Substitute for Sour Cream in Potatoes

Plain Greek yogurt makes a tangy, creamy substitute for sour cream in mashed potatoes, while butter and warm milk keep the texture smooth. This recipe folds the yogurt into tender potatoes off the heat, so the result is rich and gently tart without tasting like a direct swap gone wrong.

Ingredients

2½ lb (1.1 kg) Yukon Gold potatoes, or half Yukon Gold and half russet potatoes
8 cups (1.9 L) water, or enough to cover the potatoes in the pot
2 tsp (12 g) fine salt for the cooking water, plus more to taste
4 tbsp (57 g) unsalted butter, cut into pieces
½ cup (120 ml) whole milk
¾ cup (180 g) plain Greek yogurt, preferably full-fat
¼ tsp (0.5 g) freshly ground black pepper, plus more to taste
1 small garlic clove, finely grated, optional
1 tbsp (3 g) finely chopped chives, optional, for serving

Use plain, unsweetened yogurt rather than vanilla or fruit yogurt. Greek yogurt is thick and gives the potatoes a pleasantly tangy flavor; regular plain yogurt also works, but it is thinner, so begin with ⅓ cup (80 ml) and add more only if the potatoes need it. Full-fat yogurt is less likely to taste sharp or make the mash feel watery.

Instructions

Prepare the potatoes. Scrub and peel the potatoes, or leave some skin on for a more rustic mash. Cut them into evenly sized pieces about 1½ inches (4 cm) across so they cook at roughly the same rate. If you are using both Yukon Gold and russet potatoes, cut the firmer Yukon Gold pieces slightly smaller if needed. Put the pieces in a large pot and add the water and 2 teaspoons of salt.
Boil until tender. Bring the pot to a boil over high heat, which usually takes about 8 minutes. Reduce the heat to maintain a steady simmer and cook for about 17 minutes. Check a larger piece with a fork: it should slide through easily, and the potato should break apart when pressed gently. If the center still feels firm, simmer for another 2 minutes and check again. Avoid cooking the pieces until they disintegrate, since waterlogged potatoes are harder to make fluffy.
Warm the dairy. While the potatoes simmer, put the milk and butter in a small saucepan or microwave-safe cup. Warm until the butter is melted and the milk is hot but not boiling, about 1 minute in a microwave or 2 to 3 minutes on the stovetop. Stir in the grated garlic, if using, and let it sit while the potatoes finish. Warm liquid blends into hot potatoes more evenly than cold milk straight from the refrigerator.
Drain and mash. Drain the potatoes thoroughly in a colander, then return them to the warm pot. Let them sit for about 1 minute so excess steam can escape. Mash with a potato masher until mostly smooth, or leave a few small lumps if you prefer a rustic texture. A potato ricer also works well. Avoid a blender or food processor: fast, forceful mixing can release too much starch and turn the potatoes gluey.
Fold in the substitute and season. Pour in the warm milk-and-butter mixture and stir just until combined. Take the pot off the heat, then fold in the Greek yogurt, pepper, and a little additional salt. Stop as soon as the potatoes look creamy; vigorous or prolonged stirring can make them dense. Taste and adjust the salt and pepper. If the mash seems too thick, fold in warm milk 1 tablespoon (15 ml) at a time. Serve hot, with chives if you like.

Tips

Choose the right substitute. Full-fat plain Greek yogurt is the closest easy swap when you want sour cream’s tang and a thick texture. Start with the ¾ cup (180 g) in this recipe, then taste before adding more. Regular plain yogurt is milder and looser, so use less at first. For a softer, less tangy finish, use ½ cup (120 g) cream cheese softened at room temperature and loosen the potatoes with a little extra warm milk.
Add yogurt off the heat. Stirring it into potatoes that are still hot is fine, but keep the pot off the burner. Direct high heat can make yogurt look grainy or separate, particularly if it is low-fat. Folding it in at the end keeps the flavor fresh and the texture creamy.
Keep the mash fluffy. Cut the potatoes evenly, drain them well, and let steam escape briefly before mashing. A masher or ricer is better than an electric blender. If the potatoes become sticky, do not keep beating them; fold in a little warm milk and stop mixing as soon as they are evenly moistened.
Adjust the salt after the swap. Yogurt’s tang can make a dish seem less seasoned, while butter and cooking water already contribute salt. Taste only after all the dairy is mixed in, then add salt in small pinches. If you use salted butter, reduce the salt added at the end.

Serving Suggestions

Serve these potatoes as a side while they are hot, when the butter is melted and the yogurt gives the mash a light, creamy tang. They pair well with roasted chicken, meatloaf, baked fish, pork chops, or a simple plate of sautéed vegetables. For a vegetarian meal, serve a generous scoop alongside roasted mushrooms, lentils, or a crisp green salad. The potatoes are also useful under a savory vegetable or lentil pie filling, where their soft texture contrasts with a browned top.

For a simple finish, add chopped chives, parsley, or green onion and a small pat of butter. A spoonful of warm milk can be swirled over the top if the potatoes have thickened while waiting. If you are serving a larger meal, transfer the finished mash to a warm serving bowl and cover it loosely; do not leave it at room temperature for an extended period. Season the garnish lightly, since the potatoes themselves should already be salted.

Variations

Use crème fraîche or cream cheese: Crème fraîche can replace the Greek yogurt in the same amount for a richer, less sharp flavor. Softened cream cheese is thicker and less tangy, so ½ cup (120 g) is a good starting amount; add warm milk gradually to reach the texture you want. Both options make the mash richer than yogurt, so you may want to use a little less butter.

Make a dairy-free version: Replace the butter with 3 tablespoons (45 ml) olive oil or a plant-based butter, use ½ cup (120 ml) unsweetened plain plant milk, and fold in ¾ cup (180 g) unsweetened plain dairy-free yogurt. Check that the yogurt is unflavored and not sweetened. Plant-based yogurts vary in thickness and tartness, so add it gradually and taste before using the full amount. Olive oil gives the potatoes a fruitier flavor than butter.

Add herbs or roasted garlic: Fold in 1 to 2 tablespoons (3 to 6 g) chopped chives or parsley at the end. For a mellower garlic flavor, use 1 teaspoon (5 g) roasted garlic instead of the raw grated clove. You can also add ¼ cup (25 g) finely grated Parmesan, but taste before adding extra salt because the cheese is salty.

Make them more rustic: Leave the skins on Yukon Gold potatoes and mash by hand. The finished potatoes will have more texture and visible flecks of skin. If you prefer a very smooth mash, peel the potatoes and use a ricer, but still avoid processing them in a blender or food processor.

Storage and Reheating

Transfer leftover potatoes to a shallow, covered container and refrigerate them within 2 hours of cooking. They keep for 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. The mash firms as it cools, and the yogurt’s tang may seem a little more noticeable the next day; that is normal. Stir in a splash of milk before reheating if the potatoes look dry. Do not leave leftovers on the counter to cool for several hours.

To reheat a portion on the stovetop, put it in a saucepan over low heat with 1 to 2 tablespoons (15 to 30 ml) milk per cup of potatoes. Cover and warm, stirring gently every minute or two until steaming hot. For a larger amount, reheat in a covered oven-safe dish at 325°F (163°C), stirring once and adding milk if needed. A microwave also works: cover the bowl loosely, heat in short intervals, and stir between intervals so the middle warms evenly. USDA food-safety guidance is to reheat leftovers to 165°F (74°C); check the center with a food thermometer. Avoid reheating the same batch repeatedly, since each cycle can dry out the potatoes.

You can freeze the potatoes in an airtight freezer-safe container for up to 1 month, although the texture may be slightly grainier after thawing because yogurt and potatoes can separate. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator, then reheat gently with a little milk and stir until smooth. Freezing is optional; for the creamiest texture, refrigerate and use the leftovers within the recommended 3 to 4 days.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best substitute for sour cream in mashed potatoes?

Plain Greek yogurt is a reliable choice because it is thick, creamy, and pleasantly tangy. Use the same amount as the sour cream called for in your recipe, then taste before adding more. Full-fat yogurt gives the smoothest result, while regular plain yogurt is thinner and may need to be added gradually.

Can I use regular plain yogurt instead of Greek yogurt?

Yes. Regular plain yogurt works, but it has more moisture and a thinner consistency. Start with about half the amount, mix it into the potatoes off the heat, and add more only if the mash needs extra tang or softness. Avoid pouring in a large amount at once, which can make the potatoes loose.

Can I use milk instead of sour cream in potatoes?

Milk can loosen and moisten mashed potatoes, but it does not provide sour cream’s thickness or tang on its own. For a simple substitute, use warm milk with butter as in this recipe, and add a little plain yogurt, cream cheese, or crème fraîche if you want a more sour-cream-like flavor. Add the milk gradually so the mash does not become watery.

Will Greek yogurt curdle in hot potatoes?

It is less likely to separate if you remove the pot from the heat before adding it and fold it in gently at the end. Very low-fat yogurt and direct heat make a grainy texture more likely. If the potatoes are piping hot, that is not a problem by itself; just avoid returning the pot to a hot burner after adding the yogurt.

How much yogurt should I use for 2½ pounds of potatoes?

This recipe uses ¾ cup (180 g) of plain Greek yogurt for 2½ pounds (1.1 kg) of potatoes. That gives a noticeable but balanced tang alongside the butter and milk. If you prefer a milder flavor, start with ½ cup (120 g), taste, and add more a spoonful at a time.

Can I make these potatoes ahead?

Yes. Make them up to 1 day ahead, cool and refrigerate them promptly, then reheat gently with a splash of milk. Stir occasionally and check that the center reaches 165°F (74°C). The texture is best when reheated slowly; a fast, uncovered heat can dry the edges before the middle is warm.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).