Tamari Soy Sauce Substitute: Easy Homemade Mix

This tamari soy sauce substitute is a quick, pourable blend of coconut aminos, salt, rice vinegar, and mushroom powder for adding salty, savory flavor to everyday cooking. It is useful when you are out of tamari or need a soy-free option, though it will be a little sweeter and less deeply fermented than tamari itself.

Tamari is a Japanese fermented soy seasoning, and products differ in saltiness and ingredients; some contain wheat, so check the label if that matters for your meal. This small-batch substitute is ready in minutes and works best when added gradually and tasted as you cook.

Ingredients

1/2 cup (120 ml) coconut aminos
1 teaspoon (5 ml) unseasoned rice vinegar
1 teaspoon (about 2 g) dried mushroom powder
1/2 teaspoon (about 3 g) fine sea salt

This makes about 1/2 cup, or eight 1-tablespoon portions. The ingredients are intentionally simple: coconut aminos provide a dark, savory base with a mild sweetness, salt brings the seasoning closer to tamari, and vinegar keeps the blend from tasting flat. Mushroom powder adds an earthy savory note. If your mushroom powder is coarse, it may settle slightly; a quick shake before using fixes that.

Instructions

Combine the base. Pour the coconut aminos into a small jar or bowl. Add the rice vinegar, mushroom powder, and fine sea salt. A jar with a tight-fitting lid is convenient because you can mix and store the substitute in the same container.
Mix until evenly seasoned. Whisk for about 30 seconds, or cap the jar and shake it vigorously. Check that there are no clumps of mushroom powder stuck to the bottom or sides. The salt may not disappear instantly; keep stirring until it is mostly dissolved.
Let the flavors settle. Leave the mixture for 5 minutes so the mushroom powder can hydrate and its flavor can spread through the liquid. Stir or shake once more. The finished sauce should be pourable, savory, and a little sweet, with no sharp vinegar smell.
Taste and adjust for your use. Try a small drop rather than tasting a spoonful of the concentrated sauce. If it needs more salt, add another small pinch, mix, and taste again. If it seems too salty or intense, stir in 1 teaspoon (5 ml) water at a time. Use it in place of tamari, starting with the amount your recipe calls for and adjusting the finished dish to taste.

No cooking is required. The 5-minute rest is included in the total time; if you are in a hurry, you can use the mixture immediately, although the mushroom flavor may be more noticeable after it has had a few minutes to hydrate. Because coconut aminos vary by brand, the final balance is best judged in the dish rather than by expecting a perfect spoon-for-spoon match to every bottle of tamari.

Tips

Check labels for dietary needs. This version contains no soy-based seasoning, but packaged coconut aminos and mushroom powder can have different manufacturing and ingredient statements. Check each label for allergens or gluten concerns. Tamari itself is often wheat-free, but not every product is; the label is the reliable guide.
Adjust salt in small increments. Coconut aminos are usually sweeter and less salty than tamari, but sodium levels vary. The recipe includes a modest amount of salt rather than trying to match every brand. If you are making a reduced-sodium dish, begin with half the salt and add more only after tasting.
Use finely ground mushroom powder. A fine powder blends more smoothly than chopped dried mushrooms. If you only have dried mushrooms, grind a small piece in a clean spice grinder and measure the powder, or leave it out; the sauce will be less earthy but still useful.
Season the whole recipe, not just the substitute. Tamari often contributes salt as well as flavor. When replacing it in a soup, stir-fry, dressing, or marinade, hold back some other salt at first, then taste the finished food and add more if needed. This avoids making a dish too salty when other ingredients are already seasoned.

Serving Suggestions

Use this blend in the same kinds of dishes where you would reach for tamari, but add it gradually. Start with a 1:1 replacement in a recipe that calls for a small amount, then taste before adding more. In a quick stir-fry, add it near the end so you can judge the seasoning after the vegetables or protein have released their juices. It also works in fried rice, noodle bowls, brothy soups, and savory sauces.

For a dipping sauce, combine 1 tablespoon of the substitute with 1 teaspoon water and taste before adding anything else. A squeeze of lemon or lime can brighten it, while a little sesame oil adds a toasted aroma but also changes the flavor and introduces sesame. For a salad dressing or marinade, whisk it with oil, a little vinegar, and any aromatics already called for in your recipe. Keep the sauce separate from raw ingredients until you are ready to cook or serve.

Since the mixture has a milder, sweeter profile than many tamaris, it is especially handy when tamari is a background seasoning rather than the main flavor. If a recipe depends on the bold, fermented taste of tamari—such as a simple dipping sauce—expect a noticeable difference and adjust with a little extra mushroom powder or salt only if the dish needs it.

Variations

For the closest simple swap: Use regular soy sauce in equal measure if soy and wheat are suitable for your needs. It will generally be saltier and more sharply fermented than this coconut-aminos mixture, so taste before adding extra salt. This is often the most direct option when the only issue is that you have run out of tamari.

For a gluten-free soy option: Use a certified gluten-free soy sauce in place of tamari if its label meets your requirements. It contains soy, unlike the recipe above, and its flavor and salt level can differ by brand. Start with the recipe’s stated quantity and adjust the finished food rather than adding extra seasoning automatically.

For a soy-free version without mushroom powder: Omit the mushroom powder if mushrooms are unsuitable or you do not have any. The result will be thinner in flavor and somewhat sweeter, so use it in dishes with other savory ingredients, such as garlic, ginger, or browned vegetables. Do not add a large amount of salt at once to compensate; add a pinch, taste, and repeat as needed.

For a deeper, rounder note: Add 1/4 teaspoon (about 1 g) unsulfured molasses, whisking until it disappears. This makes the substitute darker and slightly sweeter, so it is a better fit for a cooked sauce or marinade than for a delicate dipping sauce. Keep the change small because too much molasses can dominate the coconut aminos.

For a sharper finish: Increase the rice vinegar by 1/2 teaspoon (2.5 ml) if the mixture will go into a rich or oily dish. This adds brightness but will make the sauce more acidic, so skip the increase when using it in a light broth or a recipe that already contains citrus or vinegar.

Storage and Reheating

Transfer the substitute to a clean, tightly covered jar and refrigerate it within 2 hours of mixing. Keep it refrigerated and use it within 5 to 7 days for the best flavor; this homemade blend has no commercial preservatives, and the storage period is intentionally shorter than that of many unopened bottled sauces. Write the preparation date on the jar if you are likely to forget when you made it. Discard it if it develops an unusual smell, visible mold, or an unexpected change in appearance.

Shake or stir before each use because mushroom powder can settle. You do not need to reheat the sauce by itself. If you want it warm for a dip or dressing, warm only the portion you plan to use gently in a small pan or microwave-safe cup, then add it to the meal. Do not leave the jar at room temperature for extended periods, and return it to the refrigerator promptly after pouring.

For longer storage, freeze small portions in an ice cube tray, then transfer the frozen cubes to a labeled freezer-safe container. Use within about 2 to 3 months for best flavor. Thaw a portion in the refrigerator or add a frozen cube directly to a hot sauce or pan, allowing it to melt and mix thoroughly. Do not repeatedly thaw and refreeze the same portion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace tamari with this mixture in equal amounts?

Use an equal amount as a starting point in cooked dishes, then taste and adjust. Coconut aminos are often sweeter and less salty than tamari, so the finished food may need a little more salt. In a dipping sauce or recipe where tamari is the main flavor, the difference will be more obvious than in a dish with several other seasonings.

Is tamari always gluten-free?

No. Many tamari products are made without wheat, but ingredients and manufacturing practices vary, and some products contain wheat. Read the package label and look for an appropriate gluten-free certification if you need one. The homemade recipe uses coconut aminos instead, but packaged ingredients should still be checked individually.

Is coconut aminos the same as tamari?

No. Coconut aminos are a separate seasoning with a generally sweeter, milder taste, while tamari is a fermented soy seasoning with a more pronounced savory character. This recipe adds salt, vinegar, and mushroom powder to make coconut aminos more useful as a stand-in, but it does not recreate tamari’s fermentation or make the two products identical.

What can I use if I do not have coconut aminos?

If soy and wheat are acceptable, use regular soy sauce or a suitable gluten-free soy sauce instead; either can replace tamari directly, though salt levels may differ. If you need to avoid soy, coconut aminos are the central ingredient in this particular homemade alternative. There is no exact pantry replacement that will taste identical, so choose a seasoning that fits your dietary needs and adjust the recipe carefully.

Can I make a larger batch?

Yes. Multiply each ingredient by the same amount and mix in a clean container, keeping the proportions consistent. A larger batch is convenient, but make only what you can use within 5 to 7 days unless you freeze it in small portions. Stir or shake well before measuring, especially if the mushroom powder has settled.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).