Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie, Noodles and Broth

Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie is a hearty soup-stew of tender chicken, potatoes, and thick homemade squares of egg dough simmered in broth. Unlike a baked pot pie with a pastry crust, this regional version is served from a pot; its simple ingredients and sturdy noodles make a satisfying one-pot meal.

Ingredients

2½ lb bone-in chicken thighs or legs (1.13 kg)
10 cups water (2.4 L), plus more if needed
1 medium yellow onion, peeled and halved (about 150 g)
2 celery ribs, cut into large pieces (about 100 g)
2 medium carrots, cut into large pieces (about 150 g)
2 bay leaves
1½ tsp fine salt (9 g), plus more to taste
½ tsp black pepper (1 g)
3 cups all-purpose flour (360 g), plus extra for rolling
2 large eggs (about 100 g without shells)
⅓ cup milk (80 ml)
½ tsp fine salt for the dough (3 g)
1½ lb Yukon Gold or russet potatoes, peeled and cut into ¾-inch cubes (680 g)
1 tbsp chopped fresh parsley (4 g), optional
1 tbsp unsalted butter (14 g), optional, for finishing

Instructions

Prepare the chicken and broth ingredients. Put the chicken, water, onion, celery, carrots, bay leaves, 1½ teaspoons salt, and pepper in a large heavy pot or Dutch oven. The chicken should be mostly covered; add a little water if needed. Keep the vegetables in large pieces because they will flavor the broth and be removed before the potatoes go in.
Make the dough. While the pot is still cold, combine the flour and ½ teaspoon salt in a large bowl. In a second bowl, beat the eggs with the milk. Make a well in the flour, pour in the egg mixture, and stir until a shaggy dough forms. Knead on a lightly floured counter for about 3 minutes, just until smooth. It should be firm rather than sticky; add flour a tablespoon at a time if it clings to your hands. Cover and let it rest for 20 minutes. This short rest relaxes the dough so it rolls without springing back.
Simmer the chicken. Bring the pot to a gentle boil over medium-high heat, skimming off foam as it appears. Lower the heat so the liquid simmers steadily but does not churn, partially cover, and cook for about 35–45 minutes. Check the thickest part of a thigh with a food thermometer, avoiding the bone: poultry must reach the USDA FSIS safe minimum internal temperature of 165°F (74°C). If it has not reached that temperature, continue simmering and check again after a few minutes.
Roll and cut the pot-pie noodles. Transfer the cooked chicken to a plate. Remove the onion, celery, carrots, and bay leaves from the broth with a slotted spoon; discard them, or reserve the carrots if you want them in the finished pot. Let the chicken cool just enough to handle. Meanwhile, roll the rested dough on a floured counter to about ⅛ inch thick. Cut it into rough 2-inch squares, dusting lightly with flour to prevent sticking. The squares do not need to be perfectly even; keep them thick enough to stay pleasantly chewy in the broth.
Shred the chicken and cook the potatoes. Pull the chicken meat from the bones, discarding skin and bones, and tear it into bite-size pieces. Bring the broth back to a gentle boil. Add the cubed potatoes and simmer for about 12 minutes, until they are nearly tender when pierced with a fork but are not falling apart.
Simmer the noodles. Add the dough squares a few at a time, stirring gently after each addition so they do not clump together. Maintain a gentle simmer for 15–18 minutes, stirring carefully once or twice. The noodles should be tender throughout, with no floury or raw-tasting center. Because the dough contains eggs, check that the thickest noodle pieces reach 160°F (71°C) with a food thermometer. Stir in the shredded chicken and simmer for 3–5 minutes, until hot. If the broth has become thicker than you like, add up to 1 cup (240 ml) hot water.
Finish and serve. Taste the broth and adjust the salt and pepper. Stir in the optional butter and parsley, then let the pot pie stand for 5 minutes so the broth settles and the noodles finish absorbing flavor. Ladle the chicken, potatoes, noodles, and broth into warm bowls.

Tips

Keep the simmer gentle. A hard boil can break the potatoes and make the noodles ragged. Once the broth returns to a boil after adding ingredients, lower the heat until you see small, steady bubbles.
Flour the dough lightly. A little flour helps when rolling and cutting, but excess flour can make the broth pasty. Shake loose flour from the squares before adding them, and avoid stacking damp pieces.
Use a thermometer for the chicken. Cooking time depends on the size of the pieces and the temperature of the pot. Temperature, rather than the clock or the color near the bone, is the reliable doneness check.
Choose a shortcut thoughtfully. Frozen homemade pot-pie squares work well if available; add them frozen and follow their package timing, checking that they are tender. Wide dried egg noodles are convenient, but they make a softer, more conventional noodle soup rather than the chewy handmade-dough version.

Serving Suggestions

This is a filling meal on its own, so serve it in deep bowls with enough broth to surround the noodles. A simple green salad with a sharp vinaigrette adds freshness and contrast. Crusty bread or soft dinner rolls are useful for catching the last of the broth, though they are optional when the potatoes and noodles make the meal substantial.

For a traditional Pennsylvania Dutch-style table, offer pepper, salt, and chopped parsley at the table so each person can season their bowl. The dish is mild by design, and a few grinds of black pepper can sharpen the savory chicken broth without overwhelming it. If serving a group, keep the pot covered over very low heat only briefly; prolonged cooking can make the potatoes crumble and the noodles absorb too much liquid.

Variations

Use a quicker chicken option: Boneless thighs can replace bone-in pieces. Simmer them in the broth until they reach 165°F (74°C), usually sooner than bone-in chicken, then remove and shred them. The broth may have a little less body, so use chicken stock for part of the water if you have it.

Make the dough without milk: Replace the ⅓ cup milk with ⅓ cup water (80 ml). The dough will be a little less tender but will still roll and cook well. For a richer dough, replace the milk with ⅓ cup broth; let the broth cool before mixing it with the eggs.

Add vegetables: Stir in 1 cup (150 g) frozen peas during the last 3 minutes, or add sliced carrots with the potatoes if you want the vegetables served rather than used only to flavor the broth. Avoid adding delicate vegetables too early, since they can turn mushy during the noodle simmer.

Use leftover cooked chicken: Start with about 3 cups (450 g) cooked, shredded chicken and make broth with 8 cups (1.9 L) chicken stock. Simmer the potatoes until nearly tender, cook the dough squares as directed, and stir in the cooked chicken for the final 5 minutes. This shortens the process but gives up the flavor that comes from simmering chicken bones in the broth.

Regional and household versions vary: some cooks use a richer egg dough, others use water-based dough, and vegetables in the finished pot are a matter of preference. The defining idea is the thick, square noodles cooked directly in a savory chicken broth, not a pastry lid.

Storage and Reheating

Cool leftovers promptly and refrigerate them within 2 hours in a covered, shallow container. They keep for 3–4 days in the refrigerator. The noodles will continue to absorb broth as they sit, so store extra broth separately if you have it, or expect the leftovers to be thicker the next day.

Reheat a portion in a saucepan over medium-low heat with a splash of water or broth, stirring gently until steaming throughout. For food safety, leftovers should reach 165°F (74°C); check the center with a food thermometer. A microwave also works: cover loosely, heat in short intervals, stir between intervals, and check several spots for 165°F (74°C). Freeze leftovers in airtight containers for up to 2 months for best quality. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator and reheat to 165°F (74°C); the potatoes and noodles may be softer after freezing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie the same as baked chicken pot pie?
No. In this regional dish, “pot pie” refers to a stew with dough squares simmered in broth. It is not baked in a crust or topped with pastry, although baked pot pies are also popular elsewhere.

Can I make the dough ahead?
Yes. Wrap the dough tightly and refrigerate it for up to 24 hours. Let it sit at room temperature for about 15 minutes if it feels too firm to roll. You can also roll and cut the squares a few hours ahead; keep them lightly floured and covered so they do not dry out.

Why did my broth turn cloudy or thick?
A little cloudiness is normal because flour from the noodles enters the broth. Too much loose flour, vigorous boiling, or broken potatoes can make it much thicker. Shake excess flour from the squares, keep the pot at a gentle simmer, and thin the finished dish with hot water or broth.

Can I use store-bought noodles?
Yes. Wide dried egg noodles are the easiest substitute, but their texture is thinner and softer than the traditional cut dough. Cook them according to the package directions in the broth, then return the chicken to the pot. Add liquid as needed because dried noodles absorb broth too.

Can I make this recipe gluten-free?
Not reliably by swapping in a one-for-one gluten-free flour without adjustment. Handmade dough depends on flour structure, and gluten-free blends vary in how much liquid they absorb and whether they hold together in simmering broth. Use a tested gluten-free noodle dough, or cook a suitable gluten-free pasta separately and add it to the bowls just before serving.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).