Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie with Homemade Noodles

Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie is a hearty Pennsylvania Dutch stew of chicken, potatoes, and tender squares of homemade egg dough simmered in broth—not a pie with a pastry crust. It works as a complete, comforting supper because the noodles thicken the savory broth while the potatoes and chicken make each bowl filling.

Ingredients

2½ lb (1.13 kg) bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs
8 cups (1.9 L) low-sodium chicken broth
1 medium yellow onion, about 7 oz (200 g), peeled and quartered
2 celery stalks, about 4 oz (115 g), cut into large pieces
1 bay leaf
½ teaspoon (1 g) whole black peppercorns
1 teaspoon (6 g) fine salt, plus more to taste
2 cups (250 g) all-purpose flour, plus up to 2 tablespoons (16 g) for rolling
2 large eggs, about 100 g without shells
¼ cup (60 ml) whole milk
½ teaspoon (3 g) fine salt for the noodle dough
1½ lb (680 g) Yukon Gold or russet potatoes, peeled and cut into ¾-inch (2 cm) chunks
2 tablespoons (8 g) chopped fresh parsley, optional

Instructions

Start the broth. Put the chicken thighs, broth, onion, celery, bay leaf, peppercorns, and 1 teaspoon salt in a large heavy pot or Dutch oven. Bring the liquid just to a boil over medium-high heat, skimming off any foam that rises. Reduce the heat to maintain a gentle simmer, partly cover, and cook for 35 minutes. Check the thickest part of a thigh with a food thermometer, without touching the bone; USDA FSIS says poultry must reach a safe minimum internal temperature of 165°F (74°C).
Mix and rest the dough. While the chicken cooks, put 2 cups flour and ½ teaspoon salt in a bowl. Beat the eggs with the milk, pour them into the flour, and stir until a shaggy dough forms. Knead it briefly on a lightly floured counter, about 2 minutes, until it holds together and feels firm but not dry. Cover and let it rest for 20 minutes. This short rest relaxes the dough so it is easier to roll; it should not become sticky or soft like bread dough.
Lift out and prepare the chicken. Once the chicken reaches 165°F (74°C), transfer it to a plate with tongs and let it cool for about 10 minutes, until comfortable to handle. Remove and discard the onion, celery, and bay leaf from the broth. Skim excess fat from the surface if you prefer a lighter broth, but leave a little for flavor. Remove the chicken skin and bones, then pull or cut the meat into bite-size pieces. Keep the chicken covered while you finish the pot pie.
Roll and cut the noodles. Divide the rested dough in half. Roll each piece on a lightly floured surface into a thin rectangle, about ⅛ inch (3 mm) thick. Dust sparingly with flour if it sticks, then cut into roughly 1½-inch (4 cm) squares. The squares do not need to be perfectly even. Separate them on the counter so they do not clump together while you heat the broth.
Cook the potatoes. Bring the strained broth back to a steady simmer. Add the potato chunks and cook for 10 minutes, stirring gently once or twice. They should be beginning to soften around the edges but not falling apart; the noodles still need time in the broth.
Add the dough squares. Drop the noodles into the simmering broth a handful at a time, stirring gently after each addition to keep them separate. Maintain a lively simmer, not a hard boil, and cook for 12 to 15 minutes, stirring occasionally from the bottom of the pot. The squares are ready when tender through the center, with no raw flour taste. If the broth thickens too quickly, stir in a little hot water or broth.
Finish and season. Return the chicken to the pot and simmer for 5 minutes, until hot throughout. Taste the broth and add salt as needed; the amount depends on the broth you use. Remove the pot from the heat and stir in parsley, if using. Let the pot pie stand for 5 minutes so the broth settles and thickens slightly, then serve hot.

Tips

Keep the dough on the firm side. The noodle dough should be sturdy enough to roll and lift. If it crumbles and will not come together, add milk 1 teaspoon (5 ml) at a time. If it sticks to the counter, dust with flour lightly rather than adding a large amount; too much extra flour can make the broth pasty.
Use a gentle simmer. A rolling boil can break up the potatoes and make the dough squares ragged. Stir carefully, especially after adding the noodles, and scrape the bottom of the pot so they do not stick.
Choose broth with its salt level in mind. Low-sodium broth gives you more control over seasoning. If using regular broth, begin with less added salt and adjust after the chicken and noodles are cooked.
Short on time? Store-bought wide egg noodles can stand in for homemade squares. Add the package amount needed for six servings and cook according to its directions; the texture will be smoother and the broth less rustic. Add them after the potatoes are nearly tender.

Serving Suggestions

Serve Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie in wide, warm bowls, making sure each portion gets plenty of chicken, potato, noodles, and broth. Because it is a substantial one-pot meal, a simple side is usually enough. Try buttered green beans, steamed peas, or a crisp salad with a tangy vinaigrette to balance the rich broth. Pickled beets or chow-chow, a sweet-and-sour vegetable relish served in parts of Pennsylvania Dutch country, are traditional-style accompaniments that add a bright contrast.

Set out black pepper, chopped parsley, and extra salt at the table so each person can season their bowl. If serving bread, choose a modest portion of crusty bread or a soft dinner roll for dipping rather than another heavy side. The broth thickens as it sits, so serve soon after the short finishing rest for a more spoonable consistency.

Variations

There are family and regional versions of Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie, and the name can be confusing: this version is a broth-based dish with square noodles, rather than a baked pie with a top crust. Some cooks make the dough with just flour, eggs, and salt; the small amount of milk here makes it easier to bring together. For a more old-fashioned, chewy noodle, omit the milk and add a teaspoon or two of water only if the dough will not form.

For extra vegetables, add 1 cup (130 g) sliced carrots with the potatoes, or stir in 1 cup (150 g) frozen peas during the final 5 minutes. Carrots add sweetness and peas soften quickly, so avoid adding either too early. If you want a stronger herb note, add 1 teaspoon (1 g) dried thyme to the broth; this is a flavor variation rather than a requirement.

Bone-in chicken thighs give the broth body and stay moist during simmering. Boneless thighs can be used, but begin checking them after about 20 minutes because they cook faster; remove them once they reach 165°F (74°C), then add them back at the end. Chicken breast is another option, although it can be less tender if overcooked. For a meat-free adaptation, use vegetable broth and omit the chicken, adding extra potatoes and mushrooms; it will be a different, lighter dish rather than the classic chicken version.

Storage and Reheating

Cool leftovers promptly and refrigerate them within 2 hours in a covered, shallow container. The pot pie keeps for 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. The noodles continue to absorb broth as they stand, so the next day the dish may be thicker; that is normal. For longer storage, freeze portions in airtight, freezer-safe containers for up to 2 months. The potatoes and noodles can soften after thawing, but the dish remains suitable for reheating.

Reheat a portion in a saucepan over medium-low heat, stirring gently and adding a splash of broth or water to loosen it. Heat until steaming throughout and to 165°F (74°C), checking with a food thermometer. A microwave also works: cover loosely, heat in short intervals, and stir between intervals so the center heats evenly. Reheat only the amount you plan to eat, since repeated cooling and warming can further soften the noodles.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie the same as chicken pie?

Not in this regional style. Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie is cooked on the stovetop in broth, with square pieces of homemade dough and often potatoes. A conventional chicken pie is usually baked with a pastry crust. The shared name reflects different dishes, so look for the noodle-style description when you want this recipe.

Can I make the noodle dough ahead?

Yes. Wrap the dough tightly and refrigerate it for up to 24 hours. Let it sit at room temperature for about 15 minutes before rolling, so it is easier to work with. You can also roll and cut the squares a few hours ahead; dust them lightly with flour, arrange them in a single layer, cover, and refrigerate until ready to cook.

Can I use leftover cooked chicken?

Yes, though it will not flavor the broth as deeply as simmering bone-in chicken. Simmer the broth with the onion, celery, bay leaf, and peppercorns for about 20 minutes, then remove the aromatics and cook the potatoes and noodles as directed. Stir in about 3 cups (420 g) shredded cooked chicken for the final 5 minutes, heating it thoroughly.

Why are my noodles tough or gummy?

Thickly rolled dough takes longer to cook and can stay dense in the middle, while a hard boil or too much stirring can tear the squares and release excess flour. Roll the dough to about ⅛ inch (3 mm), keep the broth at a steady simmer, and stir gently. If the dough is gummy after the stated cooking time, simmer it a few minutes longer and check a square before serving.

Can I prepare the whole dish in advance?

It is best cooked close to serving because the noodles keep absorbing broth. For easier planning, make the dough squares and simmer the chicken a day ahead, then refrigerate them separately in covered containers. Reheat the broth, cook the potatoes and noodles, and add the chicken near the end. This keeps the noodle texture closer to freshly made than storing the fully assembled pot pie.

More recipes to cook

Safety notes: safe minimum internal temperatures from USDA FSIS; raw and undercooked fish guidance from the U.S. FDA. Food safety notes

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it (corrections policy).