Sour Cream Substitute for Baking: Baking Powder Tips

For most baking, replace sour cream with the same volume of plain, full-fat Greek yogurt; thin it with a little milk if needed. Baking powder is not a sour cream substitute: it makes baked goods rise, while sour cream adds moisture, richness, and acidity.

Ingredients

1 cup (245 g) plain, full-fat Greek yogurt, unsweetened
1 tablespoon (15 ml) whole milk, optional, for loosening the yogurt to a sour-cream-like consistency

Instructions

Spoon the Greek yogurt into a small bowl. Check that it is plain and unsweetened; flavored yogurt can add sweetness or aromas that do not belong in many cakes, muffins, biscuits, or savory bakes.
Whisk the yogurt briefly until smooth. Greek yogurt is often thicker than sour cream, so add the milk a teaspoon at a time only if the recipe needs a looser mixture. Stop when it is easy to scoop and measure, not runny.
Measure the amount called for in your recipe and use it in place of sour cream at a 1:1 ratio by volume. For example, use 1 cup of this mixture for 1 cup of sour cream. If you added milk, measure the needed amount after mixing rather than pouring extra into the batter.
Keep the recipe’s baking powder or baking soda quantity unchanged at first. The yogurt contributes acidity, but the leavener has its own job; changing it without a tested formula can affect rise and texture. Mix the batter only as much as the original recipe directs.

Tips

Choose the right yogurt. Plain, full-fat Greek yogurt is thick and rich, making it a convenient 1:1 stand-in. Low-fat yogurt can work, but the finished bake may be less tender or rich. Avoid sweetened yogurt, and check the label for added flavors before measuring.
Adjust thickness, not the leavener. If your yogurt is so thick that it is difficult to blend into the batter, stir in the optional milk gradually. Do not use baking powder to thin, sour, or otherwise imitate sour cream; it cannot supply dairy moisture or fat.
Pay attention to baking soda. Many recipes use an acidic ingredient such as sour cream to react with baking soda. Greek yogurt is also acidic, so a direct swap is often suitable. Keep the listed soda amount, especially in a recipe you have not adapted before, rather than adding extra to compensate.
Mix gently once flour is added. Yogurt can make a batter feel thicker than one made with sour cream. That alone is not a reason to add liquid. Overmixing can develop gluten and make cakes or muffins tough, so follow the recipe’s mixing directions and stop when the ingredients are combined.

Serving Suggestions

This substitute is meant to go into a recipe, not to be served as a finished dip or topping. Use it in cakes, muffins, quick breads, pancakes, coffee cakes, and many biscuit or scone doughs that call for sour cream. It also works in savory batters and baked casseroles when the sour cream is mixed into the dish before baking.

For a recipe with a delicate texture, such as a very light cake, follow the recipe’s cues as well as its measurements. A batter made with Greek yogurt may look a little thicker, and the finished crumb may be slightly less rich than one made with full-fat sour cream. The substitution is generally easiest in sturdy everyday bakes, where the other ingredients and mixing method also shape the result.

If you are using the mixture in a dip, sauce, or as a cold topping, taste it first. Greek yogurt is tangier and usually less rich than sour cream. A pinch of salt or herbs may suit a savory dip, but those additions are not part of this baking substitute and should not be added to a sweet batter.

Variations

Use plain whole-milk yogurt. Regular whole-milk yogurt can replace sour cream in many baked recipes at the same volume. It is thinner than Greek yogurt, so omit the optional milk. If the batter seems loose, do not automatically add flour; check the recipe’s expected consistency and avoid changing several ingredients at once.

Use plain Greek yogurt without thinning. In muffins, quick breads, and many cakes, the yogurt can go straight into the bowl in a 1:1 volume swap. Choose this option when the recipe can handle a thick batter or when it will be mixed with other liquids. The result may be a little denser or tangier than the sour-cream version.

Try a non-dairy yogurt. Unsweetened, plain, thick plant-based yogurt can work in some recipes, but its fat level, acidity, and water content vary by product. Use one with a texture close to Greek yogurt and try it first in a forgiving bake such as muffins. It may change browning, flavor, or tenderness, so it is not an exact match.

Use cottage cheese for a smooth, rich alternative. Blend plain cottage cheese until smooth, then measure it cup for cup. It is less tangy than sour cream and can be thicker, so a small splash of milk may help. This option is useful in baked dishes and hearty batters, but its flavor and texture can be noticeable in delicate cakes.

Storage and Reheating

Prepare only what you need when possible. If you have leftover yogurt mixture, transfer it promptly to a clean, covered container and refrigerate it; do not leave dairy at room temperature for more than 2 hours. Keep it cold at 40°F (4°C) or below and use it within 3 days, or sooner if the yogurt’s package instructions or use-by date call for it. Stir before measuring because a little liquid may separate.

There is no need to reheat the substitute on its own. If you have mixed it into a batter, bake that batter according to the original recipe rather than storing it for later; leavening can lose effectiveness while batter sits. Store finished baked goods according to their recipe, since storage depends on ingredients and whether they contain a perishable filling or topping. Refrigerate perishable finished dishes within 2 hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use baking powder instead of sour cream?
No. Baking powder is a chemical leavener that helps a batter rise; it does not provide the moisture, fat, or tang of sour cream. Use plain Greek yogurt or another suitable dairy substitute for the sour cream, and keep the recipe’s baking powder amount as written.

Should I add more baking powder when I use Greek yogurt?
Usually not. Greek yogurt is acidic, much like sour cream, and can react with baking soda in a recipe. Leave both baking powder and baking soda at the amounts listed unless you are following a recipe specifically formulated for a different substitution. Extra leavener can cause a fast rise followed by a collapse, or leave an unpleasant taste.

Is the substitution one cup for one cup?
Yes, for many cakes, muffins, quick breads, and similar recipes, use the same volume of plain Greek yogurt as sour cream. If you thin the yogurt with milk, measure the final mixture. A 1:1 swap is a practical starting point, though the bake may be slightly tangier or less rich.

Can I use nonfat Greek yogurt?
You can, but expect a possible difference in texture. Nonfat yogurt has less fat than sour cream, so cakes or muffins may turn out less tender or rich. If that is the yogurt you have, use it plain and start with a 1:1 swap; adding extra oil or butter is not necessary unless the recipe has been adjusted for it.

Can I use this in frosting or as a topping?
It is best suited to recipes where sour cream is mixed into a batter or baked dish. Greek yogurt is more tart and may be thinner or less rich in a frosting or topping, which can affect both taste and consistency. For a topping, plain sour cream or a recipe designed specifically for yogurt is a more predictable choice.

Can I make the substitute ahead?
You can mix it shortly ahead and keep it covered in the refrigerator, but there is little advantage to preparing it far in advance. Use it within 3 days, follow the yogurt’s date guidance, and stir it before measuring. For best results in a bake, add it to the batter when the recipe calls for it.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).