Eye Fillet Steak Recipes: Pan-Seared and Tender

This pan-seared eye fillet steak is a tender beef dinner finished with garlic, thyme, rosemary, and a quick butter baste. The cut is also known as beef tenderloin or filet in some places; this simple method gives two steaks a browned crust without masking their mild, delicate flavor.

Ingredients

2 eye fillet steaks, about 1¼ inches (3 cm) thick and 6 ounces (170 g) each
¾ teaspoon kosher salt (about 4 g)
½ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper (about 1 g)
1 tablespoon olive oil (15 ml)
2 tablespoons unsalted butter (28 g)
1 garlic clove, lightly crushed (about 3 g)
2 fresh thyme sprigs (about 2 g)
1 small rosemary sprig (about 1 g)
½ teaspoon lemon juice (2.5 ml), for finishing

Instructions

Prepare the steaks. Take the steaks from the refrigerator while you gather the other ingredients; there is no need to leave them out until they reach room temperature. Pat every surface dry with paper towels so the meat sears rather than steams. Sprinkle the salt and pepper over both sides and the edges. Set aside while you prepare the pan and aromatics, about 12 minutes total for the preparation.
Heat the pan. Choose a heavy skillet large enough to hold both steaks with a little space between them. Heat it over medium-high for about 3 minutes, then add the olive oil and swirl to coat. The oil should look fluid and shimmer, but it should not be smoking heavily. If the steaks will touch or crowd the pan, cook them one at a time; crowding lowers the pan temperature and makes a good crust harder to achieve.
Sear the first side. Lay the steaks in the pan away from you to reduce splashes. Leave them undisturbed for about 2½ minutes. A steak that has formed a crust will release more readily when lifted; if it sticks, give it another 20 to 30 seconds rather than pulling at it. Turn each steak with tongs and sear the second side for about 2½ minutes.
Brown the edges and baste. Use the tongs to hold each steak on its edge for about 30 seconds per edge, browning the narrow sides as well. Lower the heat to medium, then add the butter, crushed garlic, thyme, and rosemary. When the butter foams, tilt the skillet slightly and spoon the melted butter over the steaks for about 2 minutes. Keep the butter foaming gently, not darkening or burning; reduce the heat if it begins to smell acrid.
Check doneness with a thermometer. Insert an instant-read thermometer sideways into the center of the thickest part of each steak, avoiding the pan and any large seam of fat. For whole cuts of beef, the USDA FSIS safe minimum is 145°F (63°C), followed by a rest of at least 3 minutes. If a steak has not reached 145°F (63°C), keep cooking it in 30-second increments, checking again after each interval. Thickness and pan temperature affect the timing, so the thermometer—not the clock—determines when it is ready.
Rest and finish. Transfer the steaks to a warm plate or board and rest for 5 minutes, which exceeds the required 3-minute rest. Spoon a little of the herb butter over each steak and add the lemon juice just before serving. Resting lets the temperature even out and helps limit juices running onto the plate when you cut the meat. Serve whole or slice across the grain.

Tips

Dry the surface well. Moisture on the outside delays browning, so blot the steaks thoroughly before seasoning. If the steaks have been salted well ahead, keep them refrigerated and uncovered only if your refrigerator is clean and the meat is protected from contact with other foods.
Use a suitable pan and give the steaks space. Cast iron or stainless steel holds heat well. A nonstick pan can work at a moderate heat, but it may not produce the same deep crust, and it should not be heated empty over high heat. For a small skillet, cook the steaks separately and use half the oil and butter for each round.
Adjust for thickness, not just weight. Two steaks of the same weight can cook at different speeds if one is broad and thin. The timings here suit steaks about 1¼ inches (3 cm) thick; check earlier for thinner steaks, and allow extra time for thicker ones. Use a thermometer in each steak because they may not be exactly alike.
Make a simple substitution if needed. If fresh thyme and rosemary are unavailable, use ½ teaspoon dried thyme (about 0.5 g) in place of the fresh herbs. Dried herbs taste more concentrated and will not give quite the same fresh aroma, so avoid adding a large extra handful. Ghee can replace butter, though it gives a less milky, more toasted finish.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the steaks promptly with the pan butter spooned over the top. A potato side is a natural match: try mashed potatoes, roasted baby potatoes, or crisp fries to catch the savory butter. For a lighter plate, add green beans, asparagus, or broccolini, cooked until tender-crisp, and a leafy salad dressed with a sharp vinaigrette. The acidity in the salad or a squeeze of lemon balances the rich butter without competing with the beef.

For a more substantial dinner, pair each steak with a baked potato and a green vegetable, or put thin slices over warm polenta. Keep the sides ready before the steaks go into the pan: eye fillet is best served soon after its short rest, and it will cool while waiting for vegetables to finish. If serving sliced steak, cut it just before it reaches the table and arrange the slices with any resting juices. A spoonful of horseradish sauce or Dijon mustard on the side is an easy extra, but neither is necessary for the herb-butter version.

Variations

Make a peppercorn finish: After transferring the steaks to rest, carefully pour off excess fat, leaving about a teaspoon in the pan. Add ¼ cup (60 ml) beef stock and 1 teaspoon crushed peppercorns (about 2 g), scrape up the browned bits, and simmer for 2 to 3 minutes. Stir in 2 tablespoons (30 ml) cream if desired and simmer briefly until lightly thickened. This makes a small pan sauce; do not pour it over the steaks until they have rested.

Try a mustard-herb butter: Mix 1 tablespoon softened butter (14 g) with 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard (5 g) and 1 teaspoon finely chopped parsley (about 1 g). Place a small dab on each steak after resting instead of using the garlic-herb butter. It gives a tangier finish and avoids adding mustard to the hot pan, where it can scorch.

Use a grill instead: Oil the steaks lightly and grill over medium-high direct heat, turning once or as needed to brown both sides. Grill marks alone do not confirm doneness, so check the center with a thermometer and use the same 145°F (63°C) safe minimum temperature and 3-minute minimum rest. Outdoor grills vary in heat, so expect the timing to differ from the skillet method.

Change the herbs: Swap the thyme and rosemary for 1 tablespoon chopped parsley (about 4 g) stirred into the melted butter after cooking. Parsley tastes fresher and milder, and adding it at the end keeps its color. For a bolder finish, add a small pinch of chili flakes, but keep the amount modest so the seasoning does not overwhelm the beef.

Storage and Reheating

Refrigerate leftover steak within 2 hours of cooking, in a covered shallow container. It keeps for 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. Store any pan sauce separately if possible, since keeping the meat submerged can soften its seared exterior. If you do not expect to eat the leftovers within that time, freeze them in an airtight freezer-safe container; for best texture, use within about 2 to 3 months and thaw overnight in the refrigerator.

Reheating can make a tender cut firmer, so use gentle heat and avoid cooking the steak for a long time. Put slices in a covered skillet with a teaspoon of water or stock and warm them over low heat, turning once. For food safety, leftovers should reach 165°F (74°C) when reheated; check the thickest pieces with a thermometer. You can also reheat a whole steak in a low oven until it reaches that temperature, then add a little butter or sauce. Do not leave cooked steak at room temperature for an extended period, and discard it if it has been unrefrigerated for more than 2 hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is eye fillet the same as filet mignon?

Eye fillet is a name commonly used in Australia and New Zealand for a portion of beef tenderloin. Filet mignon generally refers to a steak cut from the smaller end of the tenderloin, while naming and butchery can vary by country and butcher. For this method, choose evenly thick steaks about 1¼ inches (3 cm) thick.

How do I know when eye fillet steak is done?

Use an instant-read thermometer inserted into the center of the thickest part. This recipe follows the USDA FSIS safe minimum for whole beef cuts: 145°F (63°C), followed by at least a 3-minute rest. Color and firmness are less reliable indicators because lighting, cut, and cooking conditions can change how a steak looks.

Can I cook eye fillet steak from frozen?

For the most even sear and predictable timing, thaw the steaks in the refrigerator before cooking, ideally overnight in a covered container. If cooking from frozen, the outside can brown before the center is safely cooked, so this skillet timing will not apply. A separate method designed for frozen steaks and frequent thermometer checks is a better choice.

Why did my steak turn out tough?

Eye fillet is naturally tender, but it can become firmer if cooked well beyond the desired temperature or sliced immediately without resting. Check the center with a thermometer and remove the steak once it reaches the safe minimum, then give it the full rest. Also slice across the visible direction of the muscle fibers rather than along them.

Can I make the steaks ahead?

They are at their best just after cooking and resting, so prepare the sides and seasonings ahead rather than searing the meat hours in advance. You can mince the garlic and measure the herbs earlier, then keep them covered in the refrigerator. Cooked steaks can be stored and reheated safely, but reheating to 165°F (74°C) may make the texture less tender.

What if I do not have a meat thermometer?

A thermometer is the dependable way to verify that a whole cut of beef reaches the USDA FSIS safe minimum. Timing, touch, or cutting into the center cannot confirm the temperature accurately. If you cook steak often, an instant-read thermometer is a useful tool; until you have one, do not treat the times in this recipe as a safety guarantee.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).