose its original crunch; adding fresh toasted crumbs after reheating can improve the texture. Do not leave the casserole at room temperature for more than 2 hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace sour cream with Greek yogurt in a casserole?

Yes. In most casseroles, plain Greek yogurt can replace sour cream in a one-to-one amount. It has a similar tang and a thick consistency, though it can taste slightly sharper and may look grainy if heated too aggressively. Full-fat yogurt, gentle mixing, and baking rather than boiling help keep the sauce smooth.

What is the best substitute if I do not have Greek yogurt?

Plain regular yogurt is a practical choice; strain it first if it is runny, or reduce the other liquid in the recipe. Blended cottage cheese works when you want a mild, creamy filling, while crème fraîche is a close rich substitute if it is available. Mayonnaise alone is not an ideal one-for-one replacement because it is much richer and does not have the same tang or dairy texture.

Will yogurt curdle when baked?

It can become grainy if exposed to very high heat, a lot of acidity, or prolonged boiling, but it generally works well in a casserole baked at a moderate temperature. Use plain full-fat yogurt, mix it with the other sauce ingredients before adding it, and avoid boiling the mixture. Some slight texture variation is possible, but it should still be safe and enjoyable when cooked as directed.

Can I assemble this casserole ahead of time?

For the best topping, mix the filling and bake it soon after assembly. You can assemble it up to one day ahead, cover it, and refrigerate it; keep the panko topping separate and add it just before baking so it does not absorb moisture. A cold casserole may need extra oven time, so check the center with a thermometer and make sure it reaches 165°F (74°C).

Can I use uncooked rice or raw chicken in this recipe?

No. The quantities and baking time here assume cooked rice and cooked chicken. Uncooked rice needs a measured amount of liquid and a longer covered cooking method, while raw chicken requires a different preparation and a verified safe temperature. Use fully cooked ingredients for this version, then heat the casserole’s center to 165°F (74°C) before serving.

Why is my casserole watery?

Excess liquid usually comes from wet broccoli, thin regular yogurt, or adding too much milk. Drain and pat vegetables dry, use thick yogurt when possible, and add milk gradually until the filling is coated but still holds its shape. If the casserole is already baked, let it stand briefly before serving; the rice and other ingredients may absorb a little of the loose moisture, though the texture will not change dramatically.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).