Best Meat for Steak Tartare: Cuts, Quality and Safety

The best meat for steak tartare is very fresh, whole-muscle beef tenderloin, trimmed and hand-cut just before serving. It is tender, mild, and easy to dice finely; however, the cut alone cannot make raw beef safe, so careful sourcing, cold handling, and an understanding of the risks matter just as much.

What to Look For

Choose intact, whole-muscle beef from a butcher or supplier who can tell you when it was cut, how it was handled, and whether it is intended to be eaten raw. Ask for a freshly cut piece and trim it yourself. Do not assume that “steak tartare quality,” “sushi grade,” or a clean appearance is a regulated safety guarantee; those labels do not establish that meat is free of harmful bacteria.

Whole muscle, not ground beef: Bacteria can be mixed throughout ground meat during processing. Tartare should be made from an intact cut, with the exterior trimmed away and the interior diced with clean equipment. Trimming reduces some surface contamination risk but does not eliminate it.
Freshness and cold handling: Buy from a reputable source, keep the beef refrigerated at 40°F (4°C) or below, and prepare it shortly before serving. Avoid meat with an off smell, sticky texture, damaged packaging, or an uncertain history.
Leanness and texture: A tender, lean cut is easier to chop into neat, distinct pieces. Excessive fat or connective tissue makes the mixture chewy or greasy.
Clean, sharp tools: Hand-chopping with a clean knife gives control over texture and avoids the extra handling of a grinder. Wash hands and sanitize the board, knife, and work surface before and after contact with raw meat.
Risk awareness: Raw beef can contain pathogens even when it looks and smells normal. People who are pregnant, young children, older adults, and anyone with a weakened immune system should choose a cooked beef dish instead. For the lowest food-safety risk, cook beef to the USDA FSIS safe minimum of 145°F (63°C) and rest it for 3 minutes; that temperature changes tartare into a cooked preparation.

Beef Tenderloin

Strengths: Tenderloin is exceptionally tender, mild in flavor, and low in connective tissue. Its even shape is convenient for trimming and cutting into small, uniform cubes. It is a dependable choice when a soft, delicate tartare is the goal.

Trade-offs: It is usually the most expensive option and can taste less beefy than more worked muscles. Do not pay a premium solely for a “tartare” label; ask about handling and freshness instead.

Best for: First-time tartare makers and anyone prioritizing tenderness and a clean, mild flavor. Buy a small, intact piece and prepare it immediately before serving.

Top Sirloin

Strengths: Top sirloin offers a good balance of beef flavor, tenderness, and price. It is generally lean enough for tartare, and a well-trimmed piece can be cut into tidy cubes without the cost of tenderloin.

Trade-offs: It can be firmer and more variable than tenderloin. Remove the fat cap, silverskin, and any tough connective tissue carefully; ask the butcher for a tender, evenly shaped piece rather than a pre-ground product.

Best for: Cooks who want a flavorful, practical middle ground and are comfortable trimming a cut themselves.

Beef Strip Loin

Strengths: Strip loin, also sold as New York strip, has a pronounced beef flavor and a fairly fine texture when trimmed well. It is widely available and can make a more robust-tasting tartare than tenderloin.

Trade-offs: The exterior fat and occasional bands of connective tissue need to be removed. Its chew can vary, so choose a tender piece and cut across the grain before dicing.

Best for: Those who prefer a stronger beef flavor and can spend a few minutes trimming. It is often a sensible choice when tenderloin feels too mild or costly.

Beef Eye of Round

Strengths: Eye of round is lean, widely available, and often less expensive than tenderloin or strip loin. A fresh, carefully trimmed piece can be diced small for a lean tartare.

Trade-offs: This hardworking muscle is notably firmer and less forgiving. Remove all silverskin, chill the meat until firm but not frozen, and use a very sharp knife to cut it into small pieces. Chopping does not make questionable meat safe.

Best for: Budget-conscious cooks who value leanness and are willing to do careful trimming. It is not the best pick if a soft, buttery texture is your priority.

Beef Top Round

Strengths: Top round is another lean, relatively economical whole-muscle option. It has a straightforward beef flavor and can work when sourced fresh and trimmed thoroughly.

Trade-offs: It is less tender than tenderloin and may have more connective tissue. Choose a compact piece, remove tough seams, and dice finely. If the butcher cannot confirm the cut’s handling or freshness, select another preparation rather than taking a chance.

Best for: Experienced cooks looking for a lower-cost alternative who are prepared to inspect and trim the meat closely.

How to Choose

For the easiest texture: Choose tenderloin. The higher price buys tenderness and less trimming, not a guarantee of safety. For a more affordable balance, ask about top sirloin or strip loin. Eye of round and top round can lower the cost, but they require more trimming and tend to be firmer.

For flavor: Tenderloin is mild; sirloin and strip loin taste beefier. Round cuts are lean and direct in flavor but can seem less tender. Keep the seasoning simple enough to complement the meat: salt, pepper, and finely minced shallot are common choices. Traditional garnishes vary; capers, mustard, Worcestershire sauce, and egg yolk are optional, not requirements.

For the occasion: If serving guests, ask about dietary restrictions and tell them plainly that the dish contains raw beef. Consider offering a cooked alternative. Do not serve raw tartare to people at higher risk from foodborne illness, or to anyone who would rather avoid raw meat.

For handling: Keep the meat cold during shopping and preparation, and do not leave it at room temperature for more than 2 hours total (1 hour if the temperature is above 90°F/32°C). Prepare only what you expect to serve and serve it promptly. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours, but raw tartare is best eaten the day it is made; discard leftovers rather than saving them for another meal. Freezing does not reliably make raw beef safe.

If you cannot confirm that the meat is intact, freshly handled, and kept cold, do not use it raw. Cook it instead: whole cuts of beef should reach 145°F (63°C) measured with a food thermometer and rest for 3 minutes, per USDA FSIS guidance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use supermarket steak?
Possibly, if it is a fresh, intact whole cut with a reliable handling history and has stayed properly refrigerated. Ask the meat department about freshness and handling. Ordinary packaging and a “premium” label do not guarantee suitability for raw consumption.

Is ground beef safe for tartare?
No. Do not use ordinary ground beef for raw tartare because grinding can distribute bacteria throughout the meat. Use a whole-muscle cut, trim the outside, and hand-chop it with clean tools.

Should I grind the beef or chop it by hand?
Hand-chopping is preferable for control over texture and avoids passing the meat through a grinder. If you use a grinder, its parts must be thoroughly cleaned and sanitized, and the beef must remain cold; grinding still does not remove food-safety risks.

Does freezing make beef safe to eat raw?
No. Freezing is not a reliable way to kill all harmful bacteria in beef. It may firm the meat for easier cutting, but it does not replace careful sourcing and handling.

Can I prepare tartare ahead?
It is best chopped and served promptly. Keep it refrigerated until serving, and do not leave it out beyond the food-safety time limits. Avoid storing leftovers; discard any that have been left out too long.

Is tenderloin always the best choice?
It is the easiest choice for tenderness, but not automatically the best for everyone. Sirloin or strip loin can offer more flavor for less money, while round cuts suit a tighter budget if you accept a firmer result and more trimming.

Bottom Line

For most people choosing a cut, fresh, intact beef tenderloin is the top pick for steak tartare because it is tender, mild, and straightforward to prepare. Top sirloin is the best all-around alternative when price and beefy flavor matter more; whichever cut you choose, prioritize a trustworthy source, cold handling, clean preparation, and the fact that raw beef carries food-safety risk.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).