Substitute for Butter to Cream Sugar: What Works Best

For creaming sugar without butter, solid vegetable shortening is the most dependable dairy-free substitute: it can be beaten with sugar to trap air, much like softened butter. This small-batch method replaces 1 cup of butter in a baking recipe, with a little water to help account for butter’s moisture; the finished bake may be softer and less buttery in flavor.

Ingredients

1 cup (190 g) plain vegetable shortening, at cool room temperature
1 cup (200 g) granulated sugar, or the exact amount of sugar called for in the recipe you are adapting
2 tablespoons (30 ml) cool water, added gradually; use milk instead if dairy is suitable and you want a slightly richer result

This quantity of shortening replaces 1 cup (227 g) of butter. The sugar quantity above is a workable example, not a fixed ratio: if your original recipe calls for a different amount, measure that amount instead. For recipes that call for less or more butter, scale the shortening and water proportionally. A small pinch of salt can also be added if the original recipe uses unsalted butter and you want to keep its salt level consistent, but do not add it if the recipe already specifies salt.

Instructions

Prepare the shortening. Let it stand just until it is pliable enough to indent with a finger but still holds its shape. If it is very warm or shiny, it may be too soft to hold much air. Measure the sugar and water, and fit a large bowl with an electric mixer or set out a sturdy whisk and bowl.
Beat the shortening briefly. Beat the shortening on medium speed for about 30 seconds, scraping the bowl once if needed. This smooths it before the sugar goes in. With a stand mixer, use the paddle attachment; a whisk attachment can incorporate too much air or leave the mixture uneven.
Add the sugar in stages. Add the sugar in two or three additions, beating on medium speed for 2 to 3 minutes. Stop once or twice to scrape the bowl and paddle. The mixture should look paler, fluffy, and evenly combined, though it may not look exactly like butter and sugar.
Drizzle in the water. With the mixer running on low, add the water a teaspoon or two at a time, beating until each addition is absorbed. Once all the water is in, mix for about 20 seconds and scrape the bowl. The result should be cohesive and creamy, not separated or watery. If it looks slightly curdled, mix briefly on low; do not pour in extra water to correct it.
Continue with the original recipe. Add eggs, flavorings, flour, and other ingredients in the order and amounts stated in the recipe you are adapting. Scrape the bowl as directed, then bake according to that recipe’s temperature and timing. The shortening mixture is a replacement for its creamed butter and sugar, not a complete cookie or cake batter on its own.

Tips

Use the right shortening. Plain, solid vegetable shortening gives the most predictable result. Do not substitute liquid cooking oil in this creaming method: oil cannot trap air in the same way, so the texture of the finished bake may be dense. If you prefer to avoid shortening, a firm stick-style margarine is usually easier to cream and can often replace butter cup for cup; choose one intended for baking, not soft tub spread.
Keep it cool but workable. Shortening should yield when pressed without looking melted. If it is too firm, cut it into small pieces and let it stand for a few minutes. If it becomes glossy or nearly liquid, chill it until it firms up before beating. Warm fat can make the sugar mixture slack and reduce the lift you get from creaming.
Follow the target recipe’s sugar amount. The sample batch uses 1 cup (200 g) sugar, but the substitution is based on the butter quantity. Use exactly the sugar amount in the recipe being adapted rather than automatically using equal parts shortening and sugar. The extra 2 tablespoons (30 ml) water are a starting point for replacing the moisture in 1 cup of butter; reduce or omit them if the recipe already has plenty of liquid or the batter seems loose.
Do not chase a butter-like appearance. Shortening and sugar can become fluffy, but the mixture may retain a slightly grainy look because sugar crystals do not dissolve during creaming. Beat for the stated time, scrape thoroughly, and move on. Excessive mixing after flour is added can make some baked goods tougher.

Serving Suggestions

This creamed mixture is meant to go straight into another baking recipe, rather than be served by itself. It works particularly well in recipes where shortening is already a familiar option, such as many drop cookies, sandwich cookies, and some layer cakes. Once you have beaten it with sugar, follow the recipe’s remaining steps and bake the complete batter as directed; the substitution does not change the recipe’s stated oven temperature or make its bake time automatically shorter.

Expect a difference in flavor and texture. Butter contributes dairy flavor and water, while shortening has a more neutral taste and is nearly all fat. Cookies made with shortening may hold their shape more and spread less, though the exact result depends on the flour, sugar, and other ingredients in the original recipe. Cakes can have a soft, tender crumb but will not have quite the same buttery aroma. Vanilla, citrus zest, spices, or a little extra salt already accounted for in the recipe can make the overall flavor feel more rounded.

Variations

Use stick margarine for a closer butter-style swap. If dairy-free shortening is not required, firm baking margarine is a convenient alternative. Use 1 cup (about 227 g) for every 1 cup (227 g) butter, and cream it with the recipe’s sugar as you would softened butter. Margarine contains water and varies by product, so skip the extra water in this method unless the recipe’s directions or the margarine’s label indicate otherwise. Avoid tub spreads, which can contain more water and may make a batter too loose.

Make the batch dairy-free. Use vegetable shortening and water, and check that the shortening is labeled dairy-free if that matters for your recipe. If the recipe later calls for milk, choose a suitable unsweetened plant beverage in that part of the recipe; this substitution does not replace any separate milk or cream listed there. The flavor will be more neutral than a version made with butter.

Use a blended fat only with care. Some bakers replace part of the butter with shortening to keep a familiar flavor while changing spread or tenderness. For example, replace half of 1 cup butter with 1/2 cup (95 g) shortening and use 1/2 cup (113 g) butter. Because the remaining butter already supplies moisture, do not automatically add the full 2 tablespoons of water; begin without it and judge the mixture before adding any. This is a variation, not a guaranteed identical result in every recipe.

Adjust the flavor, not the creaming method. A small amount of vanilla, almond extract, or citrus zest can complement a neutral shortening-based bake, but add it only if it fits the recipe. Extracts are usually added with the eggs or other flavorings, not used in place of the water. Do not add extra sugar to make up for missing butter flavor; that can alter spread, sweetness, and browning.

Storage and Reheating

For the most reliable texture, use the creamed shortening and sugar as soon as it is made. If you need to pause, cover the bowl and refrigerate the mixture, especially if you used milk or if it will be mixed with other perishable ingredients. Refrigerate within 2 hours of preparation. The plain shortening-and-sugar mixture can be held covered for up to 2 days, though it may firm up and lose some of its airy texture; mixtures containing milk should also be kept refrigerated and used within 2 days.

For longer storage, freeze the covered mixture for up to 2 months. Thaw it overnight in the refrigerator, then let it stand briefly until it is pliable and beat it on low just until smooth. Do not microwave it to soften: a few seconds too long can melt the fat, and melted shortening will not cream properly. This is an uncooked baking component, so it does not need reheating. If it has been left out for more than 2 hours after adding milk or another perishable ingredient, discard it rather than returning it to the refrigerator.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I cream sugar with oil instead of butter?
Not with the same method. Liquid oil cannot hold air pockets when beaten with sugar, so the mixture will not become light and fluffy like creamed butter or shortening. Oil can work in recipes specifically written for oil, where it is usually mixed with sugar and liquid ingredients differently, but it is not a direct replacement in a standard creaming method.

Is shortening a one-to-one substitute for butter?
For the fat itself, 1 cup (190 g) shortening is a common replacement for 1 cup (227 g) butter by volume. Since butter includes some water and shortening is nearly all fat, adding about 2 tablespoons (30 ml) water per cup of shortening can help approximate that moisture. It will not make the result identical: the flavor, browning, spread, and crumb can change, so the specific recipe matters.

Can I use coconut oil to cream sugar?
Usually it is less predictable than shortening. Coconut oil can be solid at a cool room temperature but softens quickly, and its firmness depends on the room and the product. If it becomes too soft, it will not hold air well; unrefined coconut oil also adds a noticeable coconut flavor. Use a recipe written for coconut oil or choose solid shortening for a more dependable creaming substitute.

Why does my shortening and sugar mixture look grainy?
That is often normal. Creaming is about distributing sugar through the fat and incorporating air, not dissolving every sugar crystal. A pale, fluffy, evenly mixed appearance is a better guide than a completely smooth surface. If the mixture is lumpy, scrape the bowl and beat briefly; if it is oily or melted-looking, chill it until firm enough to beat again.

Will cookies spread the same way as they do with butter?
Not necessarily. Shortening has a different melting behavior from butter and contains less water, so cookies often spread less and may stay thicker. The result also depends on the recipe’s flour, sugar, and oven temperature. For a first batch, bake one or two test cookies if the recipe allows, then adjust the dough’s chilling or spacing only if the original recipe provides room for that change.

Can I prepare the creamed mixture ahead?
Yes, but making it immediately before the rest of the batter is usually easiest. Cover and refrigerate it for up to 2 days, then let it soften until pliable and beat briefly before using. Do not leave a mixture containing milk at room temperature for an extended period, and do not try to revive chilled shortening by melting it in the microwave.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).