Who Made Sandwiches? A Classic Club Sandwich Recipe

The sandwich is named for John Montagu, the 4th Earl of Sandwich, but stories about who first put fillings between bread are disputed. This classic club sandwich layers ready-to-eat turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato between three slices of toast; the crisp bread and simple fillings make it a satisfying lunch that is easy to assemble.

Ingredients

12 slices sandwich bread, about 1 lb (450 g), white, wheat, or sourdough
⅓ cup mayonnaise (75 g)
12 oz (340 g) thinly sliced, ready-to-eat deli turkey
8 slices fully cooked bacon (about 3 oz / 85 g); heat according to the package if desired
1 large ripe but firm tomato (about 7 oz / 200 g), cut into 8 thin slices
4 large, crisp lettuce leaves (about 1 oz / 30 g), washed and thoroughly dried
4 thin slices cheddar or Swiss cheese (about 3 oz / 85 g), optional
¼ teaspoon (1.5 g) fine salt, or to taste
⅛ teaspoon (0.3 g) freshly ground black pepper, or to taste
4 long toothpicks or sandwich picks, optional, for holding the layers together

Instructions

Get everything ready. Wash and dry the lettuce, slice the tomato, and separate the turkey and bacon into portions for four sandwiches. Pat the tomato slices dry with a clean towel so excess juice does not soak into the bread. If you are using cheese, have one slice ready for each sandwich. This quick setup makes assembly easier and helps you serve the sandwiches while the toast is still pleasantly crisp.
Toast the bread. Toast the 12 slices in a toaster or toaster oven until golden and crisp, working in batches if needed. Most slices take about 3–5 minutes, depending on the appliance and the bread. Keep the toast on a plate or rack rather than stacking it; trapped steam softens the surfaces. If the bread is very thick, toast it until the center is warmed through but not so dark that it becomes brittle when cut.
Warm the bacon if you like. The recipe uses fully cooked bacon, so it can go straight into the sandwich. For warm bacon, heat it according to the package directions, usually in a microwave or skillet for a few minutes. Take care not to overheat it until it becomes hard or crumbly. Keep the warmed slices on a paper towel briefly to remove excess grease, then divide them evenly among the sandwiches.
Season the tomato. Arrange the tomato slices in a single layer and sprinkle lightly with the salt and pepper. Seasoning at this point brings out the tomato flavor without needing extra sauce. If the tomato is especially juicy, leave it on a paper towel for a minute before building the sandwiches. Avoid salting the lettuce, which can draw out moisture and make the leaves limp.
Spread the toast. Lay out four slices of toast for the bottom layer, four for the middle, and four for the tops. Spread about 1 teaspoon of mayonnaise over one side of each slice, using a little more if you prefer a richer sandwich. A thin, even coating is enough to add flavor and create a barrier between the bread and moist fillings. If using cheese, place a slice over the mayonnaise on four of the middle pieces.
Build the bottom layer. Put a lettuce leaf on each bottom slice, then divide the turkey evenly over the lettuce. Add a little black pepper if you enjoy it. Keeping lettuce between the bread and turkey helps protect the toast from the tomato juices that will go into the next layer. Fold large turkey slices loosely rather than pressing them into a dense stack; a little air between the slices gives the finished sandwich a lighter texture.
Add the middle and top. Set a middle slice of toast over each turkey layer, mayonnaise-side up. Add the tomato and two slices of bacon to each sandwich, arranging them so every bite gets some of both. Top with the remaining lettuce, then place the last slice of toast on top with its mayonnaise side facing down. Press gently, just enough to settle the layers. Secure each sandwich with one or two picks if needed.
Cut and serve. Use a sharp serrated knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into halves or quarters. A gentle sawing motion cuts through the crisp toast without squeezing out the filling. Remove any picks before eating, or make sure everyone knows they are there. Serve promptly while the bread is still crisp and the bacon is at its best.

Tips

Dry the produce well. Water left on lettuce or tomato is a common reason a club sandwich turns soggy. After washing, spin the lettuce dry or pat it with a clean towel, and blot juicy tomato slices before assembly. Choose a ripe tomato that still holds its shape when sliced; an overripe one tends to slide out and wet the toast.
Use a light hand with mayonnaise. A generous smear can make the layers slippery and overwhelm the turkey. Start with about a teaspoon per slice and add more at the table if you want. If you need a dairy-free alternative, use a plant-based mayonnaise; it works in the same quantity and keeps the sandwich creamy, though its flavor may be slightly different.
Keep the layers level. Fold the turkey rather than piling it in a tall mound, and place bacon strips across the sandwich instead of lengthwise in one narrow line. Even layers make the sandwich easier to cut and less likely to fall apart. If the bread is small, trim or fold the fillings so they stay inside the edges.
Toast in batches without steaming. If all the bread will not fit in the toaster at once, toast it in batches and spread the slices out on a rack. Do not cover warm toast with a plate or put it in a sealed bag; steam quickly removes its crunch. Assemble as soon as practical, but prepare the fillings first so the bread is not waiting for a long time.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the club sandwiches soon after cutting, with a crisp side that balances the rich bacon and mayonnaise. Potato chips, baked potato wedges, a simple green salad, or crunchy pickle spears are all easy choices. For a lighter lunch plate, offer sliced cucumber, carrot sticks, or fruit alongside a half sandwich rather than adding another heavy side.

For a casual meal, cut the sandwiches into quarters and arrange them on a platter with the cut sides facing up. This makes the fillings visible and gives guests a manageable portion. Add small bowls of extra mayonnaise, mustard, or pickles so people can adjust their sandwiches without overloading the bread before serving. If you are packing lunches, keep wet sides such as pickles in a separate container.

Variations

Swap the bread. Whole-wheat bread adds a nuttier, heartier flavor, while sourdough brings a mild tang and sturdy crust. Soft white sandwich bread gives a familiar diner-style result. Whichever kind you choose, use slices large enough to contain the fillings, and toast them to a similar level so the sandwich holds together when cut.

Change the deli meat. Sliced roast chicken can replace turkey in the same amount, or use thinly sliced ham for a saltier sandwich. You can also make a meat-free version with sliced avocado, grilled zucchini prepared ahead, or a generous layer of roasted red pepper. These alternatives change the classic club flavor and may be softer, so use well-dried lettuce and avoid piling on wet fillings.

Adjust the cheese and sauce. Cheddar and Swiss are both good with turkey and bacon; provolone is mild, while pepper jack adds heat. For a sharper sauce, stir 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard into the ⅓ cup mayonnaise. A little mustard makes the spread tangier, so begin with a small amount and taste it before adding more.

Make a simpler two-slice sandwich. If three slices feel too filling, use two slices of toast and stack the turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato between them. Use the same quantities divided among four sandwiches, or make two larger portions. The two-slice version is easier to handle but has less bread between the moist tomato and other fillings, so serve it right away.

Storage and Reheating

These sandwiches are best assembled just before serving because tomato moisture gradually softens the toast. If you have leftovers, refrigerate them within 2 hours of preparation. Wrap each sandwich tightly or place it in an airtight container and keep it refrigerated for up to 3–4 days, although the bread and lettuce will lose quality well before then. For the best texture, store the turkey, bacon, vegetables, and bread separately and assemble only what you plan to eat.

Do not reheat a fully assembled sandwich with lettuce and tomato inside; the vegetables wilt and the bread can turn soggy. If you want warm fillings, remove the cold produce, warm the turkey and bacon separately, and then rebuild the sandwich with fresh lettuce and tomato. Reheat leftover cooked turkey or bacon to 165°F (74°C), the USDA FSIS safe temperature for reheated leftovers, checking with a food thermometer where practical. Toast fresh bread rather than trying to crisp a refrigerated assembled sandwich.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who made the first sandwich?

The sandwich takes its name from John Montagu, the 4th Earl of Sandwich, an 18th-century British nobleman. A familiar story says he requested meat between pieces of bread so he could eat without leaving a card game, but the details and claim that he invented the idea are disputed. People had been eating food with bread long before then, so it is more accurate to say the name became associated with him than to credit him definitively as the first maker.

Is this the original club sandwich?

No single original version is established by this recipe. Club sandwiches are commonly made with toasted bread, poultry, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, but the number of bread slices, the choice of meat, and whether cheese is included vary by cook and restaurant. This recipe gives you a practical, familiar version rather than claiming to be the sole traditional formula.

Can I make these sandwiches ahead?

You can prepare the components a few hours ahead: wash and dry the lettuce, slice the tomato, portion the turkey, and refrigerate everything separately. Keep the bread untoasted or toast it shortly before serving, then assemble at the last moment. If you need to make finished sandwiches ahead for a packed lunch, use dry lettuce, blot the tomato, and place lettuce between the tomato and bread to slow sogginess.

What can I use instead of mayonnaise?

Use an equal amount of plant-based mayonnaise, or spread a thin layer of softened cream cheese for a thicker, tangier result. Mashed avocado also works, though it has a softer texture and may darken after being cut. If you use mustard alone, spread it sparingly because its sharper flavor can dominate the turkey and bacon.

How do I keep a club sandwich from falling apart?

Toast the bread until crisp but not brittle, keep the fillings in even layers, and avoid overfilling the edges. A sharp serrated knife and a gentle sawing motion help preserve the stack when cutting. Sandwich picks can hold the layers in place, but remove them before eating and take care when serving the sandwich to children.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).