Substitute Raw Sugar for Brown Sugar in Baking

Raw sugar can stand in for brown sugar, but its larger, drier crystals may change the texture of baked goods. For a closer match, mix raw sugar with a little molasses; this quick, no-cook substitute adds back brown sugar’s moisture and mellow caramel flavor.

Ingredients

1 cup (200 g) raw cane sugar, such as turbinado or demerara, measured level and not packed
2 teaspoons (10 ml; about 14 g) unsulfured light molasses

Instructions

Measure the sugar. Add the raw sugar to a medium bowl. A level cup is a useful starting point, but weighing it gives a more dependable result because coarse crystals can leave different-sized gaps in a measuring cup. This batch makes about 214 g of sugar mixture, close to the weight of 1 cup of packed light brown sugar.
Add the molasses. Drizzle the molasses over the sugar rather than pouring it into one spot. Light molasses gives a familiar brown-sugar flavor without overwhelming the sugar’s own mild caramel notes. If your molasses is especially thick, stir it briefly so it is easier to distribute.
Mix until evenly colored. Use a fork or small whisk to press and toss the mixture for 2 to 3 minutes, breaking up damp clumps as you go. Scrape the bottom and sides of the bowl. The finished mixture should be evenly tan, with no distinct streaks or pockets of molasses. It will not feel quite as soft as commercial brown sugar because the raw crystals remain larger.
Check the texture for your recipe. For muffins, quick breads, and many bar cookies, the mixture can go straight into the batter. For a recipe where a fine, even texture matters, pulse the mixture in a food processor for a few short bursts. Stop as soon as the crystals are smaller and the color is uniform; processing for too long can make the sugar dusty or cause it to clump.
Use it in place of brown sugar. Substitute the mixture for 1 cup packed light brown sugar in most recipes. If the recipe gives a weight, use 214 g rather than relying on volume. Add it at the same point in the recipe as the brown sugar, and follow the recipe’s usual mixing and baking directions; this ingredient swap does not require a change to the oven temperature or baking time by itself.

Tips

Choose the right raw sugar. Turbinado and demerara are the most practical options: they have a light golden color and mild toffee-like taste. Their crystals are usually larger than those in brown sugar, so they may leave a slight crunch in a very delicate dough if you do not mix or briefly process them. Other less-refined cane sugars can work, but color, crystal size, and flavor vary by product.
Use light molasses for a light-brown-sugar match. The 2-teaspoon amount makes a mild substitute. If you prefer a deeper, darker flavor, increase the molasses to 1 tablespoon (15 ml; about 21 g). That creates a darker, moister mixture and increases the total weight, so it is better suited to recipes calling for dark brown sugar than to an exact 1-cup light-brown-sugar replacement.
Avoid blackstrap unless you want its strong taste. Blackstrap molasses is more bitter and robust than light or regular molasses. It can dominate a delicately flavored cake or cookie. If it is the only type available, use less at first and expect a more assertive flavor and darker color.
Do not pack the raw sugar into the measuring cup. Brown sugar is normally packed when measured, but coarse raw sugar can compact unevenly and make a cup too heavy. Measure it level, or weigh the finished substitute to keep the amount consistent. For the most repeatable baking, follow a recipe’s gram weight when provided.

Serving Suggestions

Use this mixture in recipes that call for brown sugar, especially cookies, crumbles, muffins, quick breads, and spice cakes. It pairs naturally with cinnamon, ginger, oats, nuts, apples, pears, and chocolate. In cookies, the molasses helps bring back some of the soft, chewy quality associated with brown sugar, while the raw sugar can still lend a slightly more noticeable grain to the finished texture.

For recipes where sugar is creamed with butter, make the mixture as fine and uniform as you can before adding it. That helps it blend more evenly and reduces the chance of coarse crystals remaining in the dough. In a stirred batter, such as a quick bread, the difference is usually less noticeable. The substitute is also useful in a fruit crumble topping, where a little texture from larger crystals is often welcome.

It is less predictable in recipes that depend heavily on brown sugar’s moisture and fine texture, such as very soft cookies, chewy candies, or some sauces. Those recipes may need additional adjustments beyond a simple sugar swap. When the result matters, try the substitute in a small batch first rather than changing the sugar in a large or special-occasion bake.

Variations

Direct raw-sugar swap: If you do not have molasses, use raw sugar in the same amount as brown sugar for many everyday baked goods. Expect a drier, less caramel-like result, and potentially crisper edges or a coarser bite. This is most dependable in recipes with other sources of moisture, such as fruit, yogurt, or mashed banana, and less dependable when the brown sugar provides much of the recipe’s softness.

Darker brown-sugar style: Mix 1 cup (200 g) raw sugar with 1 tablespoon (15 ml; about 21 g) light or regular molasses. The extra molasses gives the blend a deeper color and flavor. Since this version weighs more than a standard cup of packed light brown sugar, use it where a dark-brown-sugar character is welcome, or measure by the amount your recipe specifies and accept a slightly more pronounced molasses note.

Small-batch amount: To replace ½ cup packed light brown sugar, combine ½ cup (100 g) raw sugar with 1 teaspoon (5 ml; about 7 g) molasses. Scale both ingredients in the same proportion for other amounts. Mixing a smaller quantity in a bowl with a fork is usually easier than running a small amount through a food processor.

Fine-textured blend: For a cake or cookie dough where large crystals could be distracting, pulse the raw sugar briefly in a clean food processor before adding the molasses. Do not grind it to a powder. Add the molasses after pulsing, then mix until evenly colored. This can make the substitute more uniform, though it still may not be identical to commercial brown sugar.

Storage and Reheating

Transfer leftover sugar mixture to a clean, dry, airtight container and keep it in a cool, dry pantry. For the best texture, use it within 2 to 4 weeks. It does not need reheating, and refrigeration is usually unnecessary; cold storage can introduce condensation when the container is opened, which encourages clumping. Keep water and damp utensils out of the container.

If the mixture firms up, break it apart with a fork before measuring. A clean slice of bread placed in the container for a few hours can help soften a clump, but remove the bread afterward and do not leave it in the sugar. If the mixture smells unusual, looks damp or discolored, or has been contaminated by food or a wet utensil, discard it and make a fresh batch. For easier baking, you can mix only the quantity needed for the recipe rather than storing a large batch.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace brown sugar with raw sugar in equal amounts?
Usually, yes, especially in straightforward baked goods. A direct one-to-one swap is convenient, but raw sugar is typically drier and coarser, so the result may be less moist, less chewy, or slightly more textured. Adding molasses as in the recipe above makes the replacement closer to brown sugar in flavor and moisture.

Is raw sugar the same as brown sugar?
No. Raw cane sugar commonly has larger crystals and a small amount of natural molasses left from processing, while brown sugar is fine sugar combined with molasses or retains molasses during processing. Brown sugar is usually softer and more moisture-rich. The names and exact processing can vary, so check the package if crystal size or flavor matters for your recipe.

Will the molasses make my baking taste strongly of molasses?
Not at the amount in this formula. Two teaspoons spread through about 1 cup of sugar add a mild caramel-like depth similar to light brown sugar. The taste becomes more noticeable if you use the 1-tablespoon dark-style variation, or if you use a strong type such as blackstrap. For a delicate vanilla cake, start with the lighter amount.

Can I use this substitute in every recipe that calls for brown sugar?
It works in many cookies, muffins, cakes, quick breads, and crumble toppings, but it is not a perfect match in every application. Brown sugar contributes both sweetness and moisture, and some recipes rely on its fine texture or acidity. Candy, syrup, very soft cookies, and recipes balanced around a specific sugar may need more than a simple swap. If unsure, make a small test batch.

Can I make the substitute without molasses?
Yes. Use raw sugar directly, measured by weight or volume as the recipe directs, and expect a paler, drier result with less brown-sugar flavor. If molasses is unavailable but you have another syrup, it may add moisture, but it will change the flavor and can add water differently; it is not an exact replacement. For the closest match, molasses is the most practical addition.

Should I change the baking time or temperature?
Do not change either automatically. Use the temperature and timing given in the original recipe, then check the bake for doneness as directed. The sugar swap may affect browning or texture, but the amount of change depends on the recipe and the raw sugar’s crystal size. If the first batch spreads less or turns crisp sooner, adjust the mixing or use the molasses blend next time.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).