Fall Old Fashioned Recipe with Maple, Apple and Bitters

A fall Old Fashioned is a bourbon cocktail stirred with maple syrup, apple cider, and aromatic bitters, then served over a large ice cube with an orange or apple garnish. The cider brings a mellow apple note while maple rounds out the whiskey, making a seasonal variation that stays spirit-forward rather than tasting like a sweet punch.

Ingredients

2 fl oz bourbon (60 ml)
1/2 fl oz fresh, nonalcoholic apple cider (15 ml), not hard cider
1 tsp pure maple syrup (5 ml)
2 dashes aromatic bitters (about 1 ml)
1 large ice cube, about 2 1/2 inches (6 cm) wide, for serving
1 strip orange peel, about 2 inches (5 cm) long, for garnish
1 thin apple slice, about 1/8 inch (3 mm) thick, for garnish
Ice cubes for stirring, about 1 cup (140 g)

Instructions

Prepare the glass and garnish. Put a large ice cube in a rocks glass. Cut a strip of orange peel, avoiding as much of the white pith as possible, and slice the apple just before serving so it has less time to brown. Set the glass aside while you mix the drink.
Measure the cocktail. Add the bourbon, apple cider, maple syrup, and aromatic bitters to a mixing glass. Use a small spoon to loosen the maple syrup if it clings to the bottom; it should be dispersed before you start stirring.
Stir with ice. Add about 1 cup (140 g) of ice cubes to the mixing glass. Stir steadily for about 30 seconds, until the drink is thoroughly chilled and the maple syrup is blended. The ice will also add a little water, which softens the whiskey and brings the flavors together.
Strain and garnish. Strain the drink into the prepared rocks glass over the large cube. Hold the orange peel over the glass, skin facing down, and gently twist it to release its fragrant oils. Rub the peel lightly around the rim, then add it and the apple slice to the glass. Serve right away.

Tips

Choose the cider carefully. Use fresh, nonalcoholic apple cider, sometimes sold as unfiltered apple juice. It should taste like apples, not vinegar or fermentation. If you only have clear apple juice, use the same amount; the result will be lighter and less rounded. Do not substitute hard cider unless you want a different, more sparkling drink.
Adjust the sweetness in small steps. Maple syrups vary in intensity, and some ciders are noticeably sweeter than others. Start with the listed teaspoon, stir, and taste before adding more. If you prefer a drier drink, reduce the maple syrup to 1/2 teaspoon (2.5 ml); adding extra cider to compensate can make the cocktail less whiskey-forward.
Stir, rather than shake. A stirred drink keeps a clear appearance and develops controlled dilution. Shaking can make it cloudy, aerate it, and over-dilute it if you shake for too long. Stir the drink with plenty of firm ice, then strain it off that ice onto a fresh large cube.
Keep the garnish simple. A thin apple slice and expressed orange peel add aroma without crowding the drink. Remove seeds from the apple slice, and avoid leaving the garnish in the glass for a long time before serving. If you do not have a fresh apple, the orange peel alone is a good garnish.

Serving Suggestions

Serve this cocktail in a small rocks glass, with the large cube sitting below the surface of the drink. A large cube melts more slowly than a handful of small cubes, so the drink remains balanced longer as you sip it. Chill the glass briefly if you like, but it is not essential; a room-temperature glass works well when the cocktail is properly stirred and poured over cold ice.

The apple and maple notes pair naturally with savory fall snacks: aged cheddar, toasted nuts, crisp crackers, or a small plate of roasted squash. For a meal, offer the cocktail before dinner alongside a few bites rather than serving it as a sweet dessert drink. Its bourbon base and bitters make it rich enough to stand up to salty or smoky flavors, while the cider gives it a fresh apple aroma.

For a gathering, make each drink to order if possible, so the ice dilution stays consistent. If you are serving several people, set out the bourbon, cider, maple syrup, bitters, and measured bar spoons, then stir each portion separately. This is an alcoholic drink for adults of legal drinking age; enjoy responsibly.

Variations

Use rye whiskey. Replace the bourbon with 2 fl oz (60 ml) rye whiskey. Rye usually tastes drier and more peppery, so the apple and maple may seem less prominent. Keep the other measurements the same for the first drink, then adjust the maple by a small amount if needed.

Make it less sweet. Reduce the maple syrup to 1/2 teaspoon (2.5 ml), or omit it for a more spirit-forward cocktail. Maple adds a distinct woodsy sweetness; plain simple syrup can replace it in the same small amount, but the drink will lose that maple character. Avoid adding a large pour of syrup at once, since it is harder to correct an overly sweet drink.

Add a little more spice. Use 1 dash of aromatic bitters and 1 dash of orange bitters in place of the 2 dashes of aromatic bitters. Orange bitters emphasize the citrus garnish and can make the apple seem brighter. Bitters brands differ in strength, so keep the total to two dashes until you know how the blend tastes.

Try a warming spice garnish. Add a short cinnamon stick as an optional garnish, or briefly stir the drink with it before serving. It lends a gentle baking-spice aroma without changing the basic recipe. Do not add ground cinnamon directly to the cocktail; it tends to float in clumps rather than dissolve smoothly.

Make a zero-proof version. Replace the bourbon with 2 fl oz (60 ml) of a nonalcoholic whiskey-style spirit. Keep the cider, maple, and bitters, but taste before adding more syrup because nonalcoholic alternatives vary in sweetness and spice. The result will have a different body and finish from bourbon, but the apple-maple combination still makes a flavorful seasonal drink.

Storage and Reheating

This cocktail is best made and served immediately. Once it has been stirred with ice and poured into the glass, the cube continues to melt, gradually diluting the drink. Do not store a finished cocktail with ice for later; it will lose its intended balance, and the apple garnish can brown.

If you want to prepare ahead, combine the measured bourbon, cider, maple syrup, and bitters in a clean, covered container and refrigerate it promptly. Keep it chilled and use it within 24 hours for the freshest apple flavor, stirring or shaking the container gently before pouring because maple can settle. Refrigerate the mixture within 2 hours of preparation, and do not leave it sitting out for an extended period. Add fresh ice and garnish only when serving. Reheating is not appropriate for this drink.

Frequently Asked Questions

What kind of apple cider should I use?
Use nonalcoholic apple cider or unfiltered apple juice from the refrigerated or juice section. The wording varies by shop and region, so check that the bottle is not labeled hard cider or alcoholic cider. Clear apple juice works as a substitute, though it tends to taste lighter and less tart.

Can I make this with a different whiskey?
Yes. Rye whiskey makes a drier, spicier drink, while a softer bourbon keeps the cocktail round and mellow. Irish whiskey can also work, but its lighter profile may let the cider stand out more. Start with the same 2 fl oz (60 ml) amount and taste before changing the sweetener.

Can I make a batch for a party?
Yes, but mix the drink ingredients without ice and keep the batch covered in the refrigerator. For four servings, combine 8 fl oz (240 ml) bourbon, 2 fl oz (60 ml) cider, 4 teaspoons (20 ml) maple syrup, and 8 dashes of bitters. Stir the batch before pouring, then measure about 2 3/4 fl oz (80 ml) per glass and serve each over a fresh large cube with its own garnish. Make the batch the day you plan to serve it for the best cider flavor.

Why is my cocktail too sweet?
The cider may already be sweet, or the maple syrup may be particularly rich. Reduce the syrup to 1/2 teaspoon (2.5 ml) next time and keep the cider at 1/2 fl oz (15 ml). For a drink already mixed, add a small splash of bourbon and stir; adding more bitters can increase spice, but it will not remove sweetness.

Do I need a large ice cube?
No, but it is useful because it melts more slowly than several small cubes. If you only have regular cubes, strain the cocktail over a few of them and serve promptly. Avoid using the ice from the mixing glass, which has already melted and diluted the drink while it was being stirred.

Can I leave out the bitters?
You can, but bitters bring the dry, aromatic edge that keeps the apple and maple from making the drink taste like sweetened whiskey. If you do not have aromatic bitters, use orange bitters in the same amount for a brighter citrus note. The result will be a variation rather than the same flavor profile.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).