Substitute for Butter or Margarine in Baking: Best Uses

For cakes, muffins, and quick breads, neutral oil is a dependable substitute for butter or margarine: use ¾ cup (180 ml) oil for every 1 cup (227 g) of butter. Oil keeps baked goods moist, but it does not trap air like softened butter, so the best choice depends on what you are baking and how the original recipe mixes its fat.

Ingredients

1 cup (227 g) butter or stick margarine from the original recipe, to be replaced
¾ cup (180 ml) neutral oil, such as canola, sunflower, or light olive oil

Instructions

Check how the recipe uses its fat. This oil conversion works best in cakes, muffins, brownies, and quick breads, especially when the original instructions call for melted butter or mix the fat with wet ingredients. If the recipe asks you to cream softened butter with sugar, expect a denser result with oil; see the Variations section for better options for that style of baking.
Work out the amount you need. Replace each 1 cup (227 g) of butter or margarine with ¾ cup (180 ml) oil. For ½ cup (113 g) butter, use 6 tablespoons (90 ml) oil. For ¼ cup (57 g) butter, use 3 tablespoons (45 ml) oil. These amounts reduce the fat slightly because oil is essentially all fat, while butter and many margarines contain some water.
Measure the oil accurately. Use a liquid measuring cup on a level surface, or measure with spoons. Do not pour in a full cup of oil to replace a full cup of butter: the extra fat can make the crumb greasy and heavy. If scaling the recipe, scale the oil in the same proportion as its original butter or margarine.
Add it in the right place. Stir the oil into the wet ingredients, or add it where the recipe says to add melted butter. Mix only until the batter is combined. Oil cannot be creamed with sugar to create the small air pockets that help some cakes rise, so beating it with sugar for the same time as softened butter will not reproduce the original texture.
Bake according to the original recipe. Keep its stated oven temperature and begin checking at the earliest time in the baking range. A toothpick inserted in the center should come out clean or with a few moist crumbs, unless the recipe gives another doneness cue. The substitution takes about 5 minutes to measure and incorporate; actual baking time varies by recipe and is not included in the preparation time above.

This is a ratio guide for replacing one measured quantity of fat, not a standalone cake or muffin batter. Keep the rest of the original recipe the same for the first attempt. If the batter looks somewhat looser than usual, that can be normal with oil; do not add flour automatically, since that may make the finished bake dry.

Tips

Choose the right oil. Canola and sunflower oil have mild flavors and suit most sweet baking. Light olive oil can work in chocolate cake, spice cake, and savory muffins, but extra-virgin olive oil may taste noticeable in delicate vanilla bakes. Avoid strongly flavored oils unless you want their flavor in the finished food.
Distinguish margarine types. A firm baking stick is usually a more reliable stand-in for butter than a soft tub spread, which can contain more water and vary in fat content. If replacing tub margarine with oil, the ¾-cup ratio is only a starting point; the texture may be less predictable, particularly in cookies.
Do not expect oil to make crisp, flaky layers. Butter or solid baking fat coats flour and holds its shape in pastry and biscuits. Oil stays liquid, so a straight swap can make dough difficult to handle and the result dense rather than flaky. Choose a recipe written for oil, or use a solid substitute suited to the recipe.
Use the recipe’s visual cues as well as its timer. Oil-based cakes can feel moist and tender even when fully baked. Check the center with the recipe’s usual doneness test, and avoid extending the bake just because the crumb is not identical to a butter-made version.

Serving Suggestions

Oil works especially well in tender, moist bakes where a pronounced butter flavor is not essential. Use the conversion for banana bread, zucchini bread, carrot cake, many muffins, and simple snack cakes. In those recipes, the oil is distributed through the batter and helps the crumb stay soft after cooling. A neutral oil keeps fruit, spices, cocoa, or citrus in the foreground.

For a finished cake or loaf, serve slices plain, with fresh fruit, or with a light glaze. If the original recipe includes a buttery frosting, crumb topping, or pastry shell, remember that changing the batter fat does not replace those components; adjust each part separately. Oil-based bakes can taste less rich than their butter versions, so a pinch of salt or a little extra vanilla may help round out the flavor, but avoid changing several ingredients at once.

Variations

For creamed cakes and cookies: Use a plant-based baking stick labeled for baking, in the same amount as butter, when you need a solid fat that can be beaten with sugar. Choose a stick rather than a soft spread, and check whether it is salted before adjusting the recipe’s salt. Results vary by product, but this option generally preserves the creaming method better than liquid oil. Cookies made with oil instead may spread differently, have less defined edges, and turn out more compact.

For melted-butter recipes: The ¾-cup oil substitution is the simplest approach. It suits brownies and many loaf cakes, though the flavor and chew can differ. Coconut oil is another option when solid fat is useful: replace butter by weight with refined coconut oil for a milder flavor, or unrefined coconut oil if its coconut aroma suits the recipe. Coconut oil firms as it cools, so it may change the texture and should be used in recipes that can accommodate that.

For a lower-fat, softer bake: Unsweetened applesauce can replace part of the butter in some muffins and quick breads. Try replacing no more than half the butter with the same volume of applesauce, and use oil for the remainder if the recipe needs fat. Applesauce adds moisture and fruit flavor but does not behave like fat; too much can make the center gummy or dense. This is a poor first choice for crisp cookies, pastry, or recipes that rely on creaming.

For dairy-free baking: A dairy-free baking stick can often replace butter one-for-one, while neutral oil works well in suitable cake and muffin recipes. Read the label because tub spreads and baking sticks are not interchangeable in every recipe. If the recipe uses buttermilk, milk, or cream elsewhere, replacing the butter alone does not make the whole bake dairy-free; those ingredients need their own suitable substitutes.

Storage and Reheating

The oil itself does not need special storage once measured, but follow the original recipe’s directions for the finished bake. Keep plain cakes, muffins, and quick breads in an airtight container at room temperature for about 2 to 3 days, provided the room is cool and the bake has no perishable filling or topping. Refrigerate bakes with cream, custard, or other perishable fillings within 2 hours; most cooked leftovers keep 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator.

For longer storage, wrap cooled portions well and freeze for up to 2 to 3 months for best quality. Thaw wrapped portions at room temperature so condensation forms on the wrapping rather than directly on the crumb. To reheat a stored portion, warm it in short microwave bursts or in a low oven until heated through; USDA FSIS guidance is to reheat leftovers to 165°F (74°C). Reheating may soften a crisp crust, and oil-based cakes are often pleasant at room temperature without warming.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace butter with oil in any baking recipe?
Not reliably. Oil is most dependable in recipes for cakes, muffins, brownies, and quick breads, particularly when the fat is melted or mixed into wet ingredients. Butter contributes structure, flavor, and air when creamed with sugar, and solid fat creates layers in pastry. For those methods, choose a suitable solid baking fat or a recipe designed for oil.

Is the ratio 1:1 for butter and oil?
No. A useful starting ratio is ¾ cup (180 ml) oil for each 1 cup (227 g) butter. Butter contains water as well as fat, while oil is nearly all fat, so using equal volumes of oil can make a bake greasy. For recipes with a different amount of butter, scale the oil proportionally.

Can I use olive oil instead of butter?
Yes, if its flavor suits the recipe. Light olive oil is mild enough for many bakes; extra-virgin olive oil has a stronger taste that pairs more naturally with chocolate, citrus, herbs, and warm spices than with a delicate vanilla cake. Measure the same ¾ cup oil for each cup of butter when using it in a suitable recipe.

What is the best butter substitute for cookies?
A firm baking stick, including a plant-based stick, is usually a closer match than oil because cookie recipes often depend on solid fat and creaming. Oil can make cookies spread differently and lose some crisp edges or lift. If using oil, start with a cookie recipe specifically developed for it rather than swapping directly into a butter-cookie formula.

Can applesauce replace all the butter?
It can replace some butter in moist quick breads and muffins, but using it for all the fat often produces a dense, damp texture. A cautious starting point is replacing up to half the butter with an equal volume of unsweetened applesauce and keeping some oil or solid fat in the recipe. It is not a good choice when crispness or flaky layers matter.

Does the substitution change baking time?
It can, because batter texture and pan size affect how quickly the center sets. Keep the recipe’s oven temperature, start checking at the earliest time it gives, and use its doneness cues rather than assuming the oil version needs exactly the same time. Make changes to only the fat at first so you can judge the result clearly.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).