Substitute Sour Cream for Oil in Box Cake Mix: A Guide

Yes, you can substitute sour cream for oil in box cake mix: use the same volume of sour cream as the oil called for on the package. It makes a moist, tender cake with a slightly denser crumb and a gentle tang, though it will not taste or feel exactly like a cake made with oil.

Ingredients

1 box plain cake mix, about 15.25 oz (432 g); choose any flavor and check the package directions before starting.
1/2 cup full-fat sour cream (120 g), replacing 1/2 cup oil. If your box calls for a different amount of oil, use that same volume of sour cream instead.
3 large eggs (about 150 g without shells), or the number listed on your box if it differs.
1 cup water (240 ml), or the amount listed on your box if it differs.
1 teaspoon vanilla extract (5 ml), optional, especially useful with vanilla, yellow, or chocolate cake mix.
Nonstick cooking spray, about 1 teaspoon (5 ml), for greasing the pan.

Instructions

Prepare the pan and oven. Read the cake mix package first, since box sizes, pan options, and ingredient amounts vary. Set a rack in the center of the oven and heat it to the temperature specified on the package; 350°F (177°C) is common for a 9-by-13-inch (23-by-33-cm) cake. Coat the pan lightly with cooking spray. If the package calls for a different temperature or pan, follow those directions.
Measure the sour cream swap. Find the oil quantity in the box directions and measure the same volume of sour cream. For the standard version here, that is 1/2 cup (120 g). Spoon sour cream into a dry measuring cup and level it rather than estimating by eye. Full-fat sour cream gives the softest, richest crumb. It may look thicker than oil, but do not thin it automatically; the water and eggs in the mix help loosen the batter.
Mix the batter. Put the cake mix, sour cream, eggs, water, and optional vanilla in a large bowl. Mix according to the package directions, usually on low until the dry mix is moistened, then on medium for the stated time. Stop when the batter looks smooth and evenly combined. Scrape the bowl once if dry mix is clinging to the sides, but avoid prolonged beating, which can make the baked cake tougher. A sour-cream batter may be a little thicker than the oil version; that is expected.
Fill the pan and bake. Scrape the batter into the prepared pan and spread it into an even layer, nudging it into the corners. Bake for about 30 minutes, or use the package timing for your pan and begin checking at its earliest suggested time. The edges should be set and lightly pulling from the sides; a toothpick inserted near the center should come out clean or with a few moist crumbs, not wet batter. Since this batter contains eggs, the USDA FSIS safe minimum for egg dishes is 160°F (71°C), checked with a food thermometer; a finished cake’s center is usually hotter than that minimum. If the center is still wet, bake in 2- to 3-minute increments and check again.
Cool before serving. Set the pan on a heat-safe rack and leave the cake to cool for at least 45 minutes before cutting or frosting. The center continues to settle as it cools, and frosting a hot cake can make the topping melt or slide. For neat squares, let it cool completely; for a simple warm dessert, serve after the 45-minute rest without frosting.

Tips

Match the oil amount, not a universal ratio. Many mixes call for 1/2 cup oil, but some call for 1/3 cup or another amount. Substitute sour cream one-for-one by volume for the amount printed on your particular box. Do not add extra sour cream just because the batter looks thicker than usual.
Choose full-fat sour cream when possible. It generally produces a more tender result than fat-free sour cream, which can make the cake a little less rich or change the texture. Reduced-fat sour cream can still work in the same amount. Plain, unsweetened Greek yogurt is a reasonable same-volume alternative, but it may give the crumb a tangier flavor and slightly firmer texture.
Do not overmix or overbake. Mix only as long as the package directs, and start checking the cake at the package’s earliest bake time. Sour cream contributes moisture, but it cannot prevent a cake from drying out if it stays in the oven too long. Use the toothpick and visual cues together rather than judging by a browned edge alone.
Let the cake cool before covering it. Trapping steam under a lid while the cake is still hot can make the surface sticky. Cool it first, then cover it well. If you plan to frost it, wait until the center and edges are no longer warm.

Serving Suggestions

Serve squares plain, with a light dusting of powdered sugar, or with a simple glaze. The subtle tang of sour cream is especially pleasant with vanilla, lemon, spice, and chocolate cake mixes. For a casual dessert, add fresh berries or sliced stone fruit alongside each piece; the fruit brings freshness without weighing down the tender crumb.

For a more celebratory cake, use the frosting recommended on the box or a frosting that suits the flavor. Cream cheese frosting pairs naturally with spice or carrot-style mixes, while chocolate frosting works well with chocolate or yellow cake. Spread frosting only over a fully cooled cake. If serving a frosted cake, cut it into 12 squares with a clean knife, wiping the blade between cuts for tidier portions.

Variations

Make it citrusy. Add 1 teaspoon (5 ml) finely grated lemon or orange zest to the batter, or use a citrus-flavored mix. Zest adds aroma without changing the liquid balance. A little citrus glaze can reinforce the flavor after the cake cools.
Add chocolate. Fold 1/2 cup (85 g) mini chocolate chips into the finished batter. Tossing the chips with a teaspoon of the dry cake mix before folding them in can help distribute them, though some may still settle. Keep the amount modest so the cake bakes evenly.
Use yogurt instead. Replace the sour cream with 1/2 cup (120 g) plain Greek yogurt for the standard recipe, or use the same volume as the oil amount on your box. Choose unsweetened yogurt. It tends to be tangier and may make the cake slightly less rich, so avoid flavored or sweetened yogurt unless you want its flavor in the finished cake.
Try a different pan. Cupcakes or round layers can be made if the cake mix package gives directions for those pans. Divide the batter evenly and use the package’s pan-specific temperature and baking range; smaller cakes bake faster than a 9-by-13-inch cake. Do not fill cupcake liners more than about two-thirds full, and check early rather than assuming the sheet-cake timing applies.

Storage and Reheating

After baking, cool the cake and refrigerate it within 2 hours. Store it covered in the pan or in an airtight container; it keeps well for 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. If it is frosted, check that the frosting is suitable for refrigeration and keep the cake covered so it does not pick up refrigerator odors. A tightly wrapped unfrosted cake can also be frozen for about 2 to 3 months for best quality. Thaw it, still wrapped, in the refrigerator, then frost after it has fully thawed.

This cake does not need reheating. For a softer serving, let an individual slice stand at room temperature briefly before eating, and do not leave the cake out for more than 2 hours. If you choose to warm a leftover slice, heat it until the center reaches 165°F (74°C), the USDA guidance for reheated leftovers; use short microwave bursts and expect the texture to become softer. Refrigerate any uneaten portion promptly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace oil with sour cream in any boxed cake mix?
It works with most standard cake mixes, including vanilla, yellow, chocolate, spice, and lemon. The exact result depends on the mix and the amount of oil its directions call for. Use the same volume of sour cream as oil, and follow the package’s egg, water, pan, and baking instructions unless they differ from the specific standard amounts in this recipe.

Will the cake taste like sour cream?
Usually, it will not taste strongly of sour cream. The flavor is mild, and its slight tang tends to blend into the cake, especially in chocolate or spice varieties. A simple vanilla cake may have a little more noticeable tang, but the overall flavor remains that of the mix you chose.

Does sour cream make the cake more moist?
It often gives the crumb a moist, tender feel because it contributes water and dairy fat. The cake can also be a little denser than one made with oil, since sour cream is thicker and does not behave exactly like liquid oil. Bake only until the center is set; extra oven time is the likeliest cause of a dry result.

Can I use low-fat or fat-free sour cream?
Yes, use the same volume, but expect a possible texture difference. Full-fat sour cream is the most dependable option for a rich, tender crumb. Low-fat versions may produce a less rich cake, while fat-free sour cream can make the texture less tender. Avoid adding more to compensate, because changing the ratio may leave the center gummy.

Should I reduce the water when I add sour cream?
Not as a standard adjustment. The recipe replaces the oil with sour cream while keeping the water and eggs called for by the mix. If your particular package has different instructions, use its listed quantities and swap only the oil. The batter being thicker than an oil-based batter is normal; if it is unusually stiff, check your measurements before adding anything.

Can I use this swap in a layer cake or cupcakes?
Yes, provided you use the pan instructions for that mix and divide the batter evenly. Layers and cupcakes usually bake for less time than a sheet cake, so begin checking at the earliest time on the package. Let layers cool completely before stacking, and make sure cupcakes are set in the middle before removing them from the pan.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).